The Stanley Cup final no one asked for might still be pretty good

Sure, they killed the dream of an all-Canadian showdown, but there's a lot to like in the NHL championship series between Vegas and Florida.

It's no Oilers-Leafs, but there's a lot to like in Vegas vs. Florida

Vegas Golden Knights player William Karlsson celebrates a goal with teammates while skating by his bench.
William Karlsson and the self-branded Misfits have helped Vegas reach its second Cup final in six years of existence. (Ethan Miller/Getty Images)

This is an excerpt from The Buzzer, which is CBC Sports' daily email newsletter. Stay up to speed on what's happening in sports by subscribing here.

It wasn't supposed to end like this.

Less than a month ago, everything was falling into place for an all-Canadian Stanley Cup final. With defending champion Colorado and title favourite Boston both suffering shocking first-round upsets, Edmonton and Toronto were suddenly the betting favourites to win their conferences.

Imagine that? Either the Maple Leafs would bust their ghosts by winning their first Cup in 56 years, or an Oilers championship parade would double as Connor McDavid's coronation as the rightful successor to the Great One. Either way, it would end Canada's 30-year Stanley Cup drought and bring the best trophy in sports back to a place with tradition, where hockey really matters.

Instead, the Florida Panthers and Vegas Golden Knights punctured the all-Canadian dream by bouncing Toronto and Edmonton in the second round, and now they're meeting in something like the opposite of a Leafs-Oilers final. Rather than those blue-blood franchises playing for Lord Stanley's Cup, we get an all-Sun Belt matchup featuring a No. 8 seed from the hockey-indifferent Miami metro area vs. the NHL embodiment of nouveau riche, right down to the gaudy gold uniforms.

Having said that, Florida and Vegas are worthy finalists, and this is a compelling matchup that will result in one of them hoisting the Cup for the first time in franchise history. Canadian hockey snobbery aside, that's pretty nice.

Here's a look at both teams ahead of Game 1 of the final Saturday night on the Las Vegas strip.


Unlike their Canadian counterparts, Golden Knights fans do not know suffering. Their team has been in existence for just six seasons, and this is already its second trip to the Cup final. Vegas made one of the most improbable playoff runs in sports history in 2018 when it reached the championship series as a first-year expansion franchise before losing to Alex Ovechkin's Capitals.

Several players remain from that team, which branded itself the "Golden Misfits" in defiance of the clubs that exiled them to the desert via trade or the expansion draft. The two most important holdovers to this year's playoff run are forwards William Karlsson (tied for second in the league with 10 goals in 17 games) and Jonathan Marchessault (tied for seventh in points with 17, including nine goals). Forward Reilly Smith has 11 points, and defenceman Shea Theodore ranks second on the team in ice time.

While the remaining Misfits are a good story, this Vegas team is better than that plucky 2018 squad because the front office is not afraid to gamble on star players. Talented centre Jack Eichel (team-high 18 points in the playoffs) needed back surgery when the Knights traded for him in November 2021 after a bitter falling out with Buffalo. Elite two-way winger Mark Stone (15 points) wanted a big new contract when Vegas plucked him from Ottawa at the 2019 trade deadline. Go-to defenceman Alex Pietrangelo commanded a massive seven-year, $61.6 million US free-agent deal in 2020 when he left St. Louis.

After missing the playoffs for the first time in the (brief) history of the franchise last year, this newer, shinier version of the Golden Knights posted the best record in the Western Conference before dispatching Winnipeg in five games and Edmonton and Dallas in six. The wagering odds for the final imply Vegas has about a 53 per cent chance of winning the Cup and seeing those big bets pay off.


A 47 per cent chance of winning the Cup? That's all gravy for the Panthers. Before the playoffs, betting markets gave the team with the worst record among the 16 qualifiers a less than 1-in-30 shot of hoisting the trophy and only about a 1-in-4 hope of even advancing past the first round.

Florida would have confirmed pretty much everyone's expectations and bowed out easily to Boston had Brad Marchand buried his breakaway try in the dying seconds of Game 5. But Sergei Bobrovsky kicked it out with his right pad, Matthew Tkachuk scored in overtime to stave off elimination, and the Panthers have never looked back. They beat the Presidents' Trophy-winning Bruins in OT again in Game 7 to pull off one of the biggest upsets in NHL history, then shocked Toronto in five with another pair of sudden-death wins before sweeping favoured Carolina with four one-goal victories — including, yep, two in OT.

Including their 6-0 record in overtime, the Panthers are 9-1 in one-goal games in the playoffs. That's reminiscent of the last Canadian team to win the Cup, the 1993 Montreal Canadiens, who won 10 straight OT games.

The Conn Smythe Trophy winner in '93 was Patrick Roy, and Florida has its own red-hot goalie in Sergei Bobrovsky. The two-time Vezina winner lost his starting job late in the season, but he got in back during the Boston series before stonewalling Toronto and then posting a sparkling 1.12 goals-against average and .966 save percentage vs. Carolina.

And what can you say about Matthew Tkachuk that jilted Flames fans haven't already? In his first playoffs since forcing a trade from Calgary, the skilled and scrappy forward has scored three OT winners and racked up 21 points (second-most in the league) in 16 games.

Florida is just the third team in NHL history to eliminate three of the top four clubs in the overall standings. Vegas finished fifth. So, in a way, a Stanley Cup victory would be the least surprising part of this incredible Panthers run.

Add some “good” to your morning and evening.

A variety of newsletters you'll love, delivered straight to you.

Sign up now