Day 6

What U.S. envoy Elliott Abrams' controversial past signals for Venezuela's future

Elliott Abrams has a decades-long, and highly controversial, history in El Salvador, Guatemala and Nicaragua. Now he's the U.S. State Department's point person on Venezuela.

'Over and over again ... he is the man who has been called on to help overthrow foreign governments'

U.S. Special Representative for Venezuela Elliott Abrams testifies before the House Foreign Affairs subcommittee hearing on Venezuela on Capitol Hill in Washington. (Jose Luis Magana/Associated Press)
Listen8:39

Who is Elliott Abrams?

Elliott Abrams, 71, is a long-time U.S. foreign policy official with a storied — and highly-controversial — career.

He worked for the Reagan administration in the 1980s and the George Bush administration that followed. Abrams also served in the George W. Bush White House as an advisor on Middle East affairs.

Before his 1985 appointment to head of the State Department's Latin America bureau, Abrams headed the State Department's Bureau of Human Rights and Humanitarian Affairs. Harvard-educated, he spent four years working for the U.S. Senate, during which he also wrote about foreign policy. 

Jon Schwarz, a senior writer with The Intercept, told Day 6 Abrams is "kind of one step down from Henry Kissinger in the U.S. foreign policy elite."

In January, the Trump administration appointed him to be special envoy for Venezuela.

Abrams accepted, saying, "This crisis in Venezuela is deep and difficult and dangerous, and I can't wait to get to work on it."

Elliott Abrams, left, listens to Secretary of State Mike Pompeo talk about Venezuela at the State Department in Washington. (Manuel Balce Ceneta/Associated Press)

What is his new role in Venezuela going to be?

Abrams has been tasked with restoring democracy in the country, according to a statement by Secretary of State Michael Pompeo.

Venezuela has been in political turmoil since a contested election in 2017, and there are currently two presidents vying for power.

The Associated Press reported last week that Venezuelan officials say Abrams has had two meetings with Venezuela's foreign minister. According to those officials, the U.S. used those meetings to threaten sanctions and the deployment of troops to oust President Nicolas Maduro, who neither the U.S. nor Canada recognizes as legitimate.

Instead, the governments of Canada, the United States and other countries recognize opposition leader Juan Guaido as the country's lawful leader.

RELATED LINK: Guaido says Venezuela's opposition is 'not going anywhere' in CBC interview

Venezuela's opposition supporters rallied nationwide to keep the heat on embattled President Nicolas Maduro. At the same time, government supporters took to the streets in Caracas and other cities denouncing foreign intervention. Neither side is willing to back down. 4:54

Why are people concerned about Abrams' new job?

Schwarz calls Abrams' appointment "extremely ominous for Venezuela."

That's because Abrams has a history of involvement with rebellions in Latin America and strong public support for dictatorships. Critics like Schwarz have raised three examples: Nicaragua, El Salvador and Guatemala.

In 1991, Abrams pleaded guilty to two misdemeanor counts of illegally withholding information from Congress about secret, unlawful government efforts to aid right-wing Nicaraguan rebels in their fight against the left-wing Sandinista government. Abrams was later pardoned by President George Bush for his role in that scandal, which became known as the Iran-Contra affair.

In a Feb. 13 Foreign Affairs Committee hearing on Venezuela, new member of Congress Ilhan Omar questioned why, given how he lied to Congress in the '80s, the government should trust Abrams now.

She also criticized his 1982 dismissal of the El Mozote massacre, in which nearly 1,000 civilians were killed in an El Salvadorian village by military personnel the U.S. trained and equipped.

At the time, Abrams said reports of the massacre were left-wing propaganda. He has called the Reagan administration's work in El Salvador a "fabulous achievement."

Omar asked Abrams if he thought the massacre was a fabulous achievement and he declined to respond.

Omar also asked Abrams if he would "support an armed faction within Venezuela that engages in war crimes, crimes against humanity or genocide if you believed they were serving U.S. interests, as you did in Guatemala, El Salvador and Nicaragua?"

During Abrams' tenure with the Reagan administration, the U.S. supported Guatemalan General Efraín Ríos Montt — who was convicted of genocide in 2013 — despite knowing he had killed his own people.

Again, Abrams refused to respond.

"Over and over and over again in his career he is the man who has been called on to help overthrow foreign governments. He has always done it under a rhetoric of democracy and human rights," Schwarz said.

"His role was to downplay the unbelievable barbarism, support the people who were carrying out these incredible atrocities trying to make sure that they didn't face the consequences," he added. 

What informs Abrams' thoughts on foreign policy?

People often call Abrams neo-conservative. In the 1990s, he led a Judeo-Christian think tank focused on applying those religious values to foreign policy.

Prior to his 1985 appointment as head of the State Department's Latin America bureau, Abrams reportedly said his worldview was based on the premise that the world was "an exceedingly dangerous place."

He has been avowedly anti-communist, reportedly calling the Soviet Union, "the greatest threat to human rights."

Schwarz said Abram's anti-communist rhetoric bears scrutiny.

"What you have to understand is that from the perspective of people like Abrams, what is communism? Is it erecting a gigantic statue of Joseph Stalin? No, it's not. It's people who say, 'We would like to eat every day. We would like our children not to die from easily preventable diseases.' That to them is communism."

Venezuelan National guards block the road at the border between Venezuela and Brazil in Pacaraima, Roraima state in Brazil. Across the border, at least one person was killed in an apparent clash with security forces on Friday. (Ricardo Moraes/Reuters)

Why would the Trump administration appoint someone with Abrams' record?

Abrams has not always been an ally to President Donald Trump. In 2016, he wrote that Republicans should "not allow the Republican convention to be a coronation wherein Trump and Trumpism are unchallenged." In 2017, Trump blocked Abrams' appointment to Deputy Secretary of State.

Schwarz said the reason for Abram's appointment is simple: he "gets the job done."

"People who run the U.S. government, especially the people from the U.S. right wing, truly do believe that we should, for the good of everyone, run the world. And if you need to run the world, Elliott Abrams is the guy you get."

In a press briefing, Secretary of State Michael Pompeo said "[Abrams'] passion for the rights and liberties of all peoples makes him a perfect fit and a valuable and timely addition."


To hear the full interview with Jon Schwarz, download our podcast or click the 'Listen' button at the top of this page.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.