Ben Carson on Donald Trump's heels, poll suggests

Heading into Wednesday night's Republican debate, candidate Ben Carson finds himself alongside Donald Trump atop the field of candidates seeking the party's presidential nomination.

Brain surgeon heads into 2nd Republican presidential candidates' debate placing 2nd polls

Republican presidential candidate Dr. Ben Carson, a retired brain surgeon, is catching up to billionaire Donald Trump in the polls. (Leonard Ortiz/Orange County Register/Associated Press)

Amid all the bombast in the Republican race for president, Ben Carson comes across more like a whisper.

He is, in some ways, the anti-Trump — a gentle candidate who lets his record as a renowned brain surgeon speak for itself. The bragging about his resume and place in the polls, on the rare occasions it comes, is delivered with none of the superlatives that Donald Trump can't seem to go without.

Yet the 63-year-old, the only black Republican seeking the White House in 2016, has tapped into the same wave of anti-establishment outrage fuelling the billionaire reality TV star's rise.

"The likelihood of someone like me getting through this process and making it to president is virtually impossible," Carson told The Associated Press in a recent interview. "I just have to be myself. And if being myself resonates with the American people, then they will choose me.

"And if it doesn't," he said, "they will choose somebody else."

Like Trump, Carson was dismissed early as a gaffe-prone novice lacking a national profile and any significant political network. But he appears to be connecting with Republican voters at a rate that even his closest aides didn't predict.

Heading into Wednesday night's second debate of the Republican contest, Carson finds himself alongside Trump atop the field.

A New York Times/CBS News poll released Tuesday shows Carson favoured by 23 per cent of likely Republican primary voters compared to Trump's 27 per cent. Former Florida governor Jeb Bush and Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker, meanwhile, have plummeted to six per cent and two per cent, respectively.

The poll of 1,021 voters was conducted Sept. 9 to 13 on cellphones and landlines and has a margin of sampling error of plus or minus six percentage points for Republican and Democratic primary voters, according to the New York Times.

The poll found that 63 per cent said they could change their minds before the primaries begin with the Iowa caucuses in February.

Yet it was just one of several in recent days that feature the political rookies Trump and Carson leading a field of veterans of elected office, offering the clearest example yet that Republican voters have deep frustrations with the political establishment.

The latest Reuters-Ipsos opinion poll has Trump leading among Republican voters with 32.2 per cent. Retired neurosurgeon Ben Carson was at 15.8 per cent, former Florida Governor Jeb Bush at nine per cent. The rest of the field below six per cent. (Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images)

It shows in Carson's fundraising, too. His campaign says it has raised $5 million so far this month, adding to the $9 million it pulled in during July and August — a strong performance at what is typically one of the hardest times for candidates to raise money.

Wednesday night offers Carson a new chance to build on that momentum. A stage full of Republican candidates will face off at the Reagan Presidential Library for the party's second formal debate. Carson emerged from the first as a surprise success, his popularity fuelled by his nice guy image on a night when his competitors came out swinging.

Yet he remains rough around the edges and has little experience with issues beyond health care and business, particularly foreign policy in an election where international affairs are a major part of the discussion.

Trump will be Trump, Ben will be Ben, and the contrast couldn't be clearer.- Barry Bennett, Ben Carson's campaign manager

"He's memorized every nerve in the body, he can memorize the top 12 terrorists in the world," said Carson campaign manager Barry Bennett, dismissing any concerns.

His team hopes to use any additional airtime he'll get Wednesday night to highlight Carson's biography.

He rose from the streets of inner-city Detroit to be head of pediatric neurosurgery at Baltimore's Johns Hopkins Hospital. The story inspired a television movie and gives Carson unique standing in a Republican Party often criticized as the party of older, wealthy, white men.

Carson briefly focused on race late last week by touring Ferguson, Mo., the St. Louis suburb hit by rioting after a white police officer shot a black teen. After the tour, however, Carson condemned the "Black Lives Matter" movement and said the nation should "de-emphasize race" and instead "emphasize respect."

Carson: 'All lives matter'

A religious conservative, Carson said he'd prefer the movement change its name to "All black lives matter" — to include the unborn children of black women who have abortions. Better yet, he said, the group would change its name to simply, "All lives matter."

He's expected to focus on party unity on the debate stage after declining to respond to his competitors' jabs in recent days.

"Trump will be Trump, Ben will be Ben, and the contrast couldn't be clearer," Bennett said.

In contrast to other campaigns, no one has been playing Trump during Carson's debate preparation sessions, which are somewhat unusual. Bennett described an all-day "knowledge session" Monday in which experts delivered presentations on various domestic and foreign policy topics.

"They don't pepper him with questions, he peppers them," the campaign manager said.

And while Carson doesn't focus on race, his campaign suggests his status as the only black person in the contest is a political asset.

"In a crowd of 17 candidates, it is important that you can differentiate yourself in as many ways as possible," Bennett said. "He's soft-spoken, he's African-American and he's a doctor."

The campaign has begun running TV ads in Iowa and New Hampshire promoting Carson's biography. And it's looking to expand a paid staff of 80 now divided between the campaign's suburban Washington headquarters and early voting states across the country.

The political establishment remains skeptical of his chances, but Carson doesn't seem to mind.

"My whole life people have told me you can't do this, no one's ever done this before, this is impossible," he said. "I don't even get charged up until I hear those words."


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?