Viral video of emaciated polar bear may not be what it seems, Nunavut bear monitor says
When Leo Ikakhik saw this weekend's viral video of an emaciated polar bear rummaging through the garbage in search of food, he wasn't shocked.
"I wasn't totally surprised. These things happen," the Nunavut polar bear monitor told As It Happens host Carol Off. "Mother Nature is going to do part of that. You know, it's just part of the cycle."
Ikakhik has been monitoring polar bear activity in and around Arviat, a small community on the western shore of Hudson Bay, since 2010, working with organizations like the World Wildlife Fund Canada to keep the creatures away from human populations and reduce polar bear deaths.
"Everybody probably was shocked to see a really skinny bear, but this is not my first time seeing something like this."
In the clip, an emaciated bear, bones visible through its yellowing fur, struggles to walk as it searches for food in an abandoned fishing camp on Somerset Island, near Baffin Island in Nunavut.
It was shot in July by National Geographic photojournalist Paul Nicklen for his conservation organization SeaLegacy, which runs regular expeditions in the North to document the effects of climate change.
"When the animal first got up and we could see that he was actually in the late stages of starvation," SeaLegacy co-founder Cristina Mittermeier told As It Happens on Friday.
"All of our team was in tears and feeling completely helpless to do anything about it except to roll our cameras and share it with the world."
Mittermeier said they can't be certain about the cause of this bear's condition, but hopes it prompts discussions about how climate change is affecting the North, including its wildlife.
"We are not sure that it was because of climate change. It is impossible to tell why he was in this state. Maybe it could have been an injury or a disease, but the point is that it was starving and we want people to know what a starving polar bear looks like, because as we lose the ice in the Arctic polar bears will starve," she said.
But Ikakhik isn't convinced.
Instead, he suspects the creature was likely sick or recovering from an old injury that left it unable to hunt.
He said he sees healthy and well-fed polar bears in the Arctic all the time, but some are simply unlucky.
For example, he said he recently came across a bear with a broken paw that couldn't hunt, and locals had to put it down.
"Since I'm from the North, I wouldn't really fall for the video," he said.
"I wouldn't really blame the climate change. It's just part of the animal, what they go through."
He's not the only one speaking out about the video.
After As It Happens aired its interview with Mittermeier, several listeners from the North contacted the show to object to using one dramatic video clip to illustrate the wider issue of climate change without consulting locals.
Others questioned the timing of the video's release, noting it was filmed during the region's snowless summer months, but posted online in December.
That bear is obviously quite sick or badly injured, which can also happen to any other animal. It could have been in a serious accident, got a bad fight injury or ate something that damaged it’s vital organs. Please, don’t assume all bears are starving because of this one photo.—@Ingutaq
Important to ask Inuit elders/polar bear hunters - they are the true experts regarding polar bears (demography) <a href="https://twitter.com/cbcasithappens?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">@cbcasithappens</a> <a href="https://t.co/mBcp8DRpwx">https://t.co/mBcp8DRpwx</a>—@madinuk
Still, several studies have documented the negative impact of melting sea has on polar bear populations.
It found a 71 per cent chance that the mean global population size will decline by more than one-third over the next 34-41 years, a period the authors describe as "three polar bear generations."
Since 1979, sea ice melted an average of 1.26 days earlier across the the four polar bear ecoregions and 19 subpopulation areas, the researchers said.
- Polar bear numbers could drop a third by mid-century
- Climate denier blogs ignore polar bear science: study
- Polar bears in Churchill face bleak future, researchers warn
Polar bears rely on sea ice as a habitat for hunting seals, but as the Arctic gets warmer as a result of climate change, there is less ice, especially in the summer.
"The key feeding time is being shortened and shortened progressively," University of Alberta polar bear expert Ian Stirling told The Canadian Press in an interview about the SeaLegacy video.
"So they're coming to shore with less stored fat, they're… living longer on it, and some of them are just running out of gas."
While polar bears in some areas have been particularly hard hit, a report released in March by the Canada-Greenland Joint Commission on Polar Bear found the creatures are weathering climate change better than expected in much of Canada's eastern Arctic.
'These things happen'
Ikakhik said he's not denying the existence of climate change or its effect on the North, but he takes issue with one piece of footage being used to paint a bigger picture about wildlife in the North.
"These things happen," he said.
As It Happens has reached out to SeaLegacy for further comment.
On Friday, Mittermeier said it doesn't ultimately matter what happened to this one bear.
"The point is that it was starving," she said. "As we lose sea ice in the Arctic, polar bears will starve."
— With files from Canadian Press
CORRECTION: A previous version of this story suggested that SeaLegacy suspected climate change was responsible for the bear's condition. While the group said the video brings attention to the dangers of climate change, it did not speculate on the cause of the bear's starvation.