Release of Republican memo could have wide-ranging repercussions

Top U.S. intelligence and law enforcement officials warn that last week's release of a congressional memo alleging FBI surveillance abuse could have wide-ranging repercussions.

House panel votes to release Democratic memo on Russia probe

Top U.S. intelligence and law enforcement officials warn that last week's release of a congressional memo alleging FBI surveillance abuse could have wide-ranging repercussions. President Donald Trump sits with FBI Director Christopher Wray on Dec. 15, 2017, in Quantico, Va. (Evan Vucci/Associated Press)

Top U.S. intelligence and law enforcement officials warn that last week's release of a congressional memo alleging FBI surveillance abuse could have wide-ranging repercussions: Spy agencies could start sharing less information with Congress, weakening oversight. Lawmakers will try to declassify more intelligence for political gain. Confidential informants will worry about being outed on Capitol Hill.

The Republican memo released last week contends that when the FBI asked a secret court for a warrant to do surveillance on a former associate in then-candidate Donald Trump's campaign, the bureau relied too heavily on a dossier compiled by an ex-British spy whose opposition research was indirectly funded by Democrats.

Meanwhile, the House intelligence committee voted unanimously Monday night to release a Democratic rebuttal to the Republican's memo on the Russia investigation. The document now goes to Trump, who has five days to decide whether to declassify it.

Critics of the Republican memo's release accuse Rep. Devin Nunes of abusing his power as chairman of the House intelligence committee to do the president's bidding, and undermine the investigation into whether any Trump campaign associates colluded with Russian during the 2016 election. His office rebuts that claim, saying the real abuse of power was using unverified information bought and paid for by one political campaign to justify government surveillance of former Trump campaign foreign policy adviser Carter Page.

Nunes told Fox News on Monday, "We have a responsibility... to ensure Americans that the FISA process is not being abused, and that's what we did."

Devin Nunes, the Republican chairman of the House intelligence committee, says the memo will help 'to ensure Americans that the FISA process is not being abused.' (Reuters)

Former CIA Director Mike Hayden worries that the memo's release will damage congressional oversight and the effectiveness of law enforcement.

"We are chiseling away at processes and institutions on which we currently depend — and on which we will depend in the future," said Hayden, who has worked for both Democratic and Republican administrations.

Hayden, who also directed the National Security Agency, wrote an op-ed in The Cipher Brief, an online newsletter focused on intelligence issues, to urge Justice Department and intelligence professionals to speak out. He wondered, though, if they would, given Trump's penchant for honouring loyalty.

"A senior official in justice or a senior official in intelligence needs to say, 'We need to take a knee here. We need to take a deep breath"' Hayden said. "What we are now doing is destroying the institutions we need to keep America safe."

Josh Campbell, a former supervisory special agent with the FBI who investigated counterterrorism, recently resigned to do just that. Partisan attacks undermine the agency and national security, according to Campbell, who said he disagrees with colleagues who advised staying mum until the current controversy passes.

"FBI agents are dogged people who do not care about the direction of political winds," Campbell said in an editorial published Feb. 2 in The New York Times. "But to succeed in their work, they need public backing. Scorched-earth attacks from politicians with partisan goals now threaten that support, raising corrosive doubts about the integrity of the FBI that could last for generations."

Trump and the Controversial Memo

4 years ago
Does it back up the claim: that the so -called 'Deep State' is working against Donald Trump? Our Washington Correspondents panel weighs in. 14:39

FBI director Christopher Wray and the second-ranking official at the Justice Department, Rod Rosenstein, had urged Trump to keep the memo classified and out of public view, but the president declined. Last week, Trump attacked both agencies through his Twitter account, saying their leadership and investigators had "politicized the sacred investigative process in favour of Democrats and against Republicans."

Wray has defended the bureau and its agents throughout the memo controversy.

This isn't the first time intelligence has been politicized. Both Democrats and Republicans used the release of the so-called torture report in late 2015 outlining the CIA's detention and interrogation program as political ammunition. In the 1960s, while intelligence agencies warned that the Vietnam War was being lost, the White House was telling the public the opposite. During the George W. Bush administration, cherry-picked intelligence about Iraqi weapons of mass destruction fuelled momentum for the U.S. invasion of Iraq.

Republican Rep. Will Hurd, who is a member of the House intelligence committee, said the memo is not a rebuke of the FBI rank-and-file or special counsel Robert Mueller.

"The memo is about a process and what kinds of information should be used in order to allow the federal government to spy on Americans," said Hurd, a former covert CIA officer. "In my opinion, unverified information, circular reporting and rumours should not be used in an application to spy on American citizens. We should be protecting our civil liberties."

Robert Litt, the former general counsel for the director of national intelligence, said the future relationship between intelligence agencies and their congressional overseers has been put at risk.

"The precedent that's been set here is very dangerous," Litt said. "You can only imagine if the Democrats get control of the House in the mid-year election; they will now be able to say look, 'We've established a precedent here. You've released classified information, and we're going to start doing it as well."'

Is Trump creating a constitutional crisis worse than Watergate?

4 years ago
Trump is creating a constitutional crisis with his attacks on the FBI and the Department of Justice, say White House watchers. The CBC’s Wendy Mesley speaks to former Attorney General of New Jersey Anne Milgram who believes it may be worse than Watergate 5:53

Rep. Adam Schiff of California, the ranking Democrat on the House intelligence committee, said he too fears lawmakers will start seeking to disclose intelligence information in politically biased memos.

Schiff also worries that confidential sources could become more reluctant to provide information to U.S. intelligence agencies for fear that Congress could out them. Moreover, the American public could start wondering whether actions that law enforcement and intelligence agencies take to protect the country will be mischaracterized for political reasons, he said.

Ranking member of the House intelligence committee Adam Schiff speaks on Capitol Hill in Washington on Nov. 30. Schiff has called the Republican memo 'a political hit job on the FBI in the service of the president.' (Joshua Roberts/Reuters)

"I have to think that it's going to have a chilling effect on what they're willing to share with us," he said. "It's also going to be very demoralizing for people at the FBI to see them being used as a pinata for partisan reasons."

 Trump, in a post on Twitter on Monday, accused Schiff of leaking "confidential" information.

"Adam [Schiff] leaves closed committee hearings to illegally leak confidential information. Must be stopped!" Trump wrote.

Schiff responded with his own tweet: "Mr. President, I see you've had a busy morning of 'Executive Time.' Instead of tweeting false smears, the American people would appreciate it if you turned off the TV and helped solve the funding crisis, protected Dreamers or ... really anything else."

With files from Reuters