World

U.S. defeats Canada in first dispute under new North American trade pact

Canada has lost its first dispute case under the new North American trade agreement to the United States. A panel found that Ottawa flouted part of its obligation to open the dairy market. Now the U.S. says Canada could face tariffs if it doesn't fix the problem.

The issue is dairy. U.S. says Canada not fairly implementing changes it promised, and could face tariffs

Wisconsin dairy farmer Dave Daniels is seen in this photo taken last year. The U.S. says complex Canadian rules made it hard for Americans to export the amounts they were promised under the new North American trade deal. (Alex Panetta/CBC)

This item is part of Watching Washington, a regular dispatch from CBC News correspondents reporting on U.S. politics and developments that affect Canadians. 

What's new

Canada has lost the first-ever dispute case under the new North American trade agreement, with a panel siding with the U.S. and saying Ottawa flouted part of its obligation to open the dairy market.

The three-member panel — made up of a Uruguayan diplomat who was once ambassador to Canada, a Canadian trade lawyer based in the U.S., and a U.S. trade lawyer named to the panel by Canada — agreed that Canada violated its promise to allow slightly more dairy imports by imposing unfairly complicated rules.

The U.S. says Canada now has a few weeks to comply with the ruling, or face the possibility of a trade penalty such as a tariff.

The finding comes amid a succession of trade disputes between the countries that risk souring the bilateral relationship. 

"We prevailed — as we thought we would," a senior official in the U.S. Trade Representative's office told reporters in a briefing Tuesday. 

"Now the goal is to work with Canada.… The end goal is not to put retaliatory tariffs in place." 

The report was released to the countries in a full confidential version just before the holidays, on Dec. 20; a 53-page public version was released Tuesday.

The Canadian government also claimed a partial victory: It noted that the panel otherwise upheld Canada's system of supply management of its dairy sector. 

What's the context

Dairy was one of the hardest-fought issues in negotiating the new Canada-U.S.-Mexico Agreement on trade (CUSMA), and was resolved in the final days of negotiating.

The Canadian government worked to prevent new imports, under pressure from producers concentrated in Central Canada.

They argued that Canada's tightly controlled system allows for stable farming communities without the wild price fluctuations that have periodically battered U.S. farms.

For the U.S., exporting more dairy was a top priority.

Its allies argued that the tight Canadian controls unfairly shut out competition, and innovation, and can lead to higher prices for consumers.

In the end, the U.S. gained a small opening.

A series of measures in Chapter 3 of the new trade agreement allowed the U.S. some additional exports to the tune of more than three per cent of Canada's market.

But when it came time to implement the agreement, Canada left domestic processors in charge of allocating import permissions, known as tariff-rate quotas.

This angered the U.S. industry and government: both the Trump administration and the Biden administration moved forward with a case against Canada.

They argued that by giving Canadian producers control over 80 per cent of the import quotas they created an undue hurdle to cross-border sales.

One USTR official put it this way in Tuesday's briefing: an American producer would hope to talk directly to their customer in Canada, say a grocery store, about import rights, instead of their competitors.

He said those buyers in Canada, and their customers, have an incentive to allow imports to flow — unlike the producers.

The first panel decision under the new trade pact agreed with the U.S.; it said Canada violated Article 3.A.2.11(b) of the agreement, which says tariff-rate quotas should not be allocated to producer groups. 

WATCH | Canada threatens U.S. with tariffs over EV tax credit dispute:

Canada threatens U.S. with tariffs over EV tax credit dispute

5 months ago
Duration 2:02
In a letter to top U.S. senators, Deputy Prime Minister Chrystia Freeland and Trade Minister Mary Ng threatened to impose tariffs on American goods and suspend parts of the USMCA trade agreement unless U.S. officials scrap a proposed electric vehicle tax credit.

What's next

The U.S. says Canada has 45 days to comply, from the time it received the confidential panel report. In other words, until Feb. 3, 2022.

After that, the U.S. says it would have the right to impose penalties — perhaps a tariff. 

The scope of that penalty would have to be equivalent to the value of the damage allegedly done to American dairy producers.

It would be up to the U.S. to calculate that dollar amount, and if Canada disagrees it could further challenge the U.S. calculation.

"Of course we hope not to go down that path," said a U.S. official at Tuesday's briefing. "We obviously want to talk to them. And find a positive solution to the dispute."

The Americans at the briefing stressed that the U.S. otherwise has a great relationship with Canada, in other areas.

However, this dispute decision comes at a stormy moment in the relationship.

Canada has, itself, threatened to suspend pieces of the new trade deal that are dear to the U.S.

Ottawa is furious about Buy American-type provisions related to electric vehicles in a large budget bill and promising retaliation if the idea proceeds.

That separate dispute is currently in limbo: one senator, Joe Manchin, has blown up talks over the budget bill and wants to start all over. 

The Canadian government said in a statement that it has "taken note" of the decision, takes its obligations seriously under trade agreements and will work with the Canadian dairy industry on next steps.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Alexander Panetta is a Washington-based correspondent for CBC News who has covered American politics and Canada-U.S. issues since 2013. He previously worked in Ottawa, Quebec City and internationally, reporting on politics, conflict, disaster and the Montreal Expos.

Add some “good” to your morning and evening.

A variety of newsletters you'll love, delivered straight to you.

Sign up now

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?

now