As It Happens

This assistant principal says he was fired for reading kids a book called I Need a New Butt

Toby Price never imagined he’d be fired for reading a book.

Toby Price read the humorous children’s book to a Grade 2 class over Zoom

Toby Price, former assistant principal at Gary Road Elementary School in Hinds County, Miss., is pictured reading one of his favourite children's books, I Need A New Butt. (Submitted by Toby Price)

Story Transcript

Toby Price never imagined he'd be fired for reading a book.

The Mississippi assistant principal has been let go after he read the humorous children's book I Need a New Butt to a Grade 2 class over Zoom.

"It never crossed my mind that reading a book would be something that I would be terminated for. Never, ever could I fathom this," Price, who has been an educator for more than 20 years, told As It Happens guest host Gillian Findlay.

"It came way out of left field."

It all started on March 1 when a group of second graders at Gary Road Elementary school in Byrum, Miss., logged onto Zoom for a reading, but the guest who had been booked to read didn't show up. 

"So my boss texted me and told me to read, so I grabbed one of my favourites that was nearby," Price said.

'No ifs, ands, or butts about it'

The book in question — I Need a New Butt written by Dawn McMillan and illustrated by Ross Kinnaird is targeted at children ages four to 10. It follows the story of a boy who notices the crack in his butt for the first time, and mistakenly believes it must be broken, so he decides he needs a new one.

"Will he choose an armour-plated butt? A rocket butt? A robot butt? Find out in this quirky tale of a tail, which features hilarious rhymes and delightful illustrations," reads a description from the book's publisher. "Children and parents will love this book — no ifs, ands, or butts about it!"

The kids did indeed love it, says Price.

"You could see the smiles on their faces and afterwards, you know, they were coming up to me and telling me, 'Hey, Mr. Price. The book was really funny. Thank you for reading it to us,'" he said.

I Need A New Butt is part of a series of books written by Dawn McMillan and illustrated by Ross Kinnaird. Others include: I Broke My Butt and My Butt Is So Noisy. (Dover Publications)

But his bosses didn't feel the same way. 

He says he was called into the superintendent's office later that day and given a stern talking-to, after which he was asked to resign. 

"I called my wife, and my wife told me, 'You know, if you sign that resignation, it's almost like you're walking away saying that they were right and you were wrong. And you weren't wrong,'" he said.

"So I stood up and put my chin up, sucked in all my tears and walked out of the building to let them know I was leaving and I would not be resigning, and got in my car and cried all the way home."

Two days later, he was terminated. 

You've got to show them that books can be fun and silly and engaging.- Toby Price, fired teacher 

In Price's termination letter, Hinds County Schools Superintendent Delesicia Martin cited "unnecessary embarrassment, a lack of professionalism and impaired judgment" on Price's part in picking the book.

The letter, shared in full by the free speech literary organization PEN America, notes that Price violated the school's code of conduct by using "inappropriate" words like "fart."

The school did not respond to a request for comment from As It Happens. 

Price, meanwhile, stands by his selection. As far as he's aware, no students or parents lodged complaints about the reading. 

"I know my audience, you know, second-grade reluctant readers," he said. "You've got to show them that books can be fun and silly and engaging. You know, you want them to put down their phone and pick up a book."

Now Price says he's left wondering how he will care for his three children, two of whom have autism.

"This is not just a road bump for us. This is, you know, two flat tires and we're stuck on the side of the road," he said.

Since the news broke about his firing, Price says he's received a ton of support, including from his former students and their parents. Several children's book authors and free speech organizations have spoken out in his favour.

"Your decision to punish Mr. Price for reading this book is deeply concerning. It is a threat to the freedom to read, learn, and teach, which should be protected and upheld in schools," reads a press release by PEN America.

"Reading and sharing literature, even on silly topics, should be celebrated in public education, not become a cause for punishment."

He would do it all again

Price says he's raising money online for a lawyer and plans to fight for his job. He has a hearing scheduled for March 21.

Despite all his troubles, he says that if he had his time back, he would still pick I Need A New Butt to read to the kids.

"Someone asked that question of me the other day and my daughter answered for me. She said, 'You know what? He would pick that book again, and he'd probably pick another book that was just like it,'" he said.

"And you know what? She's right."


Written by Sheena Goodyear with files from The Associated Press. Interview produced by Morgan Passi.

Add some “good” to your morning and evening.

A variety of newsletters you'll love, delivered straight to you.

Sign up now

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?

now