Sports

Positive COVID-19 tests unavoidable, leagues must aim to contain potential outbreaks

Infectious disease expert Dr. Isaac Bogoch explains why athletes testing positive don't yet have him worried about sport coming back during the pandemic.

Infectious disease expert says stringent testing should help identify cases quickly

Locked gates at the entrance of TD Ballpark, spring training home of the Toronto Blue Jays in Dunedin, Fla. Toronto is among multiple MLB franchises to close its training facilities due to COVID-19. (Carlos Osorio/The Associated Press)

As sport leagues inch closer to a pandemic comeback, many athletes are making headlines for testing positive for COVID-19.

Four tennis players tested positive at a tournament hosted by Novak Djokovic, leading them to cancel an event final. MLB teams have closed training facilities after multiple teams reported cases. A handful of NFL franchises have been struck as well.

But there's nothing to be worried about. At least, not yet.

"At some point, between all the leagues and all the testing that's going to happen, someone's going to test positive," said Dr. Issac Bogoch, an infectious disease specialist at Toronto General Hospital. "That's not going to be a surprise."

In fact, expect to see more positive cases. With athletes heading back to competition and training camps after living by their own rules — some in more high-risk areas than others — it's unrealistic to expect suggested self-isolation protocols will be universally followed.

That's why many leagues and tournament outlines are designed around tracing the positive cases to keep them from spreading.

WATCH | Pro leagues plan return despite growing COVID-19 rates:

As professional sports leagues plot their return to action, CBC News' Cameron MacIntosh details the recent spike in the number of athletes who have contracted COVID-19. 2:43

On the other hand, Dr. Bogoch is keeping an eye on what happens once athletes are back to their routines.

"What would be unnerving would be to see if there's sustained transmission within a bubble despite all these measures taken to prevent that," he said. "That would be concerning."

No perfect plans

Dr. Bogoch is impressed by the plans he's seen from leagues like the NBA and NHL, which put together hundred-page proposals to form bubbles in order to keep athletes and staff safe while re-opening. 

But in situations like these, there's no such thing as a completely sealed bubble.

"There's going to be some hole, however tiny. There are going to be some holes in any bubble for any sport in any location," he said.

So the key is to watch how fast each league and tournament is able to shut down the cases that do occur.

"If does get in, it can't get very far because there's diagnostic testing, physical distancing, hand sanitation," he said. "We get there's athletes that are going to be close to each other, but hopefully with the surveillance systems in place and the testing people will get identified really quickly and not contribute to transmission in the bubble.

"If there are these stringent measures and these bubbles are in place and people are getting infected in spite of all these protective layers, then yeah, we got a problem."

WATCH | Federal government approves NHL resumption plan:

Deputy Prime Minister Chrystia Freeland on Friday confirmed the federal government has approved the NHL's plan to return to play in Canada. 6:47

That being said, in Bogoch's opinion, it won't be as simple as a high number of cases that determines whether a league's plan is working or whether it should admit defeat against the virus.

"It's not going to be a hard number you're going to set and go 'Ok, after we have a blank number of cases we've got to shut it down.'" he said. "It's going to be a value judgment and basically look at the number of people involved and the extent to which there's involvement. Like, 'is it just one team or is it multiple teams or multiple people that are separated by time and space but still in the bubble?'

"These are things that will be taken into consideration I think."

Florida the test vehicle

And some leagues have proven in the right environment — with the right plan — sport can safely happen during the pandemic. The Korean Baseball Organization has successfully run its season since early May without any major roadblocks. The Premier League and Bundesliga have kept their seasons going despite some positive cases. And Spain's national basketball league is in the middle of a successful centralized, condensed tournament to crown a champion.

But leagues like the NBA, WNBA and MLS which plan to start their seasons next month in Florida will be putting their plans to the ultimate test. The state set a single-day record last week with just over 4,000 new cases, making the state the new hot spot in the U.S.

"Despite the best laid plans, if you're going to be putting players in a bubble in an area where there's a significant amount of disease transmission, you still may introduce the disease into the bubble," Dr. Bogoch said. "And you have to be very careful to adhere to the measures in place to make sure there's no further transmissions."

About the Author

Jacqueline Doorey is a digital host and producer for CBCSports.ca

Add some “good” to your morning and evening.

A variety of newsletters you'll love, delivered straight to you.

Sign up now

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

now