Pope criticizes Trump administration policy on migrant family separation

On World Refugee Day, Pope Francis criticized the Trump administration's policy of separating migrant families at the Mexican border.

Francis posts pointed tweets on World Refugee Day

Pope Francis has joined the chorus of voices condemning the Trump administration's policy of separating migrant families crossing illegally into the U.S. (Stefano Rellandini/Reuters)

Pope Francis has criticized the Trump administration's policy of separating migrant families at the Mexican border, saying populism is not the answer to the world's immigration problems. 

Speaking to Reuters, the Pope said he supported recent statements by U.S. Catholic bishops who called the separation of children from their parents "contrary to our Catholic values" and "immoral."

"It's not easy, but populism is not the solution," Francis said on Sunday night, ahead of World Refugee Day on Wednesday.

In a rare, wide-ranging interview, the Pope also said he may accept more bishops' resignations over a sexual abuse scandal in Chile.

Reflecting at his Vatican residence on his five years as Pope, he defended his leadership of the Roman Catholic Church against criticism by conservatives inside and outside the church who say his interpretation of its teachings is too liberal. 

He also said he wanted to appoint more women to top positions in the Vatican administration. 

One of his most pointed messages concerned President Donald Trump's zero-tolerance immigration policy, in which U.S.
authorities are criminally prosecuting all immigrants caught crossing the Mexican border illegally, holding adults in jail while their children are sent to government shelters.

The policy has caused an outcry in the United States and has been condemned abroad as videos emerged of youngsters held in concrete-floored enclosures and an audio of wailing children went viral. 

U.S. Catholic bishops have joined other religious leaders in the United States in condemning the policy. 

"I am on the side of the bishops' conference," the Pope said, referring to two statements from U.S. bishops this month.

"Let it be clear that in these things, I respect [the position of] the bishops conference." 

On Wednesday he posted pointed tweets in support of refugees.

Francis's comments add to the pressure on Trump over immigration policy. The Pope heads a church that has 1.3 billion members worldwide and is the largest Christian denomination in the United States. 

The president has strongly defended his administration's actions. 

Populists 'creating psychosis'

The U.S. crackdown chimes with a new political mood sweeping western Europe over the large numbers of migrants and asylum-seekers, most of them escaping conflict and poverty in the Middle East and Africa. 

The Pope said populists were "creating psychosis" on the issue of immigration, even as aging societies like Europe faced "a great demographic winter" and needed more immigrants. 

Without immigration, he added, Europe "will become empty."

He spoke at length about immigration, a controversial issue in Europe as well as the United States. The populist Italian government has refused port access to non-government ships that have been rescuing asylum seekers trying to cross to Italy from Africa in flimsy boats. 

One ship was forced to disembark more than 600 migrants in Spain over the weekend.

Italian Interior Minister Matteo Salvini, also leader of the far right-wing League party, has criticized the Pope in the past, once saying the pontiff should take in migrants in the Vatican if he was so concerned about them.

"I believe that you cannot reject people who arrive. You have to receive them, help them, look after them, accompany them and then see where to put them, but throughout all of Europe," Francis said.

"Some governments are working on it, and people have to be settled in the best possible way, but creating psychosis is not the cure. Populism does not resolve things. What resolves things is acceptance, study, prudence."

More women in Vatican

Since assuming the papacy in 2013, Francis has promoted a liberal interpretation of Catholic teachings at a time when politics in many parts of the West have shifted toward economic nationalism. 

He has faced internal opposition from conservative clergy who oppose his liberal interpretations, especially his approach to sexuality and showing mercy toward divorced Catholics. But the Pope said he prayed for conservatives who sometimes said "nasty things" about him. 

Defending his leadership, the 81-year-old Argentine pontiff said the future of the Catholic Church was "on the street."

The Pope has accepted the resignations of three bishops in Chile over the sexual abuse scandal there and allegations that it was covered up. He said he could accept more resignations but did not say which bishop or bishops he had in mind.

He said reform of the Vatican administration, the Curia, was going well, "but we have to work more." 

Francis said he was mostly happy about reforms enacted to make once-scandalous Vatican finances more transparent.  The Vatican bank, which closed hundreds of suspicious or dormant accounts, "now works well," he said.

"There have been some struggles and I have had to make some strong decisions."     

He said he wanted to appoint more women to head Vatican departments because they were better at resolving conflicts, though this should not lead to what he called "masculinism in a skirt." 

The Pope said his health was good apart from leg pain related to a back condition. He reiterated comments first made shortly after his election that he may someday resign for reasons of health as his predecessor, Benedict, did in 2013, but said: "Right now, I am not even thinking about it."


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?