U of T scholars ask Sport Minister for review of Own The Podium

Three University of Toronto sport scholars are asking Canada's sport minister to take a look at Own The Podium's mandate amid mounting allegations of athlete maltreatment.

Letter states medals-first mandate puts pressure to prioritize results over health

In recent weeks, more than 70 current and retired gymnasts, with the number growing to over 300, penned a letter asking for an independent investigation into their sport in Canada. (Nathan Denette/The Canadian Press)

Three University of Toronto sport scholars are asking Canada's sport minister to take a look at Own The Podium's mandate amid mounting allegations of athlete maltreatment.

In a letter to Sport Minister Pascale St-Onge, Bruce Kidd, Peter Donnelly and Gretchen Kerr said that OTP has a medals-first mandate that puts pressure on national sport organizations to prioritize top results over health and safety.

"What began as a carrot has turned out to be a stick," the letter said. "We believe that the ultimate measure for the success of the Canadian sports system should not be medals, but the health and wellbeing of athletes, and the quality and quantity of the opportunities we provide Canadians in sports, both at the highest levels and at the grassroots."

Kidd, Donnelly and Kerr joined a growing chorus of voices for sweeping changes in Canada's sport system after recent accusations of maltreatment in a number of sports.

St-Onge held an emergency roundtable meeting last week in Ottawa, telling The Canadian Press that since she was appointed Sport Minister almost six months ago, more than eight national sport organizations have faced accusations of everything from sexual abuse to misappropriation of funds.

St-Onge vowed to accelerate the opening date of an independent complaint mechanism through the Sport Dispute Resolution Centre of Canada, and on Tuesday former artistic swimmer Sarah-Eve Pelletier was named as Canada's first sport integrity commissioner. On Thursday, the federal government announced $16 million for Pelletier's office allocated over three years.

More than 70 current and retired gymnasts — the number has grown to over 300 — wrote to Sport Canada last week asking for an independent investigation into their sport in Canada.

Under the Twitter handle @Gym4ChangeCan, they said Thursday that they'd spoken with the Sport Minister's office this week "and are encouraged by these discussions. We look forward to meeting again in the near future about the next steps to make gymnastics safe for all."

OTP, meanwhile, was established to help the Canadian team top the medal standings at the 2010 Vancouver Winter Olympics, and recommends how much federal funding each sport receives. CEO Anne Merklinger said, however, there's been a shift in mandate in recent years to a more "values-based approach" to sporting excellence.

"While the initial focus was primarily on medals, over the last four to five years, we've worked very hard to ensure that essentially how Canada's athletes achieve success on the international stage is as important as the results themselves," Merklinger told The Canadian Press. "It's not just about reaching performance goals, but how you achieve those goals in a supportive culture of excellence that is safe for all to enjoy the journey. We've been working very hard on that."

Merklinger pointed to Maggie Mac Neil's recent news she won't compete in individual events at the world championships. The Olympic swim champion said the pressure had been affecting her mental health. She told CBC that "[Swimming Canada] definitely have been thinking of us as a person first which is so important. I'm grateful for that."

"There are many of those examples," Merklinger said. "We can always be better, and everyone is working hard together to be better, including Own The Podium."

WATCH | Canadian gymnasts demand investigation into abusive practices, toxic culture:

Canadian gymnasts demand investigation into abusive practices, toxic culture

4 months ago
Duration 2:04
Dozens of Canadian gymnasts have signed an open letter calling for an independent investigation into an ongoing toxic culture and abusive practices at Gymnastics Canada. The way elite sports are funded based on performance is part of the problem, according to one expert who studies abuse in sports.

Suggestions in handling issue

Among their suggestions to Sport Canada, Kidd, Donnelly and Kerr said athlete representatives should constitute a minimum of 30 per cent of national sport and multi-sport organizations, as "they know better than anyone what they need to succeed and stay healthy."

They suggest a completely independent review of the funding framework, including incentives set out by Sport Canada and OTP.

And thirdly, they recommend an independent study of the requirements needed for a cultural change to prioritize athletes' rights, health and wellbeing.

"Healthy, happy athletes also win medals, and go on to live healthy, fulfilling lives without the physical and mental damage we're hearing athletes speak about now," they wrote.

Merklinger said four national sport organizations, in consultation with their athletes, will soon be participating in a pilot project of a new tool that is "that stresses a balanced approach to people and performance.

"Experts have developed this tool, not OTP," she said. "So, we believe it will be of significant value for the system. Our focus as an organization is to really provide tools for national sport organizations to strengthen their own culture."

In recent weeks, dozens of Canadian bobsled and skeleton athletes wrote an open letter calling for the resignation of their NSO's acting CEO and high performance director amid what they called a toxic culture. The gymnasts followed with a similar letter to Sport Canada a month later, asking for a third-party investigation.

Add some “good” to your morning and evening.

A variety of newsletters you'll love, delivered straight to you.

Sign up now


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?