Stephanie Nolen was reporting on variants in South Africa — then Europe's travel ban sidelined her return
Experts have criticized decisions by governments to hastily close borders in a bid to curb newest variant
After reporting on the scientists working to identify and track coronavirus variants in southern Africa, Canadian journalist Stephanie Nolen found herself caught up in the chaos while leaving South Africa as countries closed their airports to flights from several African countries over the latest variant, omicron.
At some point during her flight from Johannesburg to Amsterdam on Friday, the European Union announced that its countries would suspend entry of travellers from several African countries — including South Africa. When her flight arrived at Amsterdam's Schiphol Airport, passengers were not allowed to deplane.
"I thought, 'Oh, well, this is going to be a good part of my story,' " Nolen, the global health reporter for the New York Times, told Cross Country Checkup on Sunday.
The omicron variant was declared a variant of concern by WHO on Friday. The European Union and other countries, including Canada, quickly responded by imposing travel bans to certain countries in Africa.
It's hard not to see this as South Africa being punished for the fact that it has world-class scientists, doing some of the best Covid surveillance in the world, and is transparent about what they find. <a href="https://t.co/356pkUs7uX">https://t.co/356pkUs7uX</a>—@snolen
The omicron variant has already been identified in several countries, including Canada. Two cases of the coronavirus variant were confirmed in Ottawa late Sunday. Many uncertainties remain about just how transmissible the variant is, and how severe an infection it might cause.
Experts have criticized decisions by governments to hastily close borders in a bid to curb the newest variant's spread.
"The key here to understand is the virus that … South African scientists have measured just in the last week probably was circulating for quite a while," said Dr. Prabhat Jha, professor of global health at the University of Toronto and an epidemiologist at St. Michael's Hospital in Toronto, on Checkup.
"I think the correct strategy is not to punish the countries, particularly South Africa, that have been so good in reporting their data so quickly, but rather we should adopt very vigorous testing and quarantine approaches for visitors from those countries."
No food, water on tarmac
Nolen was aware the latest variant was already making waves before her departure from Johannesburg. At that point, her flight was clear to take off.
After landing in Amsterdam, she said flight attendants told passengers that they would "do something different" — another round of COVID-19 tests. Nolen said she had already tested negative the day before departure, and 72 hours before that.
WATCH | Stephanie Nolen shares what happened after landing in Amsterdam:
Nolen said she and her fellow travellers spent more than five hours marooned on the tarmac at Schiphol — without anything to eat or drink.
"It was when the captain came on and said, 'We'd like to get you some food and water, but we can't because they won't let catering approach the plane' that one started to be a little bit anxious," she recalled.
A statement from GGD Kennemerland, a regional Dutch health authority, said while they understand the frustration among passengers, they were confronted with an unprecedented situation.
Cases of omicron variant detected on 2 flights
Five hours in, a bus arrived to transport the weary travellers to a cordoned-off airport terminal where all passengers were swabbed, Nolen said. She and others waited an additional nine hours for the test results, ending up packed into a tight line to have them delivered verbally.
By then, it had been nearly 24 hours since they departed Johannesburg. Many of her fellow travellers were not wearing masks, she said.
"I basically feel like I've been dipped and rolled in COVID," Nolen said.
Citing Dutch health authorities, Reuters reported that 61 passengers who arrived in Amsterdam from South Africa on two different flights — including Nolen's — on Friday tested positive for COVID-19. On Sunday, officials confirmed 13 of the cases were caused by the omicron variant.
I saw the best of humans, in South Africa's scientists and community public health workers, last week. And the worst, at Schiphol. It's difficult to reconcile the two.—@snolen
Cleared for departure, Nolen continued her journey, landing in Nova Scotia on Saturday night.
While sitting on the tarmac of Schiphol airport, the reporter documented her ordeal for the Times.
"Someday, I may appreciate the irony in this situation," she wrote, adding she had plenty of time to review research shared with her by scientists in South Africa.
Written by Jason Vermes with files from Reuters and Ashley Fraser.
To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.
By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.
Become a CBC Account Holder
Join the conversation Create account
Already have an account?