2015 World Cup: Women drop artificial turf complaint

The human rights complaint over artificial turf at the Women's World Cup is over. A group of elite women's players has withdrawn the complaint from the Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario, saying it is time to put the support of soccer first.

Lawyer says protest did accomplish some of its goals

U.S. forward Abby Wambach was part of a group of elite women's players that filed a complaint to the Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario over the use of artificial turf for the 2015 World Cup event in Canada. (Philipp Schmidli/Getty Images)

The turf war is over, with a group of elite women's players withdrawing its human rights complaint over artificial turf at this summer's Women's World Cup in Canada.

The women did not exit quietly, however. Their lawyer slammed FIFA and the Canadian Soccer Association, saying both governing bodies had behaved badly in the face of the challenge before the Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario.

Lawyer Hampton Dellinger accused the soccer authorities of threatening players with suspension, delaying legal tactics and rejecting the players' "undeniably fair settlement offer."

"In the face of such irresponsible actions by FIFA and CSA, the players have elected to end their legal fight," Dellinger said in a statement Wednesday. "The players are doing what FIFA and CSA have proven incapable of — putting the sport of soccer first."

The women also said their challenge had made a difference.

Tatjana Haenni, FIFA's head of women's competitions, acknowledged last Friday in Philadelphia that some of the artificial surfaces at the tournament may have to replaced.

"We know that Vancouver is an issue," Haenni said of B.C. Place Stadium, which will host the World Cup final among other games.

Haenni also said that the time for dissent was over, that the women should focus their attention on the field in the knowledge that a successful tournament would be good for women's soccer around the globe.

In reacting to Wednesday's announcement, FIFA secretary general Jerome Valcke said the sport's governing body had worked hard with players and technical staff "to address their concerns and doubts."

"What was very clear from the meetings with the players was their desire and enthusiasm about making this the greatest FIFA Women's World Cup ever, and to ensure that they have the best possible conditions to perform well." he said in a statement. "This is a goal they share with FIFA and we are totally committed to providing the best possible surface to enable everyone to enjoy a great footballing spectacle.

"We — the participating teams and the organizers — can now all focus on the preparation and promotion of the biggest event in women's football this June in Canada."

The CSA also welcomed the news.

"We are pleased to be moving beyond this discussion, so we can continue to focus on delivering the best FIFA Women's World Cup ever in partnership with our FIFA colleagues and stakeholders from coast to coast," association president Victor Montagliani said in a statement.

Turf protest drew attention

The turf protest drew the attention of big names on and off the playing field. Actor Tom Hanks and NBA stars Kobe Bryant and Kevin Durant — with more than 24 million Twitter followers between them — tweeted their support for real grass.

Dellinger, who like his fellow lawyers represented the women for free, pointed to other victories by the rebel faction.

"The players' united, international effort to protest discrimination has had a positive impact," he said. "The deplorable artificial surface at B.C. Place, the site of the final, will be replaced. Goal-line technology will be used for the first time in a Women's World Cup and we know that the 2019 World Cup will be held on grass. Moreover, the players and their supporters have highlighted continuing gender inequity in sports and lessened the chance that such wrongdoing will occur in the future.

"FIFA and CSA, on the other hand, will fail to host a discrimination-free tournament. They have embarrassed themselves and provided further grounds for reformers to challenge their current leadership."

The World Cup is scheduled to run June 6 to July 5 in Moncton, Montreal, Ottawa, Winnipeg, Edmonton and Vancouver.

The women had argued that making them play on artificial turf was discriminatory when the men play their showcase tournament on grass.

Turf will not be an issue at the 2019 women's tournament. France and South Korea, the two countries bidding to host, both plan to play on grass.

"On behalf of the players, I want to thank all who aided our fight for natural grass fields at the 2015 World Cup including our volunteer lawyers from Canada and the United States," said U.S. star forward Abby Wambach, whose name was front and centre on the human rights challenge.

"Our legal action has ended. But I am hopeful that the players' willingness to contest the unequal playing fields — and the tremendous public support we received during the effort — marks the start of even greater activism to ensure fair treatment when it comes to women's sports."

Canadian players were not part of the human rights challenge. They were left out since the CSA doubles as the tournament's national organizing committee.

The women may have failed in their legal battle, but it can be argued they won the battle for public opinion even if FIFA rules clearly permit the use of sanctioned artificial turf.

FIFA looked intransigent while the CSA offered little in response. And Valcke's commitment for an "open dialogue" looked empty when he refused to talk to players over the phone or to go to Brazil to talk in person during a tournament that featured stars like Wambach and Brazil's Marta.

He eventually met with a group of players before the recent Ballon d'Or announcement.

"In the end, despite the challenges created by the sexism, greed, and stubbornness endemic to FIFA and CSA, the players will make the 2015 Women's World Cup a success," Dellinger said with one final parting shot. "The on-field skill, courage, and determination the players will display will redeem the tournament from the ineptitude and ingratitude of its organizers. I hope fans around the world will join me in following and supporting these amazing athletes as they compete across Canada this June and July."


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?