World

Venice introducing fees, surveillance and pre-bookings to combat overtourism

To combat overcrowding due to tourism, Venice officials are tracking every person who sets foot in the historic Italian lagoon city.

Mayor Luigi Brugnaro says his aim is make tourism in the historic Italian city more sustainable

Venice to charge tourists for entry, require bookings for visitors

2 months ago
1:56
To combat overtourism, Venice is planning to introduce a booking system in 2022 or 2023 for those who want to visit the historic Italian city. Rates will vary depending on the season, and officials may even close the city to visitors at times if numbers become overwhelming. (Credit: Reuters/Manuel Silvestri) 1:56

From a control room inside the police headquarters in Venice, Big Brother is watching you.

To combat tourist overcrowding, officials are tracking every person who sets foot in the historic Italian lagoon city.

Using 468 CCTV cameras, optical sensors and a mobile phone-tracing system, they can tell residents from visitors, Italians from foreigners, where people are coming from, where they are heading and how fast they are moving.

Every 15 minutes, authorities get a snapshot of how crowded the city is — along with how many gondolas are sliding on the Canal Grande, whether boats are speeding and if the waters rise to dangerous levels.

Now, a month after cruise ships were banned from the lagoon, city authorities are preparing to demand that tourists pre-book their visit on an app and charge day-trippers between three and 10 euros to enter, depending on the time of the year.

A Venice officer looks at a monitor used to check the numbers of tourists entering the Italian city on Sunday. The system uses hundreds of CCTV cameras, optical sensors and a mobile phone-tracing system to track tourists. (Manuel Silvestri/Reuters)

New rules a hard sell, mayor admits

Airport-like turnstiles are being tested to control the flow of people and, should the numbers become overwhelming, stop new visitors from getting in.

Venice Mayor Luigi Brugnaro says his aim is to make tourism more sustainable in a city visited by 25 million people a year. But he acknowledges the new rules are likely to be a hard sell.

"I expect protests, lawsuits, everything … but I have a duty to make this city liveable for those who inhabit it and also for those who want to visit," he told foreign reporters on Sunday.

Potential visitors are skeptical.

"It brings the wrong tone in me when I hear that I have to pay entrance just to see the buildings in the streets of the city because who decides who can go in?" said Marc Schieber, a German national in town for the Venice Film Festival.

"I think it is probably a new way to generate money."

Brugnaro said authorities have yet to decide how many people are too many, and when the new rules would kick in, though they are expected to come into force sometime between next summer and 2023.

Tourists are seen in St Mark's Square in Venice on Saturday. (Manuel Silvestri/Reuters)

Pandemic paused tourism

The scheme, first considered in 2019, was postponed because of COVID-19.

During last year's lockdown, Venetians marvelled at their city's narrow alleys for once not crowded by throngs of tourists, the lagoon waters made pristine by the absence of motorboats.

But as visitors returned to pack St Mark's Square this summer, officials say Venice cannot afford to let the numbers go unchecked if it wants to survive.

Some 193,000 people squeezed into the historic centre in a single day during the 2019 Carnival, before the pandemic struck. On Aug. 4 this year, the city counted 148,000, with the difference explained by the fact many U.S. and Asian travellers have still not returned to Europe.

"There is a physical limitation on the number of people that can be in the city at the same time," said Marco Bettini, director general of Venis, the IT company that built the monitoring system in partnership with phone operator TIM.

"We don't want to leave anyone behind or stop people from coming to Venice. We want people to book in advance, tell us where they want to go, what they want to visit, in order to provide a better quality of service."

General Director of Venis SpA, Marco Bettini, is seen in the police control room in Venice on Saturday. (Manuel Silvestri/Reuters)

'Conditions attached'

Residents, students and commuters will be exempt from the tourist tax. So will those spending at least one night in a Venice hotel, given they will have already paid the overnight tariff of up to five euros a day levied by the city.

Brugnaro brushed aside concerns about privacy, saying the data collected was anonymous. But his message was clear: by controlling the number of tourists that come to Venice, he also wants travellers to behave.

"There'll be conditions attached to obtain priority bookings and discounts," he said. "You can't come in your swimming suit. You can't jump from a bridge or get drunk. Whoever comes must respect the city."

WATCH | Italy's Venice could find a future in its past: 

Italy's Venice could find a future in its past

1 year ago
2:16
Tourism-dependent Venice is struggling to reinvent itself in the wake of COVID-19, and the solution may lie in the artisans that were once the pulse of the city. 2:16

In Venice, where the number of residents has shrunk to just 55,000, from about 175,000 in the 1950s, Brugnaro's plan is the subject of heated debate, with some worrying it will deter less well-heeled tourists and turn the city into a theme park.

Others, such as 50-year-old Stefano Verratti who sells Murano glass near the train station, backed the idea of discouraging day-trippers.

"I have been here for 30 years, and it used to be very different. Before, Venice was really romantic," he said.

"Now it's just people rushing to buy a kebab, take a quick selfie on the Rialto bridge, and then rushing to take a train. I don't know if they really enjoy it."

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?

now