NWHL holds door open in bid to thaw relationship with PWHPA

NWHL commissioner Tyler Tumminia is leaving the door open should members of the Professional Women's Hockey Players' Association ever want to reach out to the National Women's Hockey League in a bid to thaw what has been a chilly relationship.

Commissioner Tyler Tumminia said she is willing to listen

NWHL Commissioner Tyler Tumminia says she doesn't believe the NWHL's and the PWHPA's objectives in growing women's hockey are all that different. (Maddie Meyer/Getty Images)

Tyler Tumminia is leaving the door open should members of the Professional Women's Hockey Players' Association ever want to reach out to the National Women's Hockey League in a bid to thaw what has been a chilly relationship.

The NWHL's first-year commissioner said she is willing to listen, and doesn't believe the two sides' objectives in growing the sport are all that different

"I don't think the door's ever been closed here," Tumminia told The Associated Press this week in announcing the NWHL's decision to double its salary cap to $300,000 US for each of its six teams entering its seventh season.

"I'm always going to think about the future, and salary cap increases and ownership coming in and infusing cash dollars that were needed in order to show growth and progress," she added. "It's all along the same lines the PWHPA is looking for as well."

The PWHPA was formed two years ago in a large part because a majority of North America's top players balked at joining the U.S.-based NWHL following the demise of the Canadian Women's Hockey League.

Skeptical of the NWHL's economic model, especially after the league slashed salaries nearly in half a month into its second season in 2016, the PWHPA members instead sought a fresh start. Their objective was to form a new league — preferably with the NHL's backing — and featuring a sustainable economic model in which players would be fairly compensated in wages and benefits.

Whether the NWHL's boost in pay is enough to begin a conversation is uncertain.

PWHPA executive Jayna Hefford favourably greeted the development.

"It's great to see that the league is making positive steps towards supporting their athletes better financially," Hefford wrote in a text to AP. "That is the direction this game and its players — now and future — deserve."

PWHPA member and former Canadian national team goalie Shannon Szabados was skeptical.

"Until I see a league in North America that I would want my daughter to play in, my stance with the PWHPA remains united to create a better opportunity for future generations," Szabados wrote in a text.

The PWHPA has often cited how private start-up leagues such as the NWHL have a poor track record of success once investors' money runs dry.

Aside from the cut in salaries in which many players believe they are owed back pay, the NWHL was questioned for having an unknown number of business partners whose commitment to long-term sustainability was uncertain.

The NWHL is now operating under a revamped executive structure under Tumminia and a newly established board of governors, with league founder Dani Rylan Kearney out of the picture.

Rylan Kearney stepped down as commissioner last fall and has since resigned her role overseeing the NWHL's four teams controlled by W Hockey Partners: The New Jersey-based Metropolitan Riveters, Connecticut Whale, Minnesota Whitecaps and Buffalo Beauts.

The NWHL power structure also features Miles Arnone, who is chairman of the defending champion Boston Pride, and also has a stake in BTM Partners, which operates the Toronto Six and is behind an expansion bid to establish a team in Montreal in 2022-23.

Arnone, managing partner for Cannon Capital investment firm, said he's always been open to having discussions with the PWHPA and added: "We'd love to see some reconciliation."

The PWHPA has spent the past two years holding a series of barn-storming weekend tours across the North America, many of them backed by NHL franchises. The PWHPA features five hub cities (two in the U.S. and three in Canada) where players have access to practice rinks and facilities and is backed by sponsors including Secret, Budweiser and adidas.

The NWHL cites major marketing agreements it reached over the past two years, including one with Discover, that provided enough cost certainty to increase the salary cap even though the league has yet to reach profitability.

The test for both should come this year, with national team members preparing for the 2022 Beijing Games. The PWHPA's non-national team members could consider the NWHL.

Arnone said the decision to increase the salary cap had little to do with the PWHPA, though he acknowledged the possibility of that happening.

"There's some point where that would happen. I don't know whether this is at that point or not," Arnone added. "Obviously, if some of them want to consider playing in our league, and do that, it would be wonderful, too."

Add some “good” to your morning and evening.

A variety of newsletters you'll love, delivered straight to you.

Sign up now


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?