Should Canada scrap immigration deal with the U.S. over safety concerns?
Safe Third Country Agreement is based on the understanding that both countries are safe for refugees
When Antar Davidson was working at Estrella del Norte — an Arizona shelter for unaccompanied immigrant minors — he was called by a supervisor who needed an interpreter.
The former youth worker arrived to find Brazilian siblings who had been separated from their mother the day before, and had not met anyone who spoke Portuguese in the next 24 hours.
"They were being told in Spanish and English that they now were gonna be each separated and put into a different room," Davidson told The Current's guest host Ioanna Roumeliotis.
- CBC NEWS | Former Walmart now housing boys seeking U.S. entry is crowded and prison-like, reporter says
"They were hugging each other and just weeping, and holding on desperately to each other, and the shift leader goes very aggressively to me: 'Tell them they can't hug, tell them they can't hug.'"
Davidson said the centre had a no-touching policy, just one aspect he found disturbing during the time he worked there. His concerns were so grave that he left his job.
Children are being sent to centres like Estrella del Norte because of the American government's zero-tolerance policy towards migration, which includes treating children accompanied by adults as unaccompanied. The largest, a converted Walmart in Brownsville, Texas, currently houses nearly 1,500 children.
The situation has raised concerns over child welfare, but also Canada's own refugee agreement with the U.S., which insists refugees make their asylum claim in the first country they enter. Under the deal, a migrant travelling through the U.S. to try to enter Canada would be sent back to the U.S. at the Canadian border.
Here are some photos of the boys in the cafeteria. <br><br>This is not a school cafeteria. <br><br>Hundreds called to eat at a time on rotating shifts.<br><br>When I told <a href="https://twitter.com/chrislhayes?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">@chrislhayes</a> it felt like a prison or jail, I was thinking about this. <a href="https://t.co/feZI46SPAc">pic.twitter.com/feZI46SPAc</a>—@jacobsoboroff
The Safe Third Country Agreement is predicated on the understanding that both countries are safe for refugees. If Canada cannot remove migrants to the U.S. without safety concerns, some say, the deal should be scrapped.
To discuss the issue, Roumeliotis was joined by:
- Molly Hennessy-Fiske, national reporter with the Los Angeles Times
- Antar Davidson, former youth worker at Estrella del Norte
- Sean Rehaag, associate professor at Osgoode Hall Law School, York University
Listen to the full conversation near the top of this page.
This segment was produced by The Current's Samira Mohyeddin, Kristian Jebsen and John Chipman.