World·Analysis

How one note from Lady Gaga told the story of Joe Biden's inauguration

In his inaugural address, Joe Biden spoke of the perennial challenges of racism and nativism that the U.S. has faced and appealed to a unity he acknowledged seemed "like a foolish fantasy these days." Moments earlier, Lady Gaga set the stage for that message by putting particular emphasis on a line in the U.S. national anthem celebrating the endurance of the republic.

New U.S. president calls for unity in a republic often tested by hatred

Lady Gaga sings The Star-Spangled Banner

CBC News

1 month ago
3:22
Pop star Lady Gaga sings the U.S. national anthem at Joe Biden's inauguration. 3:22

Music sometimes tells a story more succinctly than a speech and, on Wednesday, Lady Gaga managed to capture the story of Joe Biden's inauguration, and the sweep of American history, in just one note.

It lasted four soul-stirring seconds, deep into a performance of the U.S. national anthem for which the pop megastar strode to the stage gripping a golden microphone and sporting an oversized peace-symbolizing dove lapel pin. 

Gaga gestured across a balcony that two weeks ago was filled by an angry mob attacking the Capitol. In that moment, she improvised on the anthem's melody, slid up a half-tone to a C sharp and held it there in a lung-depleting extended finale to the line celebrating the endurance of the American republic:

"That our flag was still theeeeee-eeeeeere."

It so happens that the author of that anthem, Francis Scott Key, was also a notoriously committed slaveholder who not only aggressively prosecuted but even sought to execute abolitionists, the unheralded heroes of his time.

This slaver's poem rang out Wednesday over the National Mall in a ceremony where a Black and South Asian woman, Kamala Harris, became the vice-president of the United States.

And there's the story of America in four seconds.

WATCH | Republican strategist says Trumpism an 'ongoing problem':

Republican strategist says Trumpism an 'ongoing problem'

World

1 month ago
9:02
The co-founder of The Lincoln Project, a group of Republicans dedicated to preventing the re-election of Donald Trump, says the former president still 'owns the Republican party.' Rick Wilson believes a split within the party is almost inevitable. 9:02

It's a place that has repeatedly suffered political violence, has often had its politics embittered by racial hatred and inequality, and yet manages to break some barriers, on occasion faster than many nations around the world whose residents revel in judging it.

A call to unity

Biden took the podium later.

The new president used his inaugural address to tell that same story. Biden's version, unlike Lady Gaga's, lasted 2,500 words, but like Gaga's, it gained unusual poignancy after the democracy-testing events of the last few weeks.

It was a call to unity that didn't gloss over the nation's imperfections. In fact, Biden embedded America's failures squarely in his message.

"I know speaking of unity can sound to some like a foolish fantasy these days. I know the forces that divide us are deep, and they are real, but I also know they are not new," Biden said. 

"Our history has been a constant struggle between the American ideal that we are all created equal and the harsh, ugly reality that racism, nativism, fear, demonization have long torn us apart. The battle is perennial, and victory is never assured."

WATCH | Biden's full inaugural address at Wednesday's inauguration:

U.S. President Joe Biden tells Americans 'we're going to need each other'

Politics News

1 month ago
1:36
In his inauguration speech, U.S. President Joe Biden asked Americans to "set aside politics and finally face this pandemic as one nation." 1:36

Democracy prevailed after Jan. 6, says Biden

He referred to the Jan. 6 attack and described this year's troubled transition of power as a moment of triumph for the battle-tested 232-year-old republic.

"Democracy is precious. Democracy is fragile. And at this hour, my friends, democracy has prevailed," Biden said.

Of course, calls to unity are usually more easily pronounced than achieved. 

And the country is dredged in reminders that Biden's desire to unify the country faces towering and perhaps insurmountable obstacles.

Biden said politics need not be a raging, goodwill-consuming fire and that adversaries should be capable of disagreeing without detesting each other.

"We can treat each other with dignity and respect," he said. "We can join forces, stop the shouting and lower the temperature. For without unity, there is no peace, only bitterness and fury; no progress, only exhausting outrage; no nation, only a state of chaos." 

Lady Gaga sings the U.S. national anthem with Joe Biden looking on at his inauguration Wednesday. She seemed to linger on one note in particular, laden with meaning. (Kevin Lamarque/Reuters)

Yet the desire for political combat runs deep.

Even this saccharine speech from Biden drew a reprimand from one of the country's upstart right-wing media organizations, Newsmax, where an anchor called it dark and divisive.

A top congressional Republican tweeted congratulations to Biden and was flooded with angry replies from across the political spectrum.  

Republicans who voted to certify Biden's election win are being threatened with primaries by pro-Trump rivals who intend to unseat them in 2022. 

More than half of the party's lawmakers in the House of Representatives have joined a challenge to strip Liz Cheney from her leadership role as chair of the House Republican conference after she voted to impeach Donald Trump.

The coming weeks will be a big test. And not just because Trump's impeachment trial will loom over the Senate's activities.

WATCH | The day's most memorable moments:

Highlights of inauguration day

CBC News

1 month ago
1:05
Joe Biden became the 46th president of the United States on Wednesday with ceremonies that were scaled back due to the coronavirus pandemic and heightened security measures arising from the riot at the U.S. Capitol earlier this month. 1:05

The coming test to the unity message

Biden burst out of the gate with a barrage of executive orders that include rejoining the World Health Organization and the Paris climate accord, cancelling the Keystone XL pipeline, imposing new mask-wearing rules on federal property and restoring the so-called DACA program protecting immigrants who were brought illegally into the U.S. as children.

Signing orders is easy.

The harder-to-achieve, more durable, change in American politics comes in law, through bills passed through two chambers of Congress. 

Trump supporters storm the U.S. Capitol on Jan. 6 in an effort to stop the official certification of Biden's election victory. (Samuel Corum/Getty Images)

The first bill Biden intends to suggest involves immigration, and it would provide a path to legal residency and then citizenship for millions of people.

That proposal will land like a political grenade on the other side of the aisle. 

Immigration, perhaps more than any other issue in recent years, has been the one that most enrages the Republican base. 

Trump recognized that anger and milked it. That's why Trump went from agreeing with a softer approach on immigration reform, in the early 2010s, to campaigning to restrict immigration in 2015-16.

So it's far from assured this debate will go smoothly, and far from certain an immigration bill will gain enough Republican votes in the Senate to overcome a 60-vote filibuster override.

The fact that Democrats now control both chambers of Congress and the White House now gives them at least a chance to introduce bills and try getting them passed.

Kamala Harris bumps fists with Biden after she was sworn in as Vice President of the United States. (Jonathan Ernst/Reuters)

Inaugural addresses: Hits and misses

Some inaugural addresses have proven successful predictors of the era ahead. For instance, Ronald Reagan called for less government and lower taxes in 1981, and it generally happened; he called for peace with the Soviets in 1985, and the Berlin Wall fell in 1989.

In 1933, Franklin Roosevelt promised a program of job-creating actions during the Great Depression, and he delivered, in a radical few months of transformation.

Other speeches are half-prophetic. Donald Trump's in 2017 is one notable example.

In a message of national unity, Biden invited former presidents to a ceremony at the Arlington military cemetery Wednesday. In a sign of the challenge in uniting the country, Donald Trump skipped the event to leave early for Florida. (Tom Brenner/Reuters)

Trump's so-called American carnage speech promised a more nationalist, America First approach to government — and it happened.

On the other hand, Trump also promised to fight against well-connected insiders, yet Trump spent his last day in office relaxing rules for lobbyists and pardoning a number of well-connected and wealthy criminals convicted of corruption. 

Other speeches tragically fail to capture the reality ahead.

Abraham Lincoln also called for unity in 1861: "We are not enemies, but friends. We must not be enemies," he said, urging Americans to heed the better angels of their nature. What followed was a devastating four-year civil war.

Lincoln urged unity again in 1865, asking Americans to put aside the bitterness of that war and find charity, not malice,  in their hearts for former enemies. He was killed a month later; the country wrestled for decades with the war's consequences.  

Some of the rhetoric from Trump's 2017 inaugural address, above, panned out; but not all of it. (Alex Wong/Getty Images)

Whatever happens, Biden has already begun adding to an old story. From the country's founding, partisan tension has threatened to split it apart.

Thomas Jefferson also urged unity in his 1801 inauguration speech at a time when it appeared the then-new nation might not make it. Jefferson referred to the two political factions of the day and urged Americans not to allow differences of opinion tear them apart. 

"We are all Republicans," said the writer of the Declaration of Independence. "We are all Federalists."

On Wednesday, Biden mentioned Jefferson's most memorable words in the American Declaration of Independence — the idea that all men were created equal, endowed with equal rights.

Jefferson, of course, was also a slave holder, so much of a slave holder that, unlike some others in his era, he refused to allow his slaves to be freed upon his death.

It's a complicated place. 

And, as Biden acknowledged in his first moments as the 46th president, it's a complicated story. One not always as sweet as Lady Gaga's floating C sharp.

      1 of 0

      About the Author

      Alexander Panetta is a Washington-based correspondent for CBC News who has covered American politics and Canada-U.S. issues since 2013. He previously worked in Ottawa, Quebec City and internationally, reporting on politics, conflict, disaster and the Montreal Expos.

      Comments

      To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

      By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

      now