The Current

Former pilot blasts U.S. authorities for not grounding Boeing 737 after Ethiopian crash

Families and loved ones are mourning the loss of 18 Canadians who died in an Ethiopian Airlines crash on Sunday. We speak look at safety concerns with the Boeing 737 Max 8.

Boeing 737 Max 8 planes involved in two recent crashes that killed everyone on board

The Boeing 737 Max 8, shown here being built for for Ethiopian Airlines at Boeing Co.'s Renton Assembly Plant, is being grounded by some countries following Sunday's deadly Ethiopian Airlines crash. (Ted S. Warren/Associated Press)
Listen19:35

Read Story Transcript

Update, March 13, 2019: Transport Minister Marc Garneau issued a safety notice Wednesday morning, banning the Boeing 737 Max 8 aircraft from entering Canadian airspace until further notice. U.S. President Donald Trump issued an "emergency order" grounding all Boeing 737 Max 8 and Max 9 aircraft a few hours after Canada's decision.

Original story below:


The U.S. Federal Aviation Administration has "dropped the ball" by not grounding the Boeing 737 Max 8 planes involved in two recent fatal crashes, according to a former pilot.

"I think [the FAA is] siding more with the economics of Boeing and air travel and revenue to the airlines than they are to the safety of the passengers," Arthur Rosenberg, an aviation attorney and engineer, told The Current's guest host Piya Chattopadhyay.

After Sunday's Ethiopian Airlines crash that killed 157 people, including 18 Canadians, China, Australia, Singapore, and the EU have all banned the Boeing 737 Max 8 from their airspace.

Transport Minister Marc Garneau said it would be "premature" to ground all 41 of the planes currently owned by the country's air carriers. Canada's two largest airlines, Air Canada and WestJet, have also expressed confidence in the safety of the aircraft.

But given the choice, Rosenberg said he wouldn't fly in a Boeing 737 Max 8.

"The consequence … to the flying public is people now have to make decisions [about] whether they want to fly this plane or not."

A Red Cross teams picks through the debris at the crash site of Ethiopia Airlines near Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, on March 10, 2019. (Michael Tewelde/AFP/Getty Images)

'Identical fingerprint' to Lion Air jet crash

Rosenberg argued that Sunday's crash bears an "identical fingerprint" to the Lion Air plane that crashed in October, killing 189 people. But safety experts have cautioned against drawing too many comparisons between the two crashes until more is known about Sunday's disaster.

Both planes were Boeing 737 MAX 8s, a new plane which went into circulation in 2017.

Rosenberg said the plane's design creates "a tendency to nose up under certain flight conditions, which could become dangerous."

Accordingly, Boeing fitted the planes with a flight-control system — called MCAS, the Manoeuvring Characteristics Augmentation System — to push the nose down, Rosenberg said.

"The problem with this is there is something wrong with the system, it's prone to receiving aberrant information from certain sensors," he said. "It makes the airplane do things that the pilots don't want it to do, it does things to the airplane that pilots can't control."

Rosenberg said that "certainly in the Lion Air crash, the MCAS system, this invisible auto-pilot system, which works behind the scenes out of the sight and ears and senses of the flight crews, is implicated."

While he said a full investigation is needed, "it certainly looks like the same situation is here with the Ethiopian crash."

Indonesian investigators have not determined a cause for the Lion Air crash, but days after the accident, Boeing notified airlines that faulty information from a sensor could cause the plane to automatically point the nose down. The notice reminded pilots of the procedure for handling such a situation.

In November, U.S. pilots said they were not told about the issue prior to the Lion Air crash. Boeing said it did not withhold operating details from airlines and flight crews.

The crash of Ethiopian Flight 302 on March 10 and that of a Lion Air plane in Indonesia in October — both of them Boeing 737 Max 8 jetliners — has prompted Canada, the U.K. and other countries to ground the aircraft. (Boeing)

Following Sunday's crash, Boeing issued a statement saying that the 737 Max 8 is safe, and the company has been developing a flight-control software enhancement, intended to make the plane even safer. The FAA said it anticipates the mandatory software upgrade to be in place by April.

Rosenberg argued that the statement is an "acknowledgment by Boeing that yes, there's something wrong."

"The very fact that they're saying that we are making design changes, we are making changes to training manuals, we have a software upgrade ... is an admission that something is not right with this airplane."

Click 'listen' near the top of the page to hear the full conversation.


Written by Padraig Moran, with files from the Associated Press. Produced by Idella Sturino, Samira Mohyeddin and Jessica Linzey.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.