Chicago NHL team hires outside firm to investigate sex assault allegations
Former player, college student file lawsuits against Original Six franchise
Chicago's NHL team hired a former federal prosecutor to conduct an independent review of allegations that a former player was sexually assaulted by a then-assistant coach in 2010.
CEO Danny Wirtz announced the move in an internal memo Monday that was confirmed by a person familiar with the decision who spoke to The Associated Press on condition of anonymity because of the sensitivity of the situation.
"An experienced team of professionals, led by former federal prosecutor Reid Schar of the law firm of Jenner & Block LLP, has been retained and is currently conducting an independent review of these allegations," Wirtz said in the memo obtained by the AP after it was first reported by The Athletic. "Mr. Schar and his firm have significant experience conducting independent investigative reviews, have no previous ties to the [Chicago NHL] organization, and have been directed to follow the facts wherever they lead."
Speaking before Game 1 of the Stanley Cup Final, NHL Commissioner Gary Bettman said the league learned "relatively recently" of the allegations. It was informed of the accusations by the team's general counsel.
"We'll await the results of the investigation and then decide what if anything needs to be done from our standpoint," Bettman said.
Bettman declined to say whether the result of the firm's investigation should be made public, preferring to wait for its completion to address that issue. Asked about possible punishment handed down by the league, Bettman said all options are available.
"I think we need to wait and see what the result of the investigation and the litigation that seems to be pending as well," he said.
The investigation into one of the NHL's most high-profile franchises comes after the filing of two lawsuits against the team. The first alleges sexual assault by former assistant coach Bradley Aldrich during the team's run to the 2010 Stanley Cup title, and the second was filed by a former student whom Aldrich was convicted of assaulting in Michigan.
"We take the allegations described in these lawsuits very seriously," Wirtz said in his memo. "They in no way reflect this organization's culture or values."
A former player said Aldrich assaulted him, and that the team did nothing after he informed an employee. The lawsuit, filed on May 7 in Cook County Circuit Court, alleges Aldrich also assaulted another unidentified Chicago NHL player. The former player who sued and is seeking more than $150,000 in damages is referred in the document as "John Doe."
The eight-page lawsuit says Aldrich, then a video coach for Chicago, "turned on porn and began to masturbate in front of" the player without his consent. It says Aldrich also threatened to "physically, financially and emotionally" hurt the player if he "did not engage in sexual activity" with him.
Team didn't report allegations, ex-skills coach says
According to TSN, two Chicago players told then-skills coach Paul Vincent in May 2010 of inappropriate behaviour by Aldrich. Vincent said he asked mental skills coach James Gary to follow up with the players and management.
Vincent was called into a meeting with then-team President John McDonough, general manager Stan Bowman, hockey executive Al MacIsaac and Gary the next day. He said he asked the team to report the allegations to Chicago police, and the request was denied.
In an email to the AP, Vincent said he stands by everything he said to TSN. An attorney for Aldrich told Chicago public radio station WBEZ that his client denies the allegations in the lawsuit. In a May statement to the radio station, the organization said the allegations directed at it were groundless.
After leaving Chicago, Aldrich was convicted in 2013 in Michigan of fourth-degree criminal sexual conduct involving a student and is now on that state's registry of sex offenders, WBEZ reported in a series of stories based on legal filings, police records and interviews.
The former student whom Aldrich was convicted of assaulting filed a separate lawsuit against the Chicago NHL team on May 26, saying the organization provided positive references to future employers of Aldrich despite allegations from at least one player and took no action to report the matter.
That suit says the student was a hockey player at Houghton High School near Hancock in 2013 when Aldrich sexually assaulted him at an end-of-season gathering.
Houghton police records say an investigator reached out to the franchise about Aldrich, but human resources executive Marie Sutera would confirm only that he was once an employee. She requested a search warrant or subpoena for any further information regarding Aldrich.
Susan Loggans, an attorney who represents the former player and student, said she welcomed the decision by the Chicago NHL team to launch an independent review.
"They've denied this all along, including to me before I ever filed suit, so I'm happy that they're at least going this far," she said.
Miami University in Ohio also has opened an investigation. Aldrich was director of hockey operations at the school after leaving Chicago but resigned in 2012 "under suspicion of unwanted touching of a male adult," the university's attorney told police, according to WBEZ.