Germanwings Flight 4U9525 highlights lack of mandatory psychological tests for pilots

Questions surrounding the illness Germanwings co-pilot Andreas Lubitz reportedly hid from his employer have become the focus of the investigation into the crash of Flight 4U9525 and have some people asking whether mandatory psychological testing could have prevented the tragedy.

Andreas Lubitz, accused of deliberately crashing jet into mountains, apparently hid illness from airline

Andreas Lubitz, shown in a 2009 file photo from a Hamburg marathon, appears to have deliberately crashed Germanwings plane carrying 149 passengers into the French Alps. Lubitz received psychiatric treatment for a "serious depressive episode" six years ago, German tabloid Bild reported. (Foto-Team-Mueller/Reuters)

To the Dusseldorf crewmates who knew him, First Officer Andreas Lubitz gave no sign he was mentally unstable.

They didn't know about the torn-up doctor's note found in his home, or another sick note excusing him from flying the very day he crashed Germanwings Flight 9525 into the French Alps.

Lubitz had never come forward with any problems.

How and why the 27-year-old apparently hid his illness is now the focus of investigators and is also putting renewed scrutiny on pilot screening. Whether mandatory psychological tests could have prevented Lubitz from downing the airliner, killing all 150 people on board, is a question that will be explored in the coming weeks and months.

Must 'self-identify' psychological issues

All the rules governing international flights are based on standards set by the International Civil Aviation Organization, notes aviation safety expert Suzanne Kearns.

But Kearns, an associate professor who teaches about human factors and aviation safety at Western University, says those regulations largely focus on physical well-being and what to do in the event a pilot becomes incapacitated or suffers a heart attack in the air.

A pilot stands inside the cockpit during boarding for the Germanwings flight 4U9441, formerly flight 4U9525, from Barcelona to Dusseldorf. (Albert Gea/Reuters)

"You would get an electrocardiogram for your heart, audiograms for your hearing, they'd check your vision for colour-blindness, check your weight," she said.

"But there's not been much of a focus on mental health."

Pilots are only required to "self-identify" if they've been seeing doctors for mental health issues, as well as declare whether they're taking medication or dealing with mental problems.

For most pilots, who have spent years of studying and between $50,000 and $100,000 spent on flight-school training, there would be little incentive to do that, though.

"The reality is they all know if they lose their medical, they have no careers," Kearns said.

Hard to test for mental illness

French gendarmes and investigators work amongst the debris of the Germanwings Flight 4U9525at the site of the crash, near Seyne-les-Alpes, French Alps. (Emmanuel Foudrort/Reuters)

In Canada, annual physicals for commercial pilots are performed by Transport Canada-approved doctors.

Pilots 40 and older would be required to obtain a medical certificate every six months.

However, the most rigorous "category 1" medical certificates do not include a psychological testing component.

The international Aerospace Medical Association published a 2013 report recommending more mental health screening among pilots following the apparent mid-flight panic attack suffered by JetBlue captain Clayton Osbon.

While Philip Scarpa, president of the association, acknowledged "there's room for improvement" for mental health screening of pilots, he said "it's a nebulous topic because mental illness is hard to test for."

People pay their respects at a memorial for the victims in the village of Le Vernet, near the crash site, on Friday. (Robert Pratta/Reuters)

"Depression, anxiety, mania, alcohol and drug abuse -- those things can be asked about during periodic aeromedical exams," Scarpa said.

"The caveat is it needs to be effective, and trying to look for the serious sudden psychological diseases is not going to be effective."

Until psychological tests can be perfected and guarantee against false positives, he said, it would be difficult to begin grounding pilots.

Sick note not enough

During medical certificate assessments, a doctor can note down any suspected psychological triggers or symptoms in a "Remarks" section.

In Lubitz's case, however, doctor sick notes for an undisclosed illness would not have been enough to stop him from flying.

German police officers carry bags out of a house believed to belong to the parents of crashed Germanwings flight 4U 9524 co-pilot Andreas Lubitz in Montabaur on Wednesday. (Kai Pfaffenbach/Reuters)

That might only have been possible had he outed himself or admitted he was suffering from anxiety – something Kearns said pilots have a hard time acknowledging.

For its part, the Aerospace Medical Association suggests the adoption of "safe zones" designed to encourage pilots under psychological distress to self-report. These could go a long way towards changing the stigma surrounding mental illness, it says.

When his mother passed away, James Phillips, the international affairs director with the German Pilots Association, relied on an aviation support line.

I called and said, "I'm not fit to be in the cockpit...and my airline said, 'Take two weeks off. Call us when you feel better.- James Phillips, German Pilots Association

"I called and said, 'I'm not fit to be in the cockpit because I am concentrating on my mother,' and my airline said, 'Take two weeks off. Call us when you feel better,'" Phillips told CBC News Network.

"I think this should actually be the real way to go forward, but I realize it's based on a trust and honesty situation, which sometimes is very difficult."

Protecting privacy

Losing flight hours is another concern for younger pilots making meagre starting salaries, Kearns said.

If a pilot feels momentarily unsafe or unfit from a mental health perspective, it is hard to see how that wouldn't be perceived as a permanent career-ender, she said.

German police officers stand outside a house believed to belong to crashed Germanwings flight 4U 9524 co-pilot Andreas Lubitz in Montabaur. (Ralph Orlowski/Reuters)

As for how rules surrounding a pilot's mental health status would square with privacy, Minister of Transport Lisa Raitt told CBC News Network that Canada's Aeronautics Act includes provisions to ensure the privacy of a pilot is protected in such cases.

"There will be information given to the airline as to why their pilot doesn't have a certificate of fitness, but really the medical treatment — the dossier itself — is kept very private between the individual and the Transport Canada-affiliated doctor," she assured.

One way or another, Kearns expects aviation safety management systems will increasingly consider mental health disclosure guidelines in light of the Germanwings disaster.

"The reality is the culture will have to shift before anything can change, though," she said.

"Pilots have to learn mental health is not something you can tough out, or just grin and bear. It's something we need to encourage people to seek treatment for."

With files from CBC's Sima Zerehi


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?