Canadian men's soccer needs more than just Alphonso Davies to be relevant

If Canada's men’s national soccer team hopes to become a meaningful player on the international stage, it can’t just be Alphonso Davies carrying the burden. Fortunately for Canadian soccer fans and executives alike, there's hope that some other promising youngsters will emerge.

Head coach John Herdman relishes potential of ‘exciting’ squad

Canada's Alphonso Davies, front, won't be alone in the men's national team's quest for soccer relevancy, with players like Jonathan David already making an impact. (Nathan Denette/Canadian Press)

The rapid rise of Alphonso Davies has brought renewed attention to Canada's men's soccer program, and the soon-to-be 18-year-old appears to be living up to the hype.

Even as Davies prepares for a highly anticipated move to Bayern Munich, the midfielder has been a productive member of the national team during CONCACAF Nations League qualifying.

But, if the men's national team hopes to become a relevant player on the international stage, it can't just be Davies carrying the burden. Fortunately for Canadian soccer fans and executives alike, he's not alone.

"Everyone is going to be critical in this journey to take us where we want to get to," head coach John Herdman said. "Everyone is going to have a big part to play and they're going to have to bring everything they've got to do something that hasn't been done in over 30-something years."

Watch Herdman discuss unlocking Davies' potential:

How, as a coach, do you unlock the potential of a young player like Alphonso Davies?

4 years ago
Duration 2:26
Coach John Herdman touches on the potential and future evolution of young phenom Alphonso Davies.

Only one current member of the men's team — Atiba Hutchinson — was alive the last time Canada competed in a men's FIFA World Cup, in 1986. That amount of waiting can turn impatience into ambivalence, something Herdman hopes his charges can change with a spot in the 2022 tournament.

"There's a spirit there, there's a team spirit where I think people are excited there's competition, and it's driving players to put a shift in in training," said Herdman, emphasizing the roles of both his young players and veterans alike, including new captain Scott Arfield.

Some of the younger players beyond Davies are already carving out reputations for themselves. Cyle Larin made waves during his brief Major League Soccer career as a member of Orlando City before joining Turkish club Besiktas, while Jonathan David and Lucas Cavallini ply their trade with Belgium's Gent and Mexico's Puebla, respectively. All three have scored three goals in Canada's two Nations League matches.

Watch Herdman describe the environment within the national team:

How are the veterans and critical mass of young players jelling?

4 years ago
Duration 2:12
Men's National team coach John Herdman explains how the mix of rookies and veterans on the National team are working together to foster a fresh team culture.

An 8-0 drubbing of the U.S. Virgin Islands in September, followed by a recent 5-0 win over Dominica are excellent opportunities for a revitalized team to show its potential. With that said, Herdman knows stiffer challenges lie ahead —especially for his defence.

"This tournament, and the way it's formatted, [our] defenders aren't necessarily going to get tested at the level that we need them tested to fully understand what they're going to contribute when we come up against those Tier 1 and Tier 2 teams in CONCACAF," Herdman said.

"Defensively, I'm not really going to get an understanding until we start coming up against those tougher opponents. It's like anything, you can't really test it until the test comes."

Building a cohesive culture

Herdman's résumé is well-documented: the 43-year-old Englishman helmed the Canadian women's soccer team to consecutive Olympic bronze medals as well as gold at the 2011 Pan American Games before taking over the men's team.

Herdman says the experiences of the last quadrennial leading up to the Rio 2016 Olympics helped shape his approach to the four-year stretch leading up to the next World Cup.

"The one thing I haven't changed is my approach. It's very consistent," Herdman said. "People have said 'so what have you changed? What have you adapted? The guys won't sit for a meeting, you can't do this.'

"I think we've proved a lot of people wrong. They guys are buying into the same culture the women bought into to bring them success."

Watch Herdman on the influence of his previous job:

What parallels can you draw between coaching the women's and men's teams?

4 years ago
Duration 2:20
John Herdman on keeping consistent in his coaching style after leaving the women's National team and becoming the men's coach.

That includes showing footage from the women's team during video sessions with the men.

"I think it was positive," he said. "I mean, some guys maybe had the wall up a bit, like 'hey, what are you doing showing us [this]?' But I think it's been positive.

"What they're seeing is a level of tactical IQ and a level of tactical excellence in big moments in front of 60,000 people in big games where you can actually see there's a level of team cohesion here, an attacking team cohesion that these guys have been yearning for, from what I can see."

Next steps

So what comes next for Canada?

The team has two matches remaining in CONCACAF Nations League qualifying — against St. Kitts and Nevis on Nov. 18 and French Guiana on Mar. 26, 2019 — with Davies' move to Bavaria in between.

As the fight to earn a spot in the 2019 CONCACAF Gold Cup continues, one certainty Herdman will have going forward is the commitment of goalkeeper Alessandro Busti and midfielder Ballou Tabla.

Busti, who's spent most of his life in Italy and is a member of Juventus U23, confirmed his allegiance to his birth country with a start against Dominica. Tabla, who began his career with the Montreal Impact and now plays for Barcelona B, only recently committed to Team Canada after reportedly considering playing for Cô​te d'Ivoire.

Watch Herdman talk about the addition of Tabla:

What does the addition of Tabla bring to the team?

4 years ago
Duration 0:59
Men's National team coach John Herdman speaks to the benefits of adding Ballou Jean-Yves Tabla to the roster.

"I think people have been waiting with bated breath, those who had a chance to see him playing in Montreal breaking into the MLS," Herdman said of Tabla, remarking on the 19-year-old's one-on-one ability and "flair."

"I think for most people there's a sigh of relief and then there's an excitement to actually see this young man play."

Herdman is confident in the pieces he has, and in a sport where 11-person cohesion is vital, he'll need them all to be in sync.

"There's so many good players in this group, all with different attributes and different qualities," Herdman said, "Some players will add more on the pitch with their individual brilliance, other players will add more off the pitch with their leadership. And even saying that, some of the players, the young players, will start to add more off the pitch than they ever added before.

"I think it's a really exciting group."


Benjamin Blum is a producer with based in Toronto. He has also worked as a senior writer with, covering an array of international and domestic issues, and was a member of the CBC Sports digital team with a particular focus on rugby. He holds a master's of journalism from the University of King's College in Halifax. You can contact him at


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?