Suu Kyi denies Myanmar genocide allegations at International Court of Justice

Myanmar's former pro-democracy icon Aung San Suu Kyi denies the armed forces committed genocide against the Rohingya minority, telling the UN's top court the exodus of hundreds of thousands of Muslims was the unfortunate result of a battle with insurgents.

More than 700,000 Muslim Rohingya fled 2017 army crackdown

Myanmar leader in UN court over alleged Rohingya genocide

3 years ago
Duration 0:20
Aung San Suu Kyi defends military against genocide allegations

Myanmar's former pro-democracy icon Aung San Suu Kyi on Wednesday denied the armed forces committed genocide against the Rohingya minority, telling the UN's top court the exodus of hundreds of thousands of Muslims was the unfortunate result of a battle with insurgents.

Suu Kyi denied allegations the army had killed civilians, raped women and torched houses in 2017 in what Myanmar's accusers describe as a deliberate campaign of ethnic cleansing and genocide that saw more than 700,00 Rohingya flee to neighbouring Bangladesh.

She said the allegations stem from "an internal armed conflict started by co-ordinated and comprehensive armed attacks ... to which Myanmar's defence services responded. Tragically, this armed conflict led to the exodus of several hundred thousand Muslims."

Her appearance at the International Court of Justice (ICJ) was striking in that Suu Kyi was defending the very armed forces that had kept her under house arrest for about 15 years. She was awarded the 1991 Nobel Peace Prize in absentia for championing democracy and rights under Myanmar's then-ruling junta.

A small group of her supporters gathered Wednesday outside The Hague-based court.

Rohingya representatives and rights group said they were appalled by Suu Kyi's testimony.

"The world will judge their claim of no genocide with evidence," said Mohammed Mohibullah, chairman of the Arakan Rohingya Society for Peace and Human Rights. "A thief never admits he is a thief, but justice can be delivered through evidence."

Suu Kyi told the court the African nation of Gambia, which brought the legal action against Myanmar on behalf of the 57-country Organization of Islamic Cooperation, had provided "an incomplete and misleading factual picture" of what happened in Myanmar's northern Rakhine state in August 2017.

Gambia alleges genocide was committed and is still ongoing. It has asked the world court to take action to stop the violence, including "all measures within its power to prevent all acts that amount to or contribute to the crime of genocide" in Myanmar.

Bob Rae, Canada's special envoy to Myanmar, speaks from The Hague

Bob Rae says Rohingya need protection now

3 years ago
Duration 8:31
Canada's special envoy to Myanmar describes what he's seen and says the UN's top court must use its power to order some protection.

In three days of hearings this week, judges are hearing the first phase of the case: Gambia's request for provisional measures — the equivalent of a restraining order — against Myanmar to protect the Rohingya population until the case is heard in full.

Whether that will happen is not yet clear. But if the court grants the provisional measures, Canada's special envoy to Myanmar, Bob Rae, said UN organizations and others may be granted access to Rakhine they've not had previously.

"From my point of view listening to the two sides, I'd say that the very least that we ... should be able to get from the court is some greater degree of protection for the civilian Rohingya population," Rae told CBC News Network on Wednesday.

Rae said Suu Kyi's assertion the allegations are an internal matter that will be dealt with in Myanmar lacks credibility.

"The Myanmar army is not capable of taking the kind of action against its own members that clearly has to be taken," Rae said.

Having travelled to the region several times since he was appointed to the envoy role two years ago, he said every conversation he had with someone now living in a camp for the displaced revealed "another atrocity. 

"I flew over northern Rakhine — I've not been allowed to travel either by car or on foot in northern Rakhine apart from one small community — but I've seen burnt-out villages."

Rae said he's had interviews with women who describe being tortured and raped and the killing of their children.

But Suu Kyi said developments in one of Myanmar's poorest regions are "complex and not easy to fathom." She detailed how the army responded on Aug. 25, 2017, to attacks by insurgents trained by Afghan and Pakistan extremists.

Addressing the court in her capacity as Myanmar's foreign minister, Suu Kyi insisted the armed forces had tried "to reduce collateral damage" during fighting in 12 locations. While conceding excessive force might have been used and one helicopter may have killed "non-combatants," Suu Kyi said a Myanmar investigation is looking into what happened and should be allowed to finish its work.

Myanmar says genocide convention doesn't apply

"Can there be genocidal intent on the part of a state that actively investigates, prosecutes and punishes soldiers and officers who are accused of wrongdoing?" she asked the court.

Suu Kyi and Myanmar's legal team argued the genocide convention does not apply to Myanmar. They invoked Croatia during the Balkans wars in the 1990s, saying no genocide was deemed there when thousands of people were forced from their homes by fighting.

Demonstrators gathered outside the ICJ to protest against Suu Kyi, the former pro-democracy icon. (Yves Herman/Reuters)

Although a UN fact-finding mission found "the gravest crimes under international law" had been committed in Myanmar and called for genocide trials, no court has weighed evidence and established a genocide in Myanmar. 

Rights groups joined Rohingya representatives in slamming the claims Suu Kyi and Myanmar's legal team made in The Hague.

George Graham, humanitarian advocacy director at Save the Children, said Suu Kyi's remarks "fly in the face of all the evidence gathered by the UN, and the testimony our own teams have heard from countless survivors."

"Rohingya families have faced patterns of unimaginable horrors in a campaign of violence. Children and their parents have been systematically killed, maimed and raped," he said, adding that "the government of Myanmar has failed at every turn to punish those responsible."

Amnesty International's Nicholas Bequelin accused Suu Kyi of trying to downplay the severity of crimes committed against the Rohingya and "wouldn't even refer to them by name or acknowledge the scale of the abuses. Such denials are deliberate, deceitful and dangerous."

"The exodus of more than three quarters of a million people from their homes and country was nothing but the result of an orchestrated campaign of murder, rape and terror," he said.

On Tuesday, Gambia's Justice Minister Aboubacarr Tambadou urged the ICJ to "tell Myanmar to stop these senseless killings, to stop these acts of barbarity that continue to shock our collective conscience, to stop this genocide of its own people."

Also Tuesday, the U.S. slapped economic sanctions on four Myanmar military officers suspected of human rights violations. It sanctioned Min Aung Hlaing, commander of Myanmar's armed forces, over allegations of serious rights abuses. Deputy commander Soe Win and two other military leaders, Than Oo and Aung Aung, were also targeted.

CBC's Nahlah Ayed and Stephanie Jenzer travelled to Bangladesh in 2017 and Myanmar in 2018. Read some of their coverage here: 

"There are credible claims of mass-scale rape and other forms of sexual violence committed by soldiers under Min Aung Hlaing's command," a U.S. statement said.

Gambia has argued it is every country's duty under the convention to prevent a genocide from taking place. Gambia has political support from the 57-member Organization of Islamic Cooperation, Canada and the Netherlands.

Canada moved to revoke Suu Kyi's honorary citizenship in 2018. It had been granted more than a decade earlier for her pro-democracy work.

The court's hearings on Myanmar are scheduled to end Thursday.

With a file from CBC News and Reuters


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?