Mexico's missing students: Argentine experts doubt official story

A team of Argentine forensics experts is questioning Mexico's probe of the disappearance of 43 students, saying the evidence doesn't support the government's conclusion.

Government 'presented biased analyses' to support mass killing theory, report says

A forensic team from Argentina says the evidence doesn't support the Mexican government's theory that 43 missing students were killed at this garbage dump and their remains burned. (Rebecca Blackwell/Associated Press/File photo)

A team of Argentine forensics experts is questioning Mexico's probe of the disappearance of 43 students, saying the evidence doesn't support the government's conclusion and that it should be allowed to investigate all theories.

The Argentine Forensic Anthropologists team, hired on behalf of the victims' parents as an independent party, issued what it said was a list of discrepancies in the case. The team had access to forensic evidence and crime scenes along with federal prosecutors and Mexico's own forensic investigators.

Its statement said Mexico's government presented biased analyses of the scientific evidence to support its conclusion that the youths were killed, their bodies burned to ashes in Cocula in southern Guerrero state, and their remains thrown into a river to hide the evidence.

So far only one of the students has been identified from charred remains found at the river.

The team "would like to reiterate that it doesn't exclude the possibility that some of the students met the fate described by the attorney general," the experts said in the statement issued after they met with parents. "But in our opinion there is no scientific evidence to support that in the Cocula garbage dump."

The Attorney General's Office didn't respond Saturday to requests for comment on the statement from the Argentine team, which is a non-profit forensic science organization that investigates human rights violations around the world. It was established in 1984 to investigate cases of at least 9,000 who disappeared under Argentina's 1976-1983 military dictatorship.

Attorney General Jesus Murillo Karam said Jan. 27 that based on 39 confessions, 386 declarations, 487 forensic tests, 16 raids and two reconstructions, investigators concluded that municipal police arrested the youths in the city of Iguala on Sept. 26 and handed them over to the Guerreros Unidos cartel.

Conclusion questioned

The government alleges gang members killed the students, burned their corpses into the next day using a huge pyre and disposed of the ashes.

Many groups inside Mexico and abroad have questioned Murillo Karam's conclusion as implausible, including that the temperature of an open-air fire could reach that of a crematorium oven and turn 43 bodies to ash.

According to the Argentine team's statement, there was satellite evidence of many fires at the same dump in the last four years. The team found human remains at the dump that did not belong to the students, including a tooth belonging to a set of dentures. None of the students wore dentures.

The team noted the Attorney General's Office made mistakes in 20 genetic profiles collected from family members of the 43 students that made them unusable for DNA matches. It said such errors are unusual as the process of collecting material is simple.

The prosecutor's office also allowed the dump, a key crime scene, to go unguarded for several weeks, permitting anyone to plant or manipulate evidence, the team said.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?