The Doc Project·Personal Essay

My grandma sang her way to Canada at a time when Chinese people were barred entry

Gar Yin Hune travelled with her Cantonese opera troupe when the Chinese Exclusion Act was in place, and never left.

Gar Yin Hune came with her Cantonese opera troupe when the Chinese Exclusion Act was in place, and never left

Producer Julia Hune-Brown's grandmother, Gar Yin Hune. (Submitted by Hune family)
Listen to the full episode28:26

Originally published on December 30, 2019.

My grandmother's immigration story is that of family legends. As a Chinese opera singer, she managed to get into Canada during a 24-year ban on Chinese immigration and make a life for herself and our family. 

Julia Hune-Brown looking at family photos of her grandmother, Gar Yin, with her mother Bernice Hune. (Alastair Brown)

The only time I heard my grandmother sing was when I was eight. Gar Yin Hune, or Jacqueline in Canada, passed away when I was a teenager. 

My memories of her are of a confident senior striding up Spadina Avenue in Toronto's Chinatown, in an oversized 80's sweater and Reebok shoes, pausing every few minutes when people stopped her to chat. 

But my grandmother had another life outside our family circle. She would often come for dinner and then rush off to join her friends at a Cantonese opera club. 

Once I remember waking up at her condo to the sound of her singing along to a VHS tape. As an eight-year-old, I gasped in amazement to hear her voice over the dramatic Chinese music. It felt shocking to my English-speaking ears. 

She smiled at me and turned off the tape. Then, in a mix of Cantonese and English, she told me to get dressed for Egg McMuffins across the street. 

Gar Yin Hune (right) seen here performing in Vancouver. (Opera Vancouver 1938/Yucho Chow)

Opera life in China

Gar Yin Hune was born in 1918 in Guangzhou, a port city in southern China. Her father owned a number of tea houses where Cantonese opera was performed — a mix of music, dance, acrobatics and dramatic costumes. 

Gar Yin Hune learned to read by memorizing opera scores. (City of Toronto Archives, Globe and Mail Fonds 1266, Item 101788)

She had to leave school at a young age after her father refused to pay tuition for his daughter. "So she went to work in the opera company as a performer," my mother and Gar Yin's youngest daughter, Bernice Hune, told me.

Gar Yin was mentored by other female performers. She soon started performing locally and eventually toured in Southeast Asia.

At this time the Chinese Freemasons were sponsoring groups of Opera performers to go perform in Chinatowns across North America.

"They wanted their culture in an art form, but they also wanted to raise money for China to fight the Japanese," explained Shirley Hune, my aunt and Gar Yin's eldest child.

By 1937, the Second Sino-Japanese war had started. "The Japanese were invading China and her mother said to her that 'If you have an opportunity to tour again you must take it. This is an opportunity for you to leave the country,'" said Bernice.

On September 23, 1938, my grandmother left her life and family in China. Her city, Guangzhou, was invaded by Japan just a month later. 

My aunt Shirley and I recently found her immigration card. It was the first time I had seen it and I was amazed to see my grandmothers' determined 19-year-old face fiercely staring at the camera.

Gar Yin Hune's immigration card. (Submitted by the Hune family)

Looking at this, I wonder if she knew what she was getting into coming to Gum San (Gold Mountain), as she called it, or what European settlers called Canada, and to what is known to many Indigenous people as Turtle Island.

Anti-Chinese policies 

My grandmother was arriving to a country that was openly hostile to Chinese people. Right after the Canadian Pacific Railway was completed in 1885 — using Chinese labour — the Canadian government first introduced the Chinese head tax in order to keep "Canada white forever."

It was a large fee exclusively for Chinese people entering the country, an often debilitating debt that men on low wages spent years paying off. 

In 1923, the Chinese Exclusion Act stopped virtually all Chinese immigration until 1947. Officially fewer than 50 Chinese people entered Canada in that time. 

Gar Yin Hune (far right) with other company members after landing in Vancouver in 1938. One wonders if they knew how rare this scene was. (Opera Vancouver 1938)

"You never saw a woman in Chinatown," explained my grandmother's friend, Nora Hum. "They were all men in those days."

The years of the head tax had made the population extremely imbalanced and only seven per cent of the Chinese population were women.

Touring across Canada 

Gar Yin Hune (left) with fellow performers. Their company toured together across Canada, an intense experience that inspired lifelong friendships. (Opera Vancouver 1938)

My grandmother's opera troupe performed in Chinatowns across the country, places like Calgary, Lethbridge, Moose Jaw, Winnipeg, and Montreal.

Nora described how exciting it was when the opera came through Montreal. "The whole community would come. The club was packed and was standing room only," she said.

For the community, the opera was one of the only places that Chinese people could gather and be themselves. Outside of the club, they were living in a society that remained segregated. People didn't leave Chinatown because they felt unwelcome everywhere else.

By the time the tour ended, it was early 1940 and World War II had started. Crossing back across the Pacific Ocean was not a realistic option. My grandmother could stay in Canada for the time being — and she made the most of it. 

Putting down roots in Toronto

My grandmother decided to settle in Toronto, which had a larger Chinatown than other Canadian cities. 

She roomed with a family and eventually met my grandfather, Don Hune, a Canadian-born Chinese man. 

Nora told me that it was my grandmother who did the choosing. "Your grandfather was very caring, hard working and handsome. But she was the queen bee," said Nora.

Gar Yin Hune's husband, Don Hune, owned a grocery and she continued to perform, even as they married and began having children. (Submitted by the Hune family)

They rented a floor in a house just off of Toronto's Chinatown. This was before old Chinatown was expropriated for a new city hall to be built. 

"One day your grandpa came home and said, 'The landlord is going to sell this house [...] I wish I had the money to buy it.' And grandma said, 'I have money, my Cantonese opera money,'" Shirley told me. 

It was her money from performing that helped buy my family's first Toronto home. This was particularly important for security at a time when white landlords often refused to rent to Chinese people. 

Reunification

In 1947, the Chinese Exclusion Act was finally lifted and my grandmother was granted a permanent landing card. This was also the year my mother was born. 

By the 1950's my mom, then a child, was beginning to witness family reunification, as families who had been separated for decades were finally reunited. 

The Hune's celebrate grandmother Gar Yin's 80th birthday. Seen here: Gar Yin (centre), Julia Hune-Brown (second from right), and Shirley Hune (far right). (Submitted by the Hune Family)

As soon as the law changed, my grandparents worked to find ways to bring their family over. Eventually my grandmother brought her mother, her older sister, her younger brother and his young family to Canada. 

"And so actually grandma saved her entire family, through the ticket to come as a Cantonese opera singer," said Shirley.

I like the way Nora says it best: "It takes a lot of courage to leave your own environment to go to a strange country, a language you don't understand, and just hope that you know everything would turn out the way you want it to. But of course when you're young, you feel you can do anything. You know, 'we can conquer the world.' Cantonese opera helped her conquer the world."

Gar Yin Hune performs with Raymond Jai in Toronto during the 1980s. (Submitted by the Hune Family. )

I feel grateful for what this art form has given to my family. But I'm also ashamed at how little I know about it. I have a degree in theatre and I make art in Toronto, helping young minority artists tell their own stories. Yet I know so little about an art intimately tied to the roots of my family. 

Recently, I walked to Dundas Street and ventured up the stairs of a Chinatown building I have passed a million times. I found myself in the Chinese United Dramatic Society, a club Gar Yin would have gone to. Founded in 1933, it is one of the last Cantonese opera clubs operating in Toronto's Chinatown. 

The room was filled with seniors singing Cantonese opera standards to a full band. It was a room buzzing with energy, with tea being passed, loud conversations, and an ancient drummer yelling at the singers to keep up the tempo. And it was the closest I have felt to this opera life my grandmother lived. 

Gar Yin Hune's life was full of music, energy, community, people laughing, yelling, and making art together. This art form allowed our family to make a life in Canada. It felt foreign to me — but also so familiar. 


To hear the documentary, tap or click the Listen link at the top of the page.


About the Producer

(Submitted by Julia Hune Brown)
Julia Hune-Brown is a theatre artist and educator.

She works with diverse communities directing and facilitating theatre projects in her hometown of Toronto and across Canada. Julia is a lead artist with The Amy Project — Artist Mentoring Youth and Jumblies Theatre. She is currently working on an oral history theatre project in Toronto's Spadina Chinatown. Julia also teaches kindergarten and is very good at singing instructions to small people. This is Julia's first radio doc.

This documentary was produced by Alison Cook.

Archival music is from the Collection of Cantonese Opera Records at the Canadian Museum of History

 

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

now