John Scott's 7-game ban ends wild first month in NHL | Hockey | CBC Sports

Inside the Game

Hockey Night in CanadaJohn Scott's 7-game ban ends wild first month in NHL

Posted: Thursday, October 31, 2013 | 06:26 PM

Back to accessibility links
Boston Bruins sniper Loui Eriksson is drilled by Buffalo Sabres forward John Scott in a hit for which Scott was banned seven games on Thursday. (Kevin Hoffman/USA TODAY Sports/Reuters) Boston Bruins sniper Loui Eriksson is drilled by Buffalo Sabres forward John Scott in a hit for which Scott was banned seven games on Thursday. (Kevin Hoffman/USA TODAY Sports/Reuters)

Beginning of Story Content

The amount of suspensions are halfway to last year's totals for the lockout-shortened season, the number of games players have been suspended for have almost already matched last year's total and the salary forfeited already has surpassed last season.
The stretcher has seen more ice time in NHL rinks in the first month of the season than Buffalo Sabres fourth-liner John Scott.

Right from opening night, when Montreal Canadiens pugilist George Parros awkwardly toppled over Colton Orr of the Toronto Maple Leafs in a fight and Parros hit his chin on the ice to the latest incident that saw Detroit Red Wings defenceman Niklas Kronwall get carted off a couple of weeks ago.

Sure, teams are taking more precautionary measures when a player suffers a head or neck injury than in the past, and not all of the scary incidents have been the result of goon tactics.

Players like St. Louis Blues forward Max Lapierre deserved his five-game suspension for his hit-from-behind on San Jose Sharks defenceman Dan Boyle. But when Jacob Trouba crashed into the boards face first, the young Winnipeg Jets blue-liner accidentally got tangled up with Blues defenceman Jordan Leopold before his fall.

Even Kronwall shared the blame in his incident, in which Colorado Avalanche forward Cody McLeod was hit with a five-game ban.

"I could have done a lot of things differently," Kronwall told reporters upon his return to action. "I shouldn't have put myself in that spot in the first place. He's coming in with a lot of speed, sure, but I did turn at the last second.

"It goes fast out there and it's so easy to go back and slow it down, look at it in slow motion, and be very smart about things. But it's hockey and everything is high pace and it goes fast out there. Guys will make some bad decisions out there sometimes. In my case, I ended up on a stretcher."

Still, Brendan Shanahan and his department of player safety have been busy in the first month. The latest was Scott's seven-game suspension for his head check on Boston Bruins veteran Loui Eriksson.

Even if we count only the suspensions served in the 2013-14 regular season (ignoring suspensions for pre-season games), the total number of suspensions is halfway to last year's total for the lockout-shortened regular season plus the playoffs, the number of games players have been suspended for has almost already matched last year's total, and the salary forfeited already has surpassed last season's total.

Season    Players    Games     Salary Lost   Players Fined   Amount

  • 2011-12      57       204           $2,457,906             35               $87,500
  • 2013          24        64              $714,829                7               $49,376
  • 2013-14     12        60              $899,665                3               $12,243

Unless players exhibit a willingness to curb these senseless acts, the number of suspensions and fine money will soar past the totals of the last two seasons.

Shanahan and his department have been doing everything in their power to educate and deliver stiff punishment. But there are many reasons and theories as to why there appears to be an increase in the first month of the season.

We discussed this matter with several players, scouts and league executives in an off-the-record manner this week to get their honest thoughts. 

  • A common theme to the reasons was the old cliché that the game has never been faster and players are bigger. So collisions will happen and injuries will result.
  • There is so much emphasis on finishing the check. In the 1970s and 1980s, only the player with the puck got hit. "The major injuries usually occur on late hits," said one executive. "If a player gets rid of the puck, he shouldn't be hit. The defensive player has to let up, like on the Scott hit on Eriksson. That's how Raffi Torres got into all his problems. Tell me this, why when a player dumps in a puck and an opponent shields him from getting in on the forecheck a second later the defending player gets called for interference? Yet, when a player hits another play a second after he gets rid of the puck, it's okay?"
  • There is an increasing amount of demand from coaches to their players to be physical.
  • More teams dump and chase rather than rush the puck in. "We call this NZTPI (neutral zone tip-ins). This exposes defending players more, like the Boyle and Kronwall hits."
  • Has the removal of the red (centre) line played a role? Our experts were mixed on this.
  • Players expose themselves more to the big hit. "The guys are taught when you can see an opponent's eye balls, you contain. When you see their numbers, jump the puck. Some players confuse this with driving an opponent into the boards. A lot more players play the game with their backs to opponents because this has become a way to protect the puck."
  • Among our experts, the consensus is that the finish-the-check mentality has to be altered to a let-up-if-the-puck-is-no-longer-there.
It will be interesting to see if this topic is on the agenda for the general manager meetings in Toronto on Nov. 12. It will be interesting to see if the early-season trend continues to keep Shanahan a busy, busy person.

End of Story Content

Back to accessibility links

Story Social Media

End of Story Social Media

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Submission Policy

Note: The CBC does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. By submitting your comments, you acknowledge that CBC has the right to reproduce, broadcast and publicize those comments or any part thereof in any manner whatsoever. Please note that comments are moderated and published according to our submission guidelines.