As It Happens

Retired Mountie lauds Toronto police for bringing in van attack suspect alive

A retired RCMP officer is commending the way Toronto police officers handled the suspect in a deadly van attack on Monday.

'They deserve to be commended because they demonstrated a lot of restraint,' says Garry Clement

"Kill me," the man can be heard yelling as Toronto police arrested him 1:13

Read Story Transcript 

A retired RCMP officer is commending the way Toronto police officers handled the suspect in a deadly van attack on Monday.

Ten people died and 14 others were injured when the driver of a van mounted his vehicle on a sidewalk along a stretch of one of Toronto's busiest streets — striking several pedestrians. The driver fled and was arrested after a brief confrontation with police.

Dramatic footage of the arrest shows the man yelling "shoot me", as an armed officer approaches him and commands him to "get down." The officer manages to subdue him and handcuff the suspect.

The suspect has been identified as Alek Minassian, a 25-year-old from Richmond Hill, Ont.

Garry Clement, a former RCMP superintendent and the current CEO of the Clement Advisory Group, spoke with As It Happens host Carol Off about how police responded to the deadly attack.

Here is part of that conversation. 

What was your initial reaction to the reports of this van attack in north Toronto?

Probably like most Canadians — shock, extreme disappointment.

It's a type of thing that we hope we're immune from, but I've said for a long time Canada was not immune.

You've seen the videos. There's social media videos of the arrest, of the actual man in the van that is suspected of doing the attack. Can you just describe what you can see in those videos?

The police, I think, did a commendable job of getting him to get down so that they could take control of him.

Other than almost surrendering when he was forced to, it appeared almost [like] a sense of calm on the part of the individual, which does not give the indication of somebody being unbalanced.

Former RCMP Superintendent Garry Clement says police in Toronto did a 'commendable' job bringing down the suspect in Monday's deadly van attack. (CBC)

It's difficult to hear in the videos that have been posted, but ... he seems to be trying to get the officer to shoot him, and the officer won't shoot him.

That's suicide by cop. You've heard the expression before. And that kind of was the impression that he gave me is he wanted to be shot by the police.

The way that it was handled by the police officers, they deserve to be commended because they demonstrated a lot of restraint.

All the victims and families are going to go through terrible turmoil, but at least now ... they have enough information to ascertain if this is, you know, a lone wolf or if he's involved in something else. And that's essential.

It's very interesting what you're saying here, because what we're seeing here and what you'd expect would happen — perhaps [in] an American city — is that they would have shot him.

Yeah, and I kind of sense from the conversation in the way that happened, the officer did a great job of reading the individual's body language.

Obviously, it shows the level of maturity and calm of the officer. Because you're correct — I think in a lot of circumstances, the individual would have been shot.

So it's good to see. I think police officers so often don't get the recognition they deserve. But it shows that overall the training is really good and most officers react in an appropriate manner.

Written by Sheena Goodyear with files from CBC News. Interview produced by Imogen Birchard.