China sentences activist lawyer to 12 years on fraud charges
Sentence is a 'warning to human rights lawyers that they must toe the party line,' says researcher
A Chinese lawyer who defended activists and others involved in politically sensitive cases was sentenced to 12 years in prison Thursday on fraud charges, his lawyers said, in what is believed to be the harshest penalty handed down in years against those few willing to take on the ruling Communist Party.
- ANALYSIS | Trudeau welcomes Chinese Premier Li Keqiang warmly but cautiously
- Chinese Premier Li Keqiang set for bilateral talks with Trudeau
Xia Lin was sentenced Thursday by the Beijing No. 2 Intermediate Court, nearly two years after being detained, lawyer Ding Xikui said.
"We've been striving to defend his innocence," Ding said. "Even one day in prison is too much."
There was no immediate comment from the court. Ding said Xia planned to file an appeal.
Xia's sentence appeared to be the heaviest for a government critic since economist and Uighur minority rights advocate Ilham Tohti was sentenced in 2014 to life imprisonment on separatism charges after he made calls for Chinese-Uighur reconciliation and greater economic justice.
It came amid a string of recent cases and subversion trials demonstrating the Communist Party's determination to silence independent human rights activists and government critics. But the most those accused received was 7 1/2 years.
By comparison, Nobel Peace Prize winner Liu Xiaobo, identified by the party as an existential threat to its rule, is serving an 11-year sentence for subversion.
"The harsh sentence against Xia Lin sends the sternest warning yet to the community of human rights lawyers that they must toe the party line," said Maya Wang, a Hong Kong-based researcher with Human Rights Watch.
Wang said president and party leader Xi Jinping has made clear that, despite its calls for strengthened rule of law, the party intends to use the legal system to enforce its uncontested rule. "Anyone who challenges this aspiration will not be tolerated."
Human rights network defended Xia
Ding and advocacy group Network of Chinese Human Rights Defenders said the charges against Xia, who was born in 1970, related to money he borrowed from friends, who asserted they loaned it freely and had not brought legal complaints against him. He was accused of defaulting on that debt, but no convincing evidence was provided, they said.
"He had indeed borrowed money from people, but it is just normal borrowing and lending money," Ding said.
- Trudeau says Canada has 'extremely high standards' for extradition treaty with China
- Trudeau's security adviser approved the removal of China's 'economic fugitives'
The Network of Chinese Human Rights Defenders said Xia was detained on Nov. 8, 2014, as he began preparing to defend Guo Yushan, the head of a Chinese think-tank, the Transition Institute. It said Guo had been detained a month earlier for supporting the Occupy Central pro-democracy movement in the semi-autonomous Chinese region of Hong Kong.
The group said that, lacking evidence of fraud, investigators instead focused on Xia's association with government critics, including artist and human rights activist Ai Weiwei, whose design company, Beijing Fake Cultural Development Ltd., he helped defend from a demand for $1.85 million US in back taxes and fines brought in 2011 that was widely seen as a further form of government harassment following Ai's illegal detention earlier that year. Ai ultimately lost the case, despite claims of widespread legal irregularities.
"The numerous legal violations, not least the length of time it took to bring Xia to trial, demonstrate the flimsiness of the authorities' case. Xia Lin should be freed on Thursday and compensated for his time in detention," human rights researcher Frances Eve said in a statement.
Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman Lu Kang discounted such accusations, saying such groups likely didn't represent mainstream opinion about China in the international community.
Xia's case "falls within China's internal affairs ... and will be handled in accordance with law," Lu said.
President Xi's campaign against dissent began gathering steam in the summer of 2015, when about 300 activists and lawyers were initially seized in a roundup and questioned before most were released.
But more than a dozen of those detained last year remain in custody, their legal fates still unknown.