NHL preview: Steady as she goes as Shanaplan rules Leafs land

The Toronto Maple Leafs made huge strides last season, but a continued move forward is all that's needed to be considered a winning season.

It's not about 1 Stanley Cup, but many Cups, that drives the calculated development of their young stars

If all goes according to plan, Auston Matthews will be the face of the Maple Leafs franchise for years to come. (Nathan Denette/Canadian Press)

This is part two of our series of season previews for the seven Canadian-based NHL teams.

See also: Edmonton Oilers, Ottawa Senators, Montreal Canadiens, Calgary Flames, Winnipeg Jets.

Toronto Maple Leafs

2016-17 record: 40-27-15 (95 points), 4th of 8 in Atlantic Division, eliminated by Washington in 6 games in 1st round of playoffs.

Key off-season additions:  F Patrick Marleau, F Dominic Moore, D Ron Hainsey. 

Key off-season subtractions:  F Brooks Laich, F Brian Boyle, D Matt Hunwick.

Probability of winning the Cup*: 6.7%

Probability of making playoffs*:  68%

*derived from betting odds posted by Bodog

Last season's story

From opening night, when No. 1 pick Auston Matthews scored an NHL-record four goals against the Ottawa Senators, to a six-game loss to Washington in the opening round of the playoffs, the 2016-17 season was one that defied the managed expectations of the Maple Leafs' front office. Matthews' 69 points (40 goals, 29 assists) led the team and earned him a Calder Trophy as the league's top rookie, which only served to overshadow the achievements of fellow rookies Mitch Marner (19-42-61) and William Nylander (22-39-61), as well as a maturing Nazem Kadri (32-29-61). At fifth in goals scored (250), the offence wasn't a problem, but the defence (242 GA, 22nd) showed it still needs developing. Frederik Andersen (33-16-14 in 66 starts) proved the team's faith in him as a No. 1 when they signed him to a five-year, $25-million deal. Perhaps most impressive about the team's turnaround from its last-place showing the season prior was the playoff performance against top-seed Washington, pushing the Capitals to six games, five of which went to overtime.

Auston Matthews sets NHL record with 4-goal debut

6 years ago
Duration 0:21
Maple Leafs forward Auston Matthews set a new NHL record on Wednesday night by scoring four goals in his first regular season game, becoming the first player in league history to do so.

The off-season

With such a young team, the Leafs went "old" in their acquisitions, signing free agents Patrick Marleau (38 years old), Ron Hainsey (36) and Dominic Moore (37). The Leafs are being deliberate in the development of their valuable young assets and while the veteran trio is not expected to be around if and when the team wins a Stanley Cup, their influence is considered vital to the ultimate goal. Perhaps the biggest move, though, was the seven-year deal the Leafs gave 25-year-old D Nikita Zaitsev.

And because it's Toronto, there could not be a summer without some juicy headlines, and the Joffrey Lupul is-he-or-isn't-he healthy provided that fodder. So they had that going for them. Which is nice.

The Leafs are counting on the professional mentorship of Patrick Marleau to help the young team. (Frank Gunn/Canadian Press)

Dream scenario

In the cold, calculated strategy of Brendan Shanahan-Lou Lamoriello-Mike Babcock, their young charges continue their apprenticeship under the guidance of the sage veterans, learning to play the game the "right" way. On defence, Zaitsev merges with Morgan Rielly and Jake Gardiner to form the nucleus of a future contender, while Andersen provides the kind of goaltending that covers up inevitable "youthful" mistakes so the team's confidence continues to grow. And off the ice, management would love it if the championship-starved fan-base can wait at least one more year before demanding a Stanley Cup.

Lou Lamoriello, left, and Brendan Shanahan have a plan, darn it, and they are sticking to it. (Bruce Bennett/Getty Images)

Nightmare scenario

Where to start? It's Toronto so it doesn't take much. Worst-case would be significant injuries to any of Matthews-Marner-Nylander that puts their development on hold. James van Reimsdyk and Tyler Bozak, the backbone of the offence prior to the kids' arrival, are both UFAs next summer and any backsliding by the youngsters might make the organization's decision on that pair more difficult. (And keep in mind the Leafs will be looking to lock up Matthews to a mega deal next summer, and most likely Nylander and Marner as well.) If Andersen falters, it shakes the faith that he's their guy for the remaining four years of his deal, and if Rielly doesn't make the next step it again forces management's hand on finding a solution. Babcock famously promised pain when he arrived in 2015, but let's face it, after last season everyone thinks the worst of it is behind them. To go backward, in any form, is not part of the Shanaplan.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?