Banning Donald Trump from U.K. debated in Parliament today

British lawmakers argue over whether Donald Trump should be excluded from the U.K. for his anti-Muslim remarks, with one legislator cautioning that a ban would give the Republican presidential hopeful a "halo of victimhood."

Legislators call billionaire an attention-seeker, fool but many say he shouldn't be banned

Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump drew disapproval with his proposal that Muslims be banned from entering the U.S. Some Britons want him banned from the U.K. as a result. (Jae C. Hong/Associated Press)

Donald Trump doesn't have many fans in Britain's Parliament.

But a debate among lawmakers on calls to ban Trump from the country revealed little appetite to close Britain's doors to the provocative Republican U.S. presidential contender.

During a three-hour debate Monday, legislators from Britain's main parties stood to call Trump an attention-seeker, a demagogue and a fool. Many, though, argued that he should not be stifled or banned.

"While I think this man is crazy, while I think this man has no valid points to make, I will not be the one to silence his voice," said Conservative lawmaker Tom Tugendhat.

Donald Trump: The Battle of Britain


5 years agoVideo
Harsh words are being exchanged as Parliament prepares to debate a ban on Donald Trump 3:47

Parliament took up the topic after half a million people signed a petition calling for Trump to be excluded over his call for a temporary ban on Muslims entering the United States in the wake of extremist violence. Trump has also claimed that some areas of Britain are so radicalized that police fear for their lives.

Under British law, any petition supported by 100,000 people — who must each provide and confirm an email address — is considered for parliamentary debate. Monday's debate was intended to air the subject rather than take a vote.

Quotes from debate …

  • Labour's Paul Flynn, anti-ban: "The great danger by attacking this one man is that we can fix on him a halo of victimhood. We give him the role of martyrdom, which can be seen to be an advantage among those that support him."
  • Labour's Tulip Siddiq, pro-ban: "His words are not comical, his words are not funny. His words are poisonous."
  • Conservative Edward Leigh, anti-ban: "We oppose Mr. Trump for demonizing his opponents. … If we ban him from the country are we not in danger of doing the same?"
  • Democratic Unionist Party lawmaker Gavin Robinson, anti-ban: "Let him come here … let him go home with his tail between his legs."
  • Labour's Jack Dromey, pro-ban: "Donald Trump is a fool. He is free to be a fool. He is not free to be a dangerous fool on our shores."

More than 500,000 people have signed an online petition backing a ban on Trump, who owns a golf resort in Scotland, the land of his mother's birth.

Labour Party legislator Paul Flynn, who opened the session, said Trump had already received "far too much attention."

"The great danger by attacking this one man is that we can fix on him a halo of victimhood" and boost his popularity among supporters, Flynn said.

But another Labour lawmaker, Tulip Siddiq, supported a ban.

"This is a man who is extremely high-profile, ... a man who is interviewing for the most important job in the world," she said. "His words are not comical, his words are not funny. His words are poisonous."

Prime Minister David Cameron has condemned Trump's remarks about Muslims as "divisive, stupid and wrong," but he and other senior officials have said they do not think Trump should be banned.

Ban would betray free speech, lawmakers say

The government has the power to deny entry to people with criminal convictions or those whose presence is considered not "conducive to the public good." The power has been used against figures as diverse as boxer Mike Tyson, rapper Tyler the Creator, radical Muslim preachers and the late Christian fundamentalist Fred Phelps Sr.

Britain also turned away anti-Islam Dutch legislator Geert Wilders at an airport in 2009. Wilders later sued and won the right to come to Britain.

Several lawmakers argued that banning Trump would betray the principles of free speech.

Conservative Paul Scully said that while people had been excluded from Britain for incitement or hatred, "I have never heard of one for stupidity and I'm not sure we should be starting now."

But Labour's Jack Dromey said Trump was dangerous because he stirred up hatred among different faiths.

"Donald Trump is a fool," Dromey said. "He is free to be a fool. He is not free to be a dangerous fool on our shores."

Sarah Malone, executive vice-president of Trump International Golf Links, Scotland, said "debating a matter raised as part of the American Presidential election" was a waste of parliamentary time.

"Westminster is creating a dangerous precedent on this issue and is sending a terrible message to the world," she said.

High level of distaste

Terry Jones, a Florida pastor who tried to organize a Qur'an-burning protest several years ago, was banned from entering. 

There is a high level of distaste in London for Donald Trump, CBC's Ellen Mauro reported Monday.

"The mayor of London, for example, said he wouldn't go to some parts of New York City for fear of running into Donald Trump," she said.

"That was in response to comments Trump made about parts of London being so radicalized that police are too afraid to go to them."

There have also been harsh words between Trump and Alex Salmond, former leader of the Scottish National Party.

Trump called Salmond "an embarrassment to Scotland."

Salmond called Trump "a loser."

With files from CBC News, Reuters


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.