Ukraine crisis: Ceasefire holds as U.S., EU mull imposing new sanctions

After more than four months of bloodshed, a ceasefire in Ukraine's rebellious east largely held back fighting Saturday, but appeared fragile as both sides of the conflict claimed the others had violated the agreement.

Both sides claim the other broke agreement, but no fighting since Friday

Fighting reportedly continued up to 45 minutes before a ceasefire went into effect in eastern Ukraine Friday. (Vasily Fedosenko/Reuters)

After more than four months of bloodshed, a ceasefire in Ukraine's rebellious east largely held back fighting Saturday, but appeared fragile as both sides of the conflict claimed the others had violated the agreement.

Col. Andriy Lysenko, a spokesman for Ukraine's national security council, told reporters that rebels had fired at Ukrainian forces on 10 occasions after the ceasefire was to take effect, but all the incidents he detailed were on Friday night.

In Donetsk, the largest city controlled by the Russian-backed separatists, the night passed quietly — a rarity after several months of daily shelling in residential areas. But Alexander Zakharchenko, the top separatist leader from Donetsk, told the Russian news agency RIA Novosti that the ceasefire had been violated with two rounds of shelling in the town of Amvrosiivka, about 50 kilometres southeast of Donetsk.

"At this time the ceasefire agreement is not being fully observed," he said. He didn't say when the supposed breach was to have occurred. 

Lysenko said Ukrainian forces were strictly observing the ceasefire and suggested that Zakharchenko's claim was a provocation.

Ukraine had received information that the rebels on Friday "were preparing a press conference for today (in which) one of the points was the condemnation of the Ukrainian military for violation of the ceasefire," Lysenko said through a translator. "So we do not exclude that they tried to provoke the Ukrainian military to fire."

Earlier Saturday, the mayor's office in Donetsk said there had been no reports of shooting or shelling there although some shelling had been heard late Friday afternoon.

Failed ceasefires

Ukraine, Russia and the Kremlin-backed separatists signed the ceasefire deal Friday in Minsk, the Belarusian capital, in an effort to end more than four months of fighting in the region. The negotiators also agreed on the withdrawal of all heavy weaponry, the release of all prisoners and the delivery of humanitarian aid to devastated cities in eastern Ukraine.

Both sides agreed to withdraw heavy weaponry and allow the flow of aid to besieged cities across the region. (Gleb Garanich/Reuters)

If the ceasefire holds, it would be a landmark achievement for both sides. Fighting between pro-Russian rebels and Ukrainian government troops has ravaged the already teetering Ukrainian economy, claimed at least 2,600 civilian lives and left hundreds of thousands homeless, according to United Nations estimates.

But Western leaders voiced skepticism over Russia's commitment to the deal. A previous 10-day ceasefire, which each side repeatedly accused the other of violating, yielded few results at the negotiating table.

U.S. President Barack Obama said he was hopeful the ceasefire would hold but unsure the rebels would follow through and that Russia would stop violating Ukraine's sovereignty and territorial integrity.

"It has to be tested," Obama said Friday at the closing of a two-day NATO summit in Wales.

More sanctions possible

Both the U.S. and the European Union have prepared even tougher sanctions on Moscow, and Obama stressed that the most effective way to ensure the ceasefire's success was to move ahead with those measures and maintain pressure on Russia. According to an EU diplomat, these new measures would target Russia's access to capital markets and trade in arms and defense technology, dual-use goods and sensitive technologies. The new sanctions were given preliminary approval Friday night and could be implemented as early as Tuesday.

A pro-Russian separatist walks past the burnt remains of what locals say was a Ukrainian tank outside the village of Mnogopolye, southeast from Donetsk, September 5, 2014. (Maxim Shemetov/Reuters)

"If certain processes get underway, we are prepared to suspend sanctions" against Russia, German Chancellor Angela Merkel said.

Ukraine, NATO and Western nations have accused Russia of backing the separatists with weapons, supplies and thousands of regular troops. Moscow has denied this, but a NATO military told The Associated Press that the number of Russian soldiers directly involved in the conflict has grown past the alliance's earlier estimate of at least 1,000.

In a statement published online Saturday, Russia's foreign ministry condemned further EU sanctions and promised that "there will undoubtedly be a reaction from our side" to any new measures. In August, Russia passed a sweeping ban on meat, fruit, vegetables, and dairy product imports from the EU, the U.S. and a host of other countries who imposed sanctions on Russia.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?