World·Analysis

On NATO's front lines, a difference of opinion on how to best respond to Russia

The U.S. and its NATO allies have started planning to bolster military power in eastern Europe. But another key player has not: Germany. In the Baltic nation of Lithuania, CBC News heard from both perspectives.

Germany says beefing up NATO's eastern border could provoke Russia. Many disagree.

A German armoured personnel carrier and its crew arrives in Rukla, Lithuania, at the start of a six-month assignment in the Baltic nation. (Chris Brown/CBC)

With NATO pondering how to appropriately respond to Russia's mobilization along the Ukrainian border, a small element of possible deterrence arrived this week in Rukla, Lithuania.

Flatbed railcars, loaded with armoured infantry vehicles from Germany, were met by soldiers from the nearby NATO base, who promptly unloaded the noisy, tracked machines and drove them off in a convoy along the narrow, rural roads.

The vehicles and the troops that man them are replacing others returning to Germany, as one rotation ends and another begins — all part of a NATO strategy in the region known as Enhanced Forward Presence, which dates back to 2017.

In Lithuania, Germany is providing the core of the battle group for the alliance, explained commanding officer, German Lt.-Col. Hagen Ruppelt.

"We are here because the Lithuanian government and the Baltic states are perceiving a threat around them," he told CBC News during a visit to see a small part of the German operation.

German Lt.-Col. Hagen Ruppelt is the commander of NATO's Enhanced Forward Presence battle group in Lithuania, which is about 1,200 members strong. (Jason Ho/CBC)

Similar NATO bases are in place in Estonia and Latvia, led by British and Canadian commanders respectively — and all three with roughly 1,200 soldiers each.

As of late, the pressing political question for the 72-year-old NATO has been whether it urgently needs to further beef up its troops and equipment in the Baltic states that border Russia.

Or, alternatively, show a more restrained stance in the hopes of not provoking the Kremlin.

Germany an outlier among NATO members

Tensions have soared in the region amid the buildup of Russian troops near Ukraine's border, prompting fears that an invasion could be on the horizon. Western military experts estimate there are already as many as 127,000 Russian troops near the border and tens of thousand more taking up positions inside Belarus, within 200 kilometers of Kyiv. 

Russia-backed Ukrainian separatists have been fighting government forces in the Donbas region since 2014. Recently, Russia's military manoeuvres near the Ukraine border have made NATO members, including the Baltic states near Russia's western border, nervous. (CBC)

Russia denies having any such plans and insists it's just running military drills. It has also said its objective is to negotiate a security deal with the United States that would see foreign forces removed from the countries along its border, ensure Ukraine is off limits for NATO troops and provide a guarantee Ukraine would never be admitted to the alliance.

The U.S., Europe, and NATO have rejected Russia's demands but are offering a dialogue on a range of strategic issues. 

But while the U.S. and many NATO allies are stepping up their response plans in eastern Europe amid the standoff, Germany remains an outlier.

WATCH | Germany holds off on additional support for Ukraine:

NATO members grapple over how to deter Russian threat against Ukraine

4 months ago
Duration 2:11
With heightened tensions in Ukraine and other parts along NATO’s eastern edge, NATO countries are divided over whether to ramp up their presence in places like Lithuania.

Germany has vast commercial interests with Russia and buys huge amounts of natural gas from the country, leading to accusations that its government is putting its commercial interests first.

The Nord Stream 2 pipeline — built by Russia, with extensive German help — has been completed and is awaiting final regulatory approval. The project is set to double Russia's gas export capacity. 

But the United States has vowed the gas will never flow if Russia attacks.

Germany, on the other hand, has been non-committal about the pipeline's fate should that happen.

German soldiers are briefed as their equipment is unloaded at a railyard in Rukla, Lithuania. (Jason Ho/CBC)

The German battle group commander, however, insists the only considerations that matter for troop deployments are strategic ones — not economic. 

"The more forces you bring in, that can be perceived as a provocation and an increase of tensions. That is not our intent," said Ruppelt.

Lithuania sees 'credible military force' as right response

In an interview with CBC News in the capital of Vilnius, Lithuania's deputy defence minister emphatically rejected the logic that bolstering forces along NATO's eastern flank or directly helping Ukraine will inflame the situation and provoke Russia.

"I think deploying more troops to the eastern flank is the only right response to the current escalation," said Margiris Abukevičius.

"Some say this would continue the [Russian] escalation, but I really believe that the only thing that could stop the Russians from escalating further is credible military force on the other side."

Margiris Abukevičius is Lithuania's deputy minister of defence. (Jason Ho/CBC)

Abukevičius insisted his remarks should not be taken as criticism of the German NATO role in his country, which he says is deeply valued. "When it comes to Germany, we have full confidence. They are really one of the key contributors to our security and deterrence."

For Lithuania, the massive military presence now gathered on Russia's border with Ukraine, as well as in neighbouring Belarus, amounts to an existential threat.

Lithuania shares a 700-kilometre border with Belarus to the east, and a 300-kilometer border with Russia's European enclave, Kaliningrad, to the west.

Some signs Russia's moves go beyond military exercises

Along with its soldiers, Russia has also moved in mobile hospitals, pontoon bridges and its most sophisticated anti-missile interceptors, the S-400. None of those deployments are standard for typical exercises, say military experts.

The Gediminas Castle Tower is the most striking landmark in Lithuania's capital of Vilnius. (Chris Brown/CBC)

"I think this worries a lot of people, seeing how many Russian troops are gathered around; that this could go out of control and that it wouldn't stop in Ukraine," said Abukevičius.

Germany's insistence on not trying to agitate Moscow by keeping its troop levels consistent in eastern Europe is increasingly in contrast to several other NATO nations.

On Thursday, four F-16s from Denmark arrived at a NATO airbase in Lithuania to bolster the alliance's air-policing capabilities in the region. Lithuania's president was scheduled to hold a welcoming ceremony Friday for the 80 or so Danish personnel accompanying the aircraft.

The U.S., the U.K., Norway, Spain, France and the Czech Republic are also weighing sending more troops into eastern Europe.

Germany has also decided not to provide any lethal assistance directly to Ukraine, opting instead to send 5,000 helmets, along with medical supplies.

While the Ukrainian government has said it is satisfied with the level of German support, some inside the country are not. Kyiv mayor and former champion boxer Vitali Klitschko called the German offer "a joke" that left him "speechless."

Germany has also been criticized for holding up some shipments of anti-tank missiles that countries such as Estonia and Lithuania are trying to send to Ukraine, by not issuing permits for the German-origin weapons.

Canada resisting calls for combat support

In some ways, Germany's situation mirrors Canada's, which holds a command role at the NATO base next door, in Latvia.

The Trudeau government has also refused repeated requests from the Ukrainian government and pro-Ukraine groups at home to send armaments and is instead providing non-combat military trainers and intelligence assistance.

Foreign Affairs Minister Mélanie Joly visits with Canadian soldiers in Latvia in December 2021. (Stephanie Jenzer/CBC)

In the Baltics, there is overwhelming public support for a stronger NATO presence, says political scientist Margarita Šešelgytė, who teaches at Vilnius University.

"In the last year, 86 per cent of Lithuanians were very much in favour of us having these [NATO] forces. And there is a quite high percentage of Lithuanians thinking that these forces would help us to withstand Russian potential aggression," she said. 

"So it's a very big reassurance for the people who constantly feel unsafe due to Russia, and now, also, Belarus."

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Chris Brown

Foreign Correspondent

Chris Brown is a foreign correspondent based in the CBC’s London bureau. Previously in Moscow, Chris has a passion for great stories and has travelled all over Canada and the world to find them.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?

now