Hajj stampede: Iran blasts Saudi Arabia, accuses officials of 'ineptitude'

Saudi Arabia faced new accusations of neglect Friday in the hajj disaster that killed over 700 people, the second tragedy at this year's pilgrimage overseen by the kingdom's rulers who base their legitimacy in part on protecting Islam's holiest sites.

'If they had barred people from coming the other way, this would not have happened,' survivor says

An Iranian worshipper holds a poster of Iranian Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei and late revolutionary founder Ayatollah Khomeini during an anti-Saudi protest rally in Tehran on Friday. (Vahid Salemi/Associated Press)

Saudi Arabia faced new accusations of neglect Friday in the hajj disaster that killed over 700 people, the second tragedy at this year's pilgrimage overseen by the kingdom's rulers who base their legitimacy in part on protecting Islam's holiest sites.

Leading the criticism was regional Shia powerhouse Iran, which always seeks an opportunity to undermine its Sunni adversary.

Iranian President Hassan Rouhani said in New York that at least 140 Iranians were killed. He suggested that "ineptitude" by the Saudi authorities involved in organizing the hajj was to blame for the two accidents this month that have resulted in at least 830 deaths.

In Tehran, the Iranian Foreign Ministry summoned a Saudi envoy for the second time in as many days to hear protests over the incident, a vice-president blamed Saudi "mismanagement," and thousands marched in the streets and denounced the Saudi royal family.

Saudi Arabia has spent billions of dollars and undertaken massive construction projects to make the annual hajj safer for the world's Muslims, and the last serious loss of life had occurred nine years ago.

In the worst hajj disaster in a quarter century, two huge waves of pilgrims converged Thursday on a street near a religious site in Mina, and 719 people were crushed or trampled to death, while 863 were injured. That followed an accident Sept. 11 in which a storm toppled a crane at the Grand Mosque in Mecca that killed 111 people.

Witness blames Saudi guards

While Saudi authorities are still investigating Thursday's accident, Health Minister Khalid al-Falih has blamed it on the masses themselves, telling a Saudi broadcaster that "some pilgrims had moved in the wrong direction amid the crowds."

But a survivor who spoke to The Associated Press said some Saudi guards only exacerbated the stampede at Mina by refusing to open nearby gates that could have relieved the crush.

The street where the incident took place is about 12 metres wide and lined with barricades, behind which are tents of hajj tour groups. Pilgrims move in one direction to and from a religious complex, where they throw stones at pillars representing the devil. On Thursday, the crowds apparently collided with each other at an intersection, the Interior Ministry said.

Survivor Mahfouz el-Taweel of Egypt told the AP he was in the crowd packed shoulder to shoulder that collided on the same street with another mass of people coming from a different direction. Those in the back were unaware of this and pressed forward, causing a crush of bodies, trampling and a stampede, he said.

"If they had barred people from coming the other way, this would not have happened," he said.

"I'm coming to perform the hajj, not to die," el-Taweel added. "These people deserve compensation. It's not just enough to say God's will and call them martyrs."

He said Saudi Arabia should share responsibility for the hajj with a multinational force from some of the countries that send large numbers of pilgrims, such as Egypt.

Overcrowding creates dangerous Hajj conditions

7 years ago
Duration 6:33
Crowd control expert Keith Still talks about the deadliest tragedy at the annual Hajj pilgrimage

About two million pilgrims from more than 180 countries took part in this year's hajj, which ends Saturday.

Pakistan said eight of its pilgrims were killed in the accident, but 150 were still missing. Reports said at least 30 people were killed from Mali, 14 each from Egypt and India, five from Senegal, four from Turkey, and three each from Indonesia and Kenya.

The deaths of the Iranians ignited long-simmering anger Iran holds for Saudi Arabia over the authority the kingdom exerts over the hajj, especially after allegations in April that Saudi airport officials abused two male pilgrims from Iran.

Although hundreds of thousands of Iranians make religious trips to Saudi Arabia each year, Iran for a time stopped sending pilgrims. That came after Saudi security forces killed more than 400 people, mostly Iranians, in a 1987 clash sparked by protesting Iranian pilgrims.

Growing Iranian influence

Saudi Arabia fears the growth of Iranian political influence in the Middle East following the Islamic Republic's nuclear deal with world powers. In Yemen's civil war, a Saudi-led, U.S.-backed coalition supporting the country's exiled president is bombing Shia rebels there with links to Iran.

Hours after the hajj disaster, Iran's Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei urged Saudi authorities to accept responsibility for the tragedy, saying it was caused by "mismanagement." Iranian state-run media and government officials repeated that allegation Friday.

Iran's cabinet held an emergency meeting, and First Vice-President Ishaq Jahangiri said it was clear "the Saudi government is responsible for this disaster … and has to provide answers." He added that "mismanagement is definitely the cause" of the tragedy.

Thousands of demonstrators in Tehran chanted, "Death to the al-Saud family," and Iranian state TV showed similar protests in other Iranian cities.

Saudi emergency personnel stand near bodies of pilgrims after at least 717 were killed in a stampede, near the holy city of Mecca, at the annual hajj in Saudi Arabia on Thursday. (AFP/Getty)


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?