World

Mexican officials believe they found real daughter after wrong girl returned to mother in Texas

Authorities may have located a girl taken by her father from Houston to Mexico eight years ago in a cross-border custody case that exploded into international headlines recently in a case of mistaken identity, an official said Monday.

Cross-border custody case exploded into international headlines recently after mistaken identity

Alondra Luna Nunez smiles after attending a press conference upon her arrival to the Guanajuato International Airport in Silao, Mexico on April 22. The 14-year-old Mexican girl, who was taken from her school by police and sent kicking and screaming to the U.S., returned home after DNA tests showed she is not related to an American woman searching for her missing daughter. (Mario Armas/Associated Press)

Authorities may have located a girl taken by her father from Houston to Mexico eight years ago in a cross-border custody case that exploded into international headlines recently in a case of mistaken identity, an official said Monday.

The girl presented herself at a court building accompanied by three relatives and identified herself as Alondra Diaz, a court official in the southwestern state of Michoacan told The Associated Press.

The official, who was not authorized to be quoted by name and spoke on condition of anonymity, said the court was evaluating the girl's paperwork and identity documents.

The whereabouts of Alondra Diaz, who turns 13 this year, have been unknown since 2007, when her father allegedly took her to Mexico without her mother's consent.

In April, a judge erroneously sent another girl named Alondra to be reunited with Houston resident Dorotea Garcia, who was convinced she was her long-lost daughter.

Video that circulated widely in social and traditional media showed Alondra Luna Nunez being taken kicking and screaming by police.

Girl mistakenly taken has 'calmed down' after ordeal

Days later, DNA testing in the United States proved that Alondra Luna was not Garcia's daughter, and she was returned to her family in Guanajuato, Mexico. The girl and her family had asked for a DNA examination before she was sent to Texas, but the judge said that was not within her authority and declined to order the test. Prosecutors are investigating the case.

Before arriving at the courthouse, the girl who identified herself as Alondra Diaz said in an interview with Univision that she was "saddened" by what had happened.

"Yes, I was content with my father, I was happy, but at the same time I felt that something was missing ... I have lacked the love of my mother because I have not seen her for so long," the girl said. "But I also want to be with my father."

Garcia, speaking to Univision from Houston, said she intended to withdraw the complaints she had filed against the father.

Susana Nunez, the mother of Alondra Luna who was mistakenly seized, sounded a note of caution after what she called a nightmare for her family.

"I hope the authorities simply make sure that this girl is truly her, that they have the right girl," Nunez told The Associated Press by phone.

If it turns out to be the right Alondra, she said, "I'm happy for her and her mother."

Nunez said her daughter is doing well following her ordeal, returning to school and resuming the usual life of a teenager.

"She has calmed down," Nunez said.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.