The Current

This photojournalist faked an entire book to highlight how hard it is to spot misinformation

Award-winning photojournalist Jonas Bendiksen manipulated the images in his recent work, The Book of Veles, intending to be found out.

Jonas Bendiksen intended manipulated images to be caught, but no one noticed

Photojournalist Jonas Bendiksen and one of the images from his book, The Book of Veles (Arnfinn Johnsen)

When photojournalist Jonas Bendiksen released a book about the fake news industry, he got messages from people thanking him for covering such an important issue.

But he says no-one noticed one thing about the book: everything in it was also fake. 

"The whole intention was for people to find this out … the problem is that didn't happen," Bendiksen told The Current's Matt Galloway.

His work, The Book of Veles, is based in a town of the same name in North Macedonia. Veles made international headlines in 2016, as the home of a fake news industry that was pumping out misinformation on websites targeted at U.S. voters mulling over a presidential election.

An image from The Book of Veles, depicting an office used to run fake news websites. (Jonas Bendiksen/Magnum Photos)

Bendiksen wanted to explore how misinformation and disinformation has been developing in the years since, from articles riddled with lies and half-truths, to manipulated images and deepfake videos

So he went to Veles in 2019 and 2020, and took pictures of empty spaces, both outdoors and inside. Back home in Norway, he populated those real images with figures that were completely digital, posed and lit to fit into their previously empty surroundings.

"While the story of what happened in Veles is a true one, all the characters in my photographic documentary are basically a computer game character," he said.

He wanted to find out if "one averagely geeky photographer" could spend some time on YouTube learning the techniques, and then "generate fake characters, a fake storyline, a fake documentary that has no basis in fact."

"I got the sense that if I could actually do this, it would say something frightening about the information landscape that we're headed into," he said.

'Something fishy' in every photo

Bendiksen has not revealed all the specifics of what he did to each image. But he said he added "breadcrumbs" that he thought might raise suspicion in the viewer — things like a bear wandering around town. The introductory text in the book is also created using artificial intelligence, generated from media reports about fake news. Bendiksen didn't write a word of it.

"There's also objects, animals, other things I put into it, so basically every picture in the project has something fishy going on," he told Galloway.

An image from The Book of Veles, depicting an aquapark on the outskirts of the town. (Jonas Bendiksen/Magnum Photos)
Some of the pages from The Book of Veles. The text was generated using artificial intelligence. (GOST Books)
An image from The Book of Veles, depicting the hillsides above the town. (Jonas Bendiksen/Magnum Photos)

"I thought all of that would make people go, 'You know, there's something fishy going on in this work, what is it?' And I wanted to sort of play into that discussion," he said.

But in the weeks after the book was published in May, nobody raised any concerns with Bendiksen.

He decided it was time for one more "stress test," so he submitted it to Visa pour l'Image, a prestigious photojournalism festival that took place in Perpignan, France in September.

Bendiksen wanted to see if the experts noticed: "Could this fake documentary actually be accepted as a real reportage by seasoned editors?"

It turns out that it could. "They immediately accepted it," he said.

Bendiksen's images were viewed by photographers, editors and industry insiders on a large screen.

When no one spotted the deception, he decided to reveal the truth.

In an interview with Wired, the festival's director Jean-François Leroy said his organization had known and trusted Bendiksen for years.

"I think Jonas should have told me it was a fake," he said, adding that if he was in on the secret, they could have revealed it and hosted a discussion as part of the festival's program.

Bendiksen said he's not the type of "person who particularly enjoys going around and scamming people."

But he thinks that what he did was "an important experiment for us telling stories in the journalism and photography communities."

Mass-produced misinformation

While identifying misinformation and disinformation online is already an issue across the world, Bendiksen believes things will only get worse as the technology behind it develops.

"Give it a few years, we will have this whole synthetic layer on top of it, where you will have misinformation not even produced by people, but by machines, and in quite great quantities," he said. 

An image from The Book of Veles, depicting the town at dusk. (Jonas Bendiksen/Magnum Photos)

He thinks there needs to be better education around how to spot manipulated content, perhaps even as part of school curricula.

"How can we make our young, the next generations, better at navigating this very difficult mix of information, to find credible information in this mess?" he said.

He thinks the project has changed his own outlook.

Bendiksen says the project has changed his own outlook, and that from now own he'll view photography, as well as other kinds of stories, with a more critical eye than in the past.

"I see now how easy it is to reproduce fake versions of this," he told Galloway. 

The Book of Veles is available from Gost Books.


Written by Padraig Moran. Produced by Alison Masemann.

Add some “good” to your morning and evening.

A variety of newsletters you'll love, delivered straight to you.

Sign up now

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?

now