The Sunday Magazine

Revisiting Sinclair Ross's novel about false fronts and the struggle for authenticity

In Episode 5 of The Backlist, a series about Canadian novels that have fallen out of public memory, host Michael Enright speaks to celebrated Canadian writer Guy Vanderhaeghe about his 1941 novel As For Me and My House.
Celebrated Canadian writer Guy Vanderhaeghe is the recipient of many honours, including the Governor General’s Literary Award and the Order of Canada. He spoke to host Michael Enright about why Sinclair Ross's novel As For Me and My House resonates more than ever today. (Submitted by Guy Vanderhaeghe; Emblem Editions)

Welcome to Episode 5 of The Backlist, a series about Canadian novels that have fallen out of public memory — or never got the attention they deserved in the first place.

We never learn the full name of the woman who narrates Sinclair Ross's 1941 novel As For Me and My House. She is known to us only as Mrs. Bentley, the wife of a minister in a small Saskatchewan town called Horizon.

But we get extraordinary insight into her interior world — the small wounds and tensions that define her suffocating marriage, and her hunger for a bigger, freer life.

In her diary, she writes, "Three little false-fronted towns before this one have taught me to erect a false front of my own, live my own life, keep myself intact."

"I think that everyone bears a false front," writer Guy Vanderhaeghe told The Sunday Edition's host Michael Enright. "I think, for me, the novel is about the struggle that almost every human being has — and that's to be himself or herself."

Novel more relevant than ever

Vanderhaeghe believes the novel's exploration of the struggle to live an authentic life is more relevant than ever today.

"In the 1930s, and in a small Saskatchewan town, the constraints of religious piety, of conventional behaviour — that was the outside struggle that [the characters] have to make," he said.

"I sometimes think that, in the present world that we live in, given social media, Horizon, Sask., is in fact that whole social global media [world] out there, that constantly judges any individual who might step out of line."

Ross spent most of his life in the closet, and his sexual orientation became public knowledge after his death.

I'm assuming that his entire life was a struggle to achieve his being, his own authenticity.- Guy  Vanderhaeghe

"For me to imagine being either gay or bisexual, or having any preferences that were considered at that time perverse or sinful … [that] would have been an incredible burden to bear," said Vanderhaeghe.

"I'm not saying that Sinclair Ross wrote a novel to moralize about anything. I'm assuming that his entire life was a struggle to achieve his being, his own authenticity.

"And these characters carry that burden, of him working his way through the strictures that were of his own time, but the strictures that continue for all of us."

Ross's own mother dismissed his work

As For Me and My House got a cold reception when it was first published.

For much of his life, Ross viewed himself as a literary failure — once telling a friend that collecting stamps or butterflies would have been more fun than writing.

"Even his own mother dismissed his work. I think at one point she said, 'Why don't you write something somebody wants to read? The only thing you write about is wind and horses,'" Vanderhaeghe said.

But years later, As For Me and My House was hailed as a classic, and praised for its psychological depth and bleak, beautiful descriptions of prairie life.

Vanderhaeghe hopes new readers will take the novel's themes as a challenge.

"I often think that the book is an argument for human beings to actually look at themselves very closely and discover who they are," he said.

Click 'listen' above to hear the interview.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.