A young girl is crying with her mouth wide open


I Value My Daughter’s Opinion, But She Doesn’t Always Get a Choice

Feb 5, 2019

Bedtime in our household is a generally dreaded part of the day. My five-year-old daughter has always felt about sleeping the way most people do about hair in their food, or construction next door at the crack of dawn.

Some days result in what we refer to as the "hole of the tumbler" argument. 

This is when my daughter is unable to exert influence over something (like bedtime), so instead she'll fight a bloody battle over another much less significant situation.

In the given example above, when bedtime negotiation is not on the table, my daughter will lose tears over which hole of the tumbler her toothbrush can be placed in.

Relevant Reading: 4 Things to Remember During Your Kid's Next Public Meltdown

My child is strong-minded, confident and unabashedly opinionated. These are all qualities I admire, respect and dread simultaneously. My husband and I learned early on that if we were to hang on to any aspirations of being in control, we needed to set boundaries on when and how she would be allowed to get her own way. As her logical thinking, debating skills and sentence structure have improved over time, we have repeatedly come back to some basics on autonomy and choice. Here's how we exercise authority and still teach the value of autonomy.

Present a choice of choices

To strike a balance between our child exerting influence and running the show, a good strategy is to give her a spectrum of choice, or at least a choice between two reasonable alternatives. This helps alleviate the frustration she feels over her powerlessness in a specific situation, and it allows her to slow down and evaluate her choices. Most importantly, it gets her to make a decision. For example, on a mutinous bedtime day, I’ll give my daughter a choice between brushing her teeth first or changing into her PJs first, or which books to read. It’s a small choice in the routine but it redirects the conversation and calms her down.

Communicate what is and isn’t a choice

My husband and I often use the phrase, “This isn’t a choice situation.” There are certain scenarios where our daughter has choice, like at a restaurant where she is allowed to choose what to order for herself. However, at home, what’s on the dinner table is not negotiable and she understands that.

What is essential for this strategy to work is consistency and that the boundaries and scenarios for choice are clear. For example, instead of letting our daughter pick breakfast one day but not another, a better alternative is to establish an understanding that on weekdays she eats what's given to her, but on weekends she can make her own decision.

Relevant Reading: Things I Say and Do to Help Build My Kids' Confidence

Choosing the hill you want to die on

Ever been in a headache-inducing debate with your offspring only to realize a few minutes into it that you aren’t sure why you are arguing about this but you are too committed to back off? Yup, happens to all of us. It’s difficult to make real-time decisions on which hill is worth dying on, especially when the stakes are high and when you have to reinforce your parental awesomeness. However, not all battles are worth fighting and if it’s an inconsequential, safe, non-precedent setting decision, we let our child have the win sometimes. Instead of arguments each morning over outfit selection, I let my daughter choose her clothes as long as they are clean and weather-appropriate.

Encourage safe and responsible decision-making

While I may want to keep my kid safe and prevent her from having M&Ms for every meal, allowing her to make decisions and exert control is also imperative to her growth and self-confidence, and to equip her with the necessary tools and thought processes required to make well-informed decisions. It is important for children to have opportunities to use their voice, to weigh the pros and cons of a choice and understand the impact of the decisions they make. 

Relevant Reading: How to Create a Calm Down Space for Your Kids

Value their opinion where it matters

It can be a tough balance allowing a child to exercise their wild choices, without subduing their wild spirit. So we make sure to pay heed to our daughter's wishes so she feels like her opinion is valued — at least in areas where her thoughts and opinions matter, like what activities she'd like to participate in and who she likes spending time with.  

Raising a child to make the right choices isn’t an easy feat and I suspect that the complexity and intensity of our arguments will only increase from the current “hole of the tumbler” variety, but I hope that our strategies will help our daughter become a strong, autonomous woman who has the voice and the wisdom to make the right decisions in life.

Article Author Yumna Siddiqui-Khan
Yumna Siddiqui-Khan

Read more from Yumna here.

Yumna Siddiqui-Khan is an accountant by day, and writer and amateur photographer by night. A Toronto native, she now resides in Ottawa with her spouse and their 3-year-old spawn. Her photography, musings on life and the lessons learned through parenting can be found at the Institution of Parenthood.

Add New Comment

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Submission Policy

Note: The CBC does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. By submitting your comments, you acknowledge that CBC has the right to reproduce, broadcast and publicize those comments or any part thereof in any manner whatsoever. Please note that comments are moderated and published according to our submission guidelines.