As It Happens

San Francisco couple gets parking ticket after city paints a red zone around their car

Desiree and Jeff Jolly were fined $108 US for parking in a red zone, a no-parking space marked by a line of red paint on the curb.

City says the spot was always zoned for no-parking, but the red paint had faded

Two photos side by side. On the left, a close-up of a car's tire, slightly turned and partially covering the curb. A line of bright red paint on the curb visibly cuts around the tire. On the right, a picture of the same scene, but from father away, shows the car parked alongside the incomplete red stripe.
When a couple parked their car at their usual spot in San Francisco, the curb was gray. When they returned, it was freshly painted red, except for a small spot around their tire, and they had been issued a $108 US parking ticket. (Submitted by Jeff Jolly)

When Jeff Jolly saw the parking ticket on his car, he thought it must be some kind of joke.

He'd been fined $108 US ($138 Cdn) for parking in a red zone, a no-parking space marked by a line of red paint on the curb. But when his wife Desiree originally parked their car at their usual spot, there was no red paint there.

In fact, it was clear to the couple that the city had painted the line while their car was parked, as the paint actually cuts around one of their tires.

"It was just odd. You know, we thought it was a prank or something," Jeff Jolly told As It Happens guest host Helen Mann. "I said … this can't be right."

But sure enough, the ticket is the real deal. The city, however, argues the spot has always been a red zone, and the paint job was, in fact, a re-paint job.

The San Francisco Municipal Transportation Authority said in an email to CBC that the city recently repainted the curb in response to a service request. 

A photo, provided by the city, shows the curb before the touch-up, which appears to show some very faded red paint.

A car parked next to a mostly gray curb with some small flecks of visible, but faded, red paint.
This undated image, provided by the city, of the curb before it was repainted shows signs of faded red paint. (San Francisco Municipal Transportation Authority)

Jolly insists he and his wife have been using that same spot for 25 years and have never noticed any red paint or any signs indicating a red zone. As working musicians, he says they have learned to always pay close attention to parking rules.

"In this city, you know to look where you park," he said. "There's no way you would possibly miss that."

ABC7 News, which first reported this story, compared the city's photo to Google Image pictures of the street corner in 2011 and 2016, both of which show a curb that appears completely grey, suggesting the red paint job had long faded.

A black and white photo of a man and a woman sitting side by side on bar stools. The man is playing guitar and the woman is sitting in front of a microphone.
Jeff and Desiree Jolly are San Francisco musicians, and they say they have learned from doing gigs at various venues to pay close attention to street parking signage. (Submitted by Jeff Jolly)

The Jollys have officially contested the fine, and the city says their protest is pending an official review.

"For this particular case, as the curb was already a red zone but faded, the citations clerk conducting the review would evaluate the state of the previous red zone paint," spokesperson Erica Kato said in an email. "If it was significantly faded and unenforceable then it would not be considered a factor in the review."

Kato says the city will respond to the couple's complaint within 60 days. 

"We'll probably have to pay the ticket and see if we get reimbursed. But we're not even going to do that. We're just going to see what happens because it's just so ridiculous," Jolly said.

"I really didn't think it was going to go this far. You know, I really thought they were just going to say ... we made a mistake and just reverse the ticket because it's obvious just by the picture."

Jolly says he and his wife have been considering leaving the Bay Area for a myriad of reasons, including crime and the rising cost of living. They're thinking of moving to southern France where they often travel to play music. This ticket debacle just might be the last straw, he said. 

Asked if he thinks they paint their streets any better in France, he chuckled and replied: "I doubt it."


Written by Sheena Goodyear. Interview produced by Aloysius Wong.

Add some “good” to your morning and evening.

A variety of newsletters you'll love, delivered straight to you.

Sign up now

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?

now