South Korean court denies request to arrest Samsung Group chief

A South Korean court on Thursday denied a special prosecutor clearance to arrest the head of Samsung Group, the country's largest conglomerate, amid a graft scandal that has led to the impeachment of President Park Geun-hye.

Jae Y. Lee could still be indicted down the road in scandal that has ensnared outgoing president

Samsung Group chief Jay Y. Lee left without speaking to reporters following a court hearing to review a detention warrant request against him at the Seoul Central District Court. (Kim Hong-Ji/Reuters)

A South Korean court on Thursday denied a special prosecutor clearance to arrest the head of Samsung Group, the country's largest conglomerate, amid a graft scandal that has led to the impeachment of President Park Geun-hye.

But Jay Y. Lee, who has led Samsung since his father, Lee Kun-hee, suffered a heart attack in 2014, was still likely to be face the same charges of bribery, embezzlement and perjury, legal analysts said.

The pre-dawn decision by the Seoul Central District Court to allow him to go home was welcomed by Samsung Group. The 48-year-old left the Seoul Detention Centre carrying a white shopping bag and climbed into a car without talking to reporters, having been held overnight as the court deliberated whether to grant the arrest warrant.

After being refused, a spokesman for the prosecutor said there would be no let up in the investigation.

The prosecutor's office has accused Lee of paying multi-million dollar bribes to Park's confidant, Choi Soon-sil, the woman at the heart of the scandal, to win support from the National Pension Service for a controversial 2015 merger of two Samsung Group affiliates.

The merger helped cement Lee's control over the smartphones-to-biopharmaceuticals business empire. He has denied wrongdoing.

The judge said in a statement on his ruling that an arrest was not necessary – for now.

"After reviewing the contents and the process of the investigation so far ... it is difficult to acknowledge the necessity and substantiality of an arrest at the current stage," he said. The special prosecutor's office said it deeply regretted the ruling.

"We will consider necessary measures and continue with the investigation without wavering," spokesman Lee Kyu-chul said. He did not comment on whether the prosecution will try again to get an arrest warrant and did not take questions.

Lee Jung-jae, a lawyer and former prosecutor, said he didn't think the special prosecutor would push for Lee's detention again. "They probably already have as much evidence as they could gather," he told Reuters.

"They will indict him eventually, but without detention." Samsung said in an emailed statement that it appreciated "the fact that the merits of this case can now be determined without the need for detention."

The group's flagship, Samsung Electronics, is the world's biggest maker of smartphones, flat-screen televisions and memory chips.

Opposition party angered by ruling

The special prosecutor's office on Monday said it was seeking an arrest warrant for Lee for paying bribes totalling 43 billion won ($36.70 million US) to organizations linked to Choi to secure the 2015 merger of Samsung C&T Corp and Cheil Industries Inc.

Park, 64, was impeached last month by parliament over the influence-peddling scandal. If the decision is upheld by the Constitutional Court, she will become South Korea's first democratically elected leader to be forced from office early.

Park, who remains in office but stripped of her powers while the court decides her fate, and Choi have denied wrongdoing.

The special prosecutor's office said on Tuesday it had evidence that Park and Choi shared profits gained through bribery payments, but did not elaborate.

This week, the special prosecutor indicted the chairman of the National Pension Service, the world's third-largest pension fund, on charges of abuse of power and giving false testimony in relation to the deal.

Thursday's court ruling angered many, including members of the left-wing opposition Democratic Party, which said the decision ran counter to public sentiment. Samsung and its leader have been dogged by protests in recent weeks as the graft probe advanced, with some calling for Lee's immediate arrest.

"The law is not equal for all," one South Korean remarked on web portal Naver.

Key Samsung Group shares were higher following the court decision, though down from their opening peaks as investors braced for the likelihood of an indictment.

Samsung Electronics was up 0.5 per cent at 0230 GMT while shares of Samsung C&T Corp were up 1.22 perc ent, outperforming a 0.01 per cent rise in the broader market."

The only thing that has changed is that he won't be detained now," HDC Asset Management fund manager Park Jung-hoon said, adding that uncertainties were likely to linger on.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.