Quirks & Quarks

Bird song is unique as well as beautiful — no other animal makes noise this way

According to a new study, the organ that birds use to make vocal sounds is unique in the animal kingdom, raising questions about how it might have evolved.

Move over larynx — meet the syrinx, the unique organ that birds use to make sound

Birds use a unique organ, the syrinx, to produce sounds -- and now researchers wondering how such an organ evolved. (REUTERS/Vasily Fedosenko)
Listen7:52

Most animals make sounds by means of a larynx, a vocal apparatus located high up within the windpipe. But birds vocalize using a completely different structure, the syrinx, located in the chest, near the heart. Now, in a new study, researchers are probing the peculiar evolutionary path that gave rise to it. 

Singing from the heart 

In most land-dwelling vertebrates, sound is produced when air passes through vocal folds within the larynx which is located at the back of the mouth.  In birds, in contrast, sound is made when air passes over soft tissue supported by rings of cartilage in the syrinx which is located much farther down in the chest.

In this study, researchers compared the vocal apparatus of birds to that of crocodiles, salamanders, mice, and cats -- and it appears that the bird mechanism is unique.

Interestingly, birds do in fact have larynxes -- they just don't use them for making sounds. Instead, they use them as a valve to separate breathing and eating. The syrinx seems to be a "new" organ; it did not evolve from the larynx.

A unique organ

"It appears to be a new combination of structures and developmental programs that are implemented deep in the chest," paleontologist Julia Clarke of the University of Texas, Austin, told Quirks & Quarks. "It's kind of bizarre."

The finding has left Clarke and her colleagues puzzling over the question of how the syrinx evolved. Normally, when a new anatomical feature evolves, it's because it fulfills a new purpose or function. But in this case, the syrinx performs a function -- making sound -- that the larynx may have already served. 

"This kind of biological novelty is pretty rare in the history of life -- to have a new structure arising for the same function as a prior structure," Clarke said. 

An evolutionary puzzle

One possibility is that the ancestors of today's birds may have had both kinds of vocal apparatus -- a larynx as well as a syrinx -- working in unison. An alternative scenario is that, at some point, the larynx stopped working in the the ancestors of today's birds, and so the syrinx evolved to restore their sound-making ability. In this second scenario, Clarke explains, there may have been a "quiet zone" in which the ancestors of modern birds were silent.

However, birds evolved from dinosaurs, and what we know about dinosaur anatomy suggests this second scenario is less likely, Clarke says. Other researchers have found that dinosaur hearing evolved and improved over the many millions of years in which the giant creatures roamed the earth -- which suggests that they likely were producing sounds too. 

The research may help to explain why birds have such a wide array of vocal capabilities -- and, more generally, it may help scientists understand how biological innovation occurs. 

The research was published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.