World

Highlights from Marie Yovanovitch's public testimony on Trump and Ukraine

Marie Yovanovitch testified on Capitol Hill on Friday, where the ex-ambassador to Ukraine described what it was like to be disparaged by the U.S. president, as well as the stakes for American support in Ukraine. Republicans questioned her relevance as a witness to the probe the Democrats are leading.

Public session got surreal as Adam Schiff read out disparaging Trump tweet soon after it was sent

Highlights from 2nd day of U.S. impeachment inquiry

2 years ago
4:25
Ex-U.S. ambassador to Ukraine testifies about tumult that evolved with assignment and surprising end to Ukraine posting. 4:25

Career diplomat Marie (Masha) Yovanovitch got to elaborate in public testimony Friday before the U.S. House intelligence committee about her removal as U.S. ambassador to Ukraine, an event that clearly left her disappointed and puzzled.

Yovanovitch was removed from her post just over two months before a now-infamous July 25 call in which U.S. President Donald Trump asked his Ukraine counterpart Volodymyr Zelensky for a "favour," bringing up the possibility of investigations into Democratic rival Joe Biden — whose son Hunter served on the board of Ukraine energy giant Burisma while his father was U.S. vice-president — as well as a probe into whether Ukraine actors interfered in the 2016 election through cyber activities on behalf of Democrats.

That phone call and the withholding of U.S. aid to Ukraine for several weeks have formed the basis of an impeachment inquiry in the House of Representatives. Democrats allege Trump improperly used the powers of his office for personal gain and that Yovanovitch, given her exemplary record, was an obstacle to getting buy-in for those desired investigations.

After testifying for about five hours, the Montreal-born Yovanovitch left the room on Capitol Hill to applause.

Here are some of the highlights:

'It sounded like a threat'

In a rough summary released of the Trump-Zelensky phone call, the U.S. president described Yovanovitch as "bad news" and said she was "going to go through some things."

Yovanovitch described learning of the call: "It was a terrible moment. The person who saw me actually reading the transcript said that the colour drained from my face. I think I even had a physical reaction."

Yovanovitch 'shocked and devastated' to be called 'bad news' by Trump

2 years ago
1:14
Former ambassador to Ukraine Yovanovitch testifies she had physical reaction to being called 'bad news' by Trump: it was a 'terrible moment.' 1:14

Asked by Democratic counsel Daniel Goldman about the content, specifically the "going to go through some things," Yovanovitch replied: "It didn't sound good. It sounded like a threat."

Trump, in a move that was even criticized by analysts on Fox News, sent off a derogatory tweet while the hearing was ongoing, criticizing Yovanovitch's record of public service.

In a surreal moment, Adam Schiff, House intelligence committee chair, read the Trump tweet and got Yovanovitch to respond.

"Some of us here take witness intimidation very, very seriously," said Schiff.

Marie Yovanovitch responds to Trump's latest Twitter attack

2 years ago
1:44
During testimony to the U.S. House of Representatives, ex-U.S. ambassador Marie Yovanovitch addresses Donald Trump's live tweets attacking her. 1:44

The White House denied in a statement that it was intimidation, and an angry Trump insisted in a scrum with reporters on Friday afternoon, "I have a right to speak."

Republicans tried to push back at the notion Yovanovitch's professional life has ended dismally, with more than one lawmaker referring to the effusive praise she's received from fellow diplomats in testimony, as well as her current role teaching at Georgetown University.

Illinois Democrat Mike Quigley scoffed at that notion, getting her to admit Georgetown was not where she ultimately would like to be at this point in her career, and he then made his main point with a reference to Trump's pre-presidency role as The Apprentice host.

"It's not the end of a Hallmark movie. It's the end of a really bad reality TV show brought to you by someone who knows a lot about that," said Quigley.

High stakes

Yovanovitch's three decades of public service in posts have included time spent in hot spots. The diplomat spoke of fleeing from nearby gunfire in a breakaway Soviet republic, and being on the front lines several times in Ukraine as it has tried to fight off Kremlin-backed Russian fighters in the eastern part of the country.

Yovanovitch, stoic for much of the day, became a bit emotional recalling how she was summoned back to Washington for what would be her dismissal around the time she was involved in posthumously honouring Ukrainian Kateryna Handziuk, an anti-corruption activist who died after spending weeks in the hospital after having acid thrown at her.  

"This isn't a tabletop game," said Yovanovitch at one point. "There are lives in the balance."

'Why would somebody attack her with acid?' congressman asks about Ukrainian activist

2 years ago
0:54
Rep. Sean Maloney asked former U.S. ambassador to Ukraine Marie Yovanovitch about anti-corruption activist Kateryna Handziuk, who died in 2018 after an acid attack. 0:54

Yovanovitch also testified that she believed the circumstances regarding her ouster had negative repercussions pertaining to morale for foreign service officers as well as U.S. credibility in diplomatic circles around the globe.

"Our Ukraine policy has been thrown into disarray, and shady interests around the world over have learned how little it takes to remove an American ambassador who does not give them what they want," she said. "After these events, what foreign official — corrupt or not — can be blamed for wondering whether the U.S. ambassador represents the president's views?"

Ex-ambassador to Ukraine testifies about Giuliani influence

2 years ago
1:08
Marie Yovanovitch baffled by personal attacks and expresses fear for U.S. diplomacy 1:08

Again with the bribery

Article 2, Section 4 of the U.S. Constitution stipulates that the president and other officers of government "shall be removed from office on impeachment for, and conviction of, treason, bribery, or other high crimes and misdemeanours."

As happened with the impeachment cases concerning Richard Nixon and Bill Clinton, it has been presumed that if the Democrats were to draft articles of impeachment, they would accuse the president of the ill-defined "high crimes and misdemeanours."

Yovanovitch describes how U.S. interests were undermined in Ukraine

2 years ago
0:48
Former Ambassador Yovanovitch explains that foreign and private interests were able to undermine U.S. interests in Ukraine by using falsehoods 0:48

But in her weekly news conference on Wednesday, Democratic House Speaker Nancy Pelosi brought up the spectre of bribery in connection with the $391 million US in aid that was held up for several weeks. Democrats allege it was conditional on Ukraine announcing the investigations Trump desired.

"The bribe is to grant or withhold military assistance in return for a public statement of a fake investigation into the elections. That's bribery," said Pelosi.

Connecticut Democratic Jim Himes picked up the mantle from Pelosi in Friday's hearing, getting Yovanovitch to agree that bribery was a "serious abuse of power."

Trump a friend to Ukraine: Republicans

As the testimony got underway, the White House released a rough transcript of a call in late April between Trump and Zelensky, soon after the latter was elected. 

Devin Nunes, the ranking Republican on the committee, read liberally from the transcript, in which both presidents spoke of their kinship as outsider candidates and political neophytes with a high profile from TV appearances — Zelensky was a comic actor — before pulling off stunning electoral wins.

Democratic congressman Jim Himes muses on how exercising a right can become bribery

2 years ago
0:50
Facing questions from Democrat Jim Himes, Marie Yovanovitch agrees that having the right to do something does not always mean it's OK. 0:50

The value was questionable, given that the Democrats are largely focused on events between May and September. As they did in the first public hearing earlier this week involving U.S. diplomats Bill Taylor and George Kent, Republicans were probably more effective in focusing on the biggest contribution of the Trump administration to Ukraine's defence against Russia.

President Barack Obama's administration provided Ukraine with nonlethal military supplies, including counter-mortar radars, night-vision devices and medical items. The Trump administration in 2017 agreed to provide lethal weapons, committing to sell $47 million in Javelin anti-tank missiles.

Ohio Republican Brad Wenstrup got Yovanovitch to agree that the missiles serve as a deterrent to Russia. 

Republicans Mike Conaway of Texas and Mike Turner of Ohio are shown in front of a placard emphasizing the Trump administration's sale of Javelin missiles to Ukraine. (Alex Brandon/The Associated Press)

A bad look for Democrats 

There has never been credible information to emerge that indicates the Bidens engaged in wrongdoing. 

But Texas Republican John Ratcliffe essentially got Yovanovitch to agree that the appearance of a potential conflict of interest for Joe Biden was ever present, and that when she went through confirmation hearings in 2016 for her post, questions about the Bidens and Burisma were part of the preparation material for the Democratic administration.

Republican congressman asks about Hunter Biden's Ukraine ties

2 years ago
1:01
Rep. John Ratcliffe asked former U.S. ambassador to Ukraine Marie Yovanovitch about her Senate confirmation hearing and the son of former vice-president Joe Biden. 1:01

Yovanovitch could not specifically recall if any other Ukraine company was mentioned in the prep material.

Other Republicans brought up anti-Trump comments made publicly by Ukraine officials during the 2016 U.S. election campaign as evidence they were "out to get him," in the words of Republican counsel Steve Castor.

Yovanovitch comments on the value of military hardware provided to Ukraine by Trump administration

2 years ago
0:34
Under questioning from Republican Brad Wenstrup, Marie Yovanovitch offers her take on the anti-tank missiles Ukraine received from the U.S. 0:34

Yovanovitch admitted it was probably not appropriate for the Ukraine politicians to be so forthright about Trump, but felt they were "isolated incidents."

"Those elements that you've recited don't seem to me to be kind of a plan or plot of the Ukrainian government to work against President Trump or anyone else," she said.

Yovanovitch comments on alleged undermining of Trump on social media

2 years ago
3:19
While testifying on 2nd day of impeachment inquiry, ex-ambassador to Ukraine sheds light on Ukrainian officials' social media comments about Trump. 3:19

With files from The Associated Press

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?

now