Truth, dialogue & storytelling: Patti Laboucane-Benson on art and healing

Author Patti LaBoucane-Benson teamed up with a graphic novelist to share the story of gang violence and healing in Edmonton, Alta. She gives her take on art and reconciliation on the Checkup blog.
Author Patti LaBoucane-Benson teamed up with an illustrator to share the story of gang-violence and healing for Indigenous people in a graphic novel called, The Outside Circle. (Illustrated by Kelly Mellings.)

Edmonton author Patti LaBoucane-Benson wrote the graphic novel The Outside Circle in collaboration with illustrator Kelly Mellings. It's the story of gang life and healing for Indigenous people. She weighs in on this week's Cross Country Checkup question: Does art offer the best path to heal historical wrongs?

Ten years ago, if someone would have told me that a graphic novel about the healing story of a gang-affiliated, Indigenous man from Edmonton's inner-city would be a Canadian bestseller, I would have laughed. Yeah right.

For decades, advocates have been working — sometimes pleading, other times demanding — that our prison system respect and embrace Indigenous healing as a pillar of rehabilitation. But nothing changed.

I poured my efforts into doctoral research, focused on healing historic trauma to find that simply put – healing works. But the truth is, academics talking in coded, inaccessible language to other academics have yet to make any difference.

I was desperate to find a way to reach a broader Canadian public... to make offender healing matter.

I was desperate to find a way to reach a broader Canadian public... to make offender healing matter.  Reading Chester Brown's graphic novel Louis Riel changed everything.

In an act of pure rebellion – and desire to work on a project that would make my heart sing – I turned my sights on a graphic novel. I asked local artist Kelly Mellings, Greg Miller and Allen Benson to work with me, to include the findings of my research and to tell a story of historic trauma healing: The Outside Circle.

My goal in this project was to tell the truth — not to sensationalize gang activity, but to help Canadians understand what drives young Indigenous men into prison, feel the gut-wrenching process of healing and believe that change is possible.

Mellings produced inspired illustrations, in part due to his undeniable talent, but also because he participated in ceremony, visited a residential school where he spoke with the survivors, and toured a federal prison.

The characters are composites of many men, women and families; The Outside Circle is essentially an homage to the irrefutable courage and resilience of Indigenous men who have taken the In Search of Your Warrior program and have never returned to prison. Men who are doing their best to be good brothers, sons, fathers, grandfathers and uncles — to stop the intergenerational transmission of historic trauma.

That Canadians have embraced The Outside Circle still blows my mind. I love that I've introduced readers to their first (literary) graphic novel and I hope it's not their last. Graphic novels can be a powerful combination of story and art that evokes strong emotion — they "hit you right in the feels," and it's hard to forget those stories.

It makes sense that Gord Downie and Jeff Lemire have collaborated to tell the story of Chanie Wenjack as a graphic novel and animated video; they will be powerful resources for teaching young Canadians our collective history, and the legacy of residential schools.

Cover of The Outside Circle. (Illustrated by Kelly Mellings.)
Even though The Outside Circle has had broad appeal to audiences across Canada, talking with young people is hands-down my favourite outcome of its success. 

On a trip to a northern Alberta town, I was thrilled to meet a group of Grade 10 boys – described as resistant readers – who had devoured The Outside Circle in language arts class. They knew the story inside and out, and asked by far the most difficult questions I've ever had to field. They seemed to intimately understand the characters of Pete and his brother Joey, and I did my best to focus on the transformational and redemptive aspects of the story.

I fought back tears when I saw the art projects the teachers had assigned displayed on the wall - students had drawn masks of their own pain - and their own journey. I returned home that weekend, my heart filled with gratitude that the House of Anansi Press has so enthusiastically promoted this graphic novel, that Mellings had spent two year illustrating this story, and that something I've worked on has engaged both Indigenous and non-Indigenous people, created hope and a space for conversation. 

I remain convinced that truth (evidence), dialogue (connectedness) and story-telling (art) are the most important tools in our collective reconciliation journey.

You can share your perspective on art and healing in the Cross Country Checkup conversation. Live on CBC Radio this afternoon, and always on our social media pages. Twitter | Facebook


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?