China, Russia and Cuba win spots on UN Human Rights Council
Human rights groups criticized several nations who were among the 15 candidates for new seats on the council
China, Russia and Cuba won seats on the UN's premier human rights body Tuesday despite opposition from activist groups over their abysmal human rights records.
Russia and Cuba were running unopposed, but China and Saudi Arabia were in a five-way competition in the only contested race for seats on the Human Rights Council.
In that race, Pakistan received 169 votes, Uzbekistan 164, Nepal 150, China 139 and Saudi Arabia just 90 votes.
Despite announced reform plans by Saudi Arabia, Human Rights Watch said that nation continues to target human rights defenders, dissidents and women's rights activists — which include jailed former University of British Columbia student Loujian Alhathloul — and has demonstrated little accountability for past abuses, including the killing of Washington Post columnist and Saudi critic Jamal Khashoggi in the Saudi consulate in Istanbul two years ago.
Except for the Asia-Pacific contest, the election of 15 members to the 47-member Human Rights Council has been all but decided because all the other regional groups have uncontested slates.
Under the council's rules, seats are allocated to regions to ensure geographical representation. The body is composed of nations who've been elected to overlapping three-year terms.
Four countries won Africa seats: Ivory Coast, Malawi, Gabon and Senegal. Russia and Ukraine were the only candidates for two East European seats. In the Latin American and Caribbean group, Mexico, Cuba and Bolivia ran unopposed for three seats. And Britain and France are the sole candidates for two seats for the Western European and others group.
"We need for states to have a choice," said Louis Charbonneau, the UN director for Human Rights Watch. "They don't want competition.… Essentially these are backroom deals that are worked out among the regional groups.
"When states don't have a choice, the worst candidates easily find their way on to the council," he said at a briefing last week. "This is an unfortunate political reality, but we keep hammering the message that we need competition and a real election, not a fake election."
'Arsonists into the fire brigade': critic
Last week, a coalition of human rights groups from Europe, the United States and Canada called on UN member states to oppose the election of China, Russia, Saudi Arabia, Cuba, Pakistan and Uzbekistan, saying their human rights records make them "unqualified."
"Electing these dictatorships as UN judges on human rights is like making a gang of arsonists into the fire brigade," said Hillel Neuer, executive director of UN Watch.
The Geneva-based rights organization published a 30-page joint report with the Human Rights Foundation and the Raoul Wallenberg Center for Human Rights evaluating candidates for council seats. The report lists Bolivia, Ivory Coast, Nepal, Malawi, Mexico, Senegal and Ukraine as having "questionable" credentials due to problematic human rights and UN voting records that need improvement. It gave "qualified" ratings only to the United Kingdom and France.
Human Rights Watch pointed to an unprecedented call by 50 UN experts on June 26 for "decisive measures to protect fundamental freedoms in China," warning about its mass rights violations in Hong Kong and Tibet and against ethnic Uighurs in the Chinese province of Xinjiang as well as attacks on rights defenders, journalists, lawyers and government critics. Their call was echoed by over 400 civil society groups from more than 60 countries.
Conservative Party leader Erin O'Toole reacts:
By allowing these nations to take a lead role in the effort to police human rights abuses around the world, the UN has effectively given their actions a United Nations seal of approval. 3/4—@erinotoole
The rights group said Russia's military operations with the Syrian government "have deliberately or indiscriminately killed civilians and destroyed hospitals and other protected civilian infrastructure in violation of international humanitarian law," and noted Russia's veto of UN Security Council resolutions on Syria, including blocking Damascus's referral to the International Criminal Court.
The Geneva-based Human Rights Council can spotlight abuses and has special monitors watching certain countries and issues. It also periodically reviews human rights in every UN member country.
Created in 2006 to replace a commission discredited because of some members' poor rights records, the new council soon came to face similar criticism.
The United States announced its withdrawal from the council in June 2018 partly because it considered the body a forum for hypocrisy about human rights, though also because Washington says the council is anti-Israel.