A minority within a minority: Quebec's struggle to face racism

As a minority within Canada, Quebec is fiercely protective of its culture — but this leaves other minorities within Quebec itself with nowhere to turn.
Duncan McCue was joined by Haroun Bouazzi, Idil Issa and Lise Ravary to discuss Quebec's special status and how it affects minorities within the province. (Elise Jacob/CBC)
Listen21:59

Read Story Transcript

Secularism in Quebec is "used to mask racism," says a writer based in Montreal.

Idil Issa, a board member of Fondation Paroles de Femmes, points to Bill 62 as an example.

"How is it that in our society we tolerate restricting the rights of these women on the basis of their appearance," she asks, "and then say that this is all about secularism?"

The law was set to prohibit women from wearing face coverings while receiving public services, but was stalled by a judge in December.

"I think what's really going on is that this group is marginalized enough that we feel able to push this through. And nobody is going to be able to do anything about it."

Lise Ravary, a columnist at Le Journal de Montreal, thinks the bill was a political ploy.

"There is probably not even 100 women in Quebec who wear niqab, but it was easy to pick on them, right?" she says.

"But at the same time Bill 62 doesn't say you can't wear your niqab in a public place," she says. "It says that if you are getting a service from the state you have to show your face."

A minority culture that dominates

These tensions around Bill 62 play out against the backdrop of Quebec's special status, as a French-speaking minority within Anglophone Canada.

Living within Quebec, but outside the dominant white, francophone culture, is to live as a minority within a minority.

Haroun Bouazzi explains why it's so hard to talk about race and racism outside the English-French divide - particularly Islamophobia - in Quebec 2:15

Many Quebecers struggle to acknowledge these layers because they are afraid of 'Quebec-bashing', says Haroun Bouazzi, the co-president of the Association of Muslims and Arabs for a Secular Quebec.

"White francophones are both a majority that is privileged in Quebec, and a minority that historically has been racialized based on their culture, on their religion and on their voice," he says.

"They're extremely scared here — if they denounce racism — that it will be used by the rest of Canada to actually racialize us, as Quebecers, saying: 'Obviously it's a culture that is racist.'"

Ravary says that Quebecers can be reluctant to embrace outsiders, because they feel their own culture is under threat.

She also points out that Quebec only started taking control of its own economy and institutions 50 years ago, and that "it's not a long time ago when the people of Quebec saw themselves as being oppressed."

"I'm not saying… 'well it's okay, let's let it go, because it's young,' but I think it does explain why this skittishness, that you will not see maybe elsewhere in Canada, you're going to see in Quebec."

Idil Issa and Lise Ravary disagreed over the language used to discuss racism. (Elise Jacob/CBC)
"The problem was not that people didn't want to talk about racism. The problem was a word 'systemic' that most people did not understand." 1:03

Language of racism

The province had planned a consultation on systemic racism, but after political pushback it was reduced to a one-day forum to discuss jobs and diversity.

Ravary believes the term "systemic" doomed the project from the start.

"The problem was not that people didn't want to talk about racism, the problem was a word — systemic — that most people did not understand."

"They felt it was aimed at them, that Quebec was going to be on trial."

Issa disagrees, arguing that political leaders should be reminding people what these terms mean and why they're important.

"I think when you're dealing with minorities, when the conversation isn't at the stage where you can have a populist impetus for change," she says, "you need to have political leadership — people who are willing to do the right thing."

Listen to the full conversation at the top of this page, where you can also share this article across email, Facebook, Twitter and other platforms.


The Montreal town hall event on race relations in Canada was produced by The Current's Yamri Taddese, Pacinthe Mattar and Ruby Buiza.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.