DO NOT USE

Brad Gushue fall prompts curling safety concerns

Whether a helmet would have protected Brad Gushue when he crashed face-first on the curling ice Saturday is debatable. But the sight of one of the world's best curlers sporting a swollen right eye and stitches brings up the issue of whether protective headgear should be mandatory in the sport.

Head protection, safety part of Curling Canada's concussion strategy

Skip Brad Gushue was sent to hospital on Saturday afternoon after losing his footing and slipping on the ice, landing on his head. 1:19

Whether a helmet would have protected Brad Gushue when he crashed face-first on the curling ice last week is debatable.

But the sight of one of the world's best curlers sporting a swollen right eye and stitches after a fall brings to a boil what was the simmering issue of whether protective headgear should be mandatory in the sport, and at what age.

Gushue put his arms out to stop his dive in Saturday's quarter-final of The Masters in Truro, N.S., but not fast enough to protect his face. The skip from St. John's, N.L., returned to the rink and finished out that game after getting stitches at a nearby hospital.

This happened at a time when some curling clubs require junior curlers to wear helmets, senior curlers are voluntarily donning head protection and Curling Canada is developing head-protection recommendations as part of a concussion strategy.

Equipment manufacturers now produce stylish curling tuques and hats with protective padding in them. An early alternative to the helmet was a cushioned, donut-shaped "halo" worn around the head.

But don't expect to see helmets or head protection at the national men's or women's curling championships in the near future.

Resistance from viewing public

Not only would there would be resistance from teams at the Tim Hortons Brier and the Scotties Tournament of Hearts, but the viewing public wouldn't like it.

Brad Gushue, holding a towel to his forehead, is tended to after falling on the ice during the Masters Grand Slam of Curling quarter-finals on Saturday in Truro, N.S. Gushue received stitches in his eyebrow at a nearby hospital and returned to finish the match. (Anil Mungal/Canadian Press)

Those watching on television are accustomed to close-up and unfettered sight lines of curlers' heads and facial expressions.

"You should see the e-mails we get every year about guys wearing baseball caps on the ice," said Danny Lamoureux, Curling Canada's director of championship services and club development. "People are furious."

As with hockey helmets and visors, safety equipment becomes mandatory at grassroots levels before it ever becomes the rule at the elite level.

It's currently up to each curling club to set rules on helmets and head protection, but Curling Canada intends to make the issue part of a concussion strategy to be unveiled in 2016.

Federal government mandate

"The federal government has mandated all sports organizations to have a concussion policy and a return to play policy," Lamoureux explained Monday.

"Most of our injuries don't happen at the high level. They happen at the recreational level. We're in the process now of developing a concussion policy and a return-to-play policy for concussions which will reach right down to the club level. With that, we are going to come up with a helmet policy that they can follow."

Curling clubs aren't franchises of Curling Canada, but voluntary members. Clubs aren't required to adhere to the organization's recommendations, but headgear is now a burning issue at the learn-to-curl stage.

"We're getting lots of calls from people who say 'we need someone to tell us what to do,"' Lamoureux said. "They're having internal fights. One parent doesn't want their kids to wear helmets and the other parent won't let their kids play if the kids don't wear helmets."

​Six-time Canadian champion Colleen Jones said among the many challenges in curling, staying on your feet is one of them.

"Almost every curler has had a fall," she said. "I have seen first-hand blood on the ice and it is not a good thing. Brad's fall was totally, totally flukey, but they're all flukey."

Jones completely supports junior and senior curlers wearing head protection, but expects it could be years before it becomes standard at the Brier or the Scotties.

"It's not going to happen any time soon, but incidents like what happened to Brad definitely make you wonder," she said.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.