News

TikTok debuts new voice — after Canadian actor sues over the old one

Users of the social media app TikTok noticed a new female voice narrating their videos on Monday, about three weeks after a Canadian actor filed a lawsuit against the video-sharing platform for copyright violation. 

'They replaced me with another voice,' says Bev Standing

Voice actor Bev Standing says the social media app TikTok used her voice to narrate videos without her permission. (Doug Husby/CBC)

Users of the social media app TikTok noticed a new female voice narrating their videos on Monday, about three weeks after a Canadian actor filed a lawsuit against the video-sharing platform for copyright violation. 

Bev Standing, a voice actor based in Welland, Ont., is suing TikTok's parent company, China-based ByteDance, on the claim that recordings of her voice are being used without permission. 

"They replaced me with another voice," said Standing, who learned about it by email, her first tip to the change coming from a journalist. New videos feature the new voice, the previous one remains on older videos.

Legal experts say the move is an acknowledgement by the company that Standing may have suffered harm as a result of the videos, but that it does not necessarily mean TikTok will settle the case. 

Standing has been doing voice-overs for commercials, corporate videos and more as a full-time freelancer since 2014.   

CBC News asked TikTok about the voice change, but the company did not comment on it or the case. 

TikTok in late 2020 introduced a new feature that converts text typed into the app into a voice which is played over the videos. ( Drew Angerer/Getty Images)

There is no mention of the change in the company's newsroom online. Standing says neither she nor her lawyer have heard from TikTok about it.

"I am so overwhelmed by this whole thing. I'm stumbling for words, because I just don't know what to say," she said. 

The case history 

Her case was filed in a New York State court in early May. She says TikTok has used her voice in videos seen around the world since late 2020. 

According to Standing, a computer-generated version of her voice was built into a feature that converts text typed into the app into a voice which is then played over the videos. 

She thinks the company got her voice from recordings she says she did for the Institute of Acoustics, a research organization of the Chinese government, in 2018.

WATCH | Voice actor sues TikTok's owners:

Canadian suing TikTok owners for using her voice

The National

1 month ago
2:12
A Canadian woman is suing the company that owns TikTok after discovering it is using her voice to narrate videos without her permission. 2:12

The job was reading thousands of English sentences she says she was told would be used for translation.   

Standing believes these recordings came into TikTok's possession and were used to generate the text-to-speech narration.

The change is a good sign for Standing's case, according to an expert in copyright law.

"It's a positive step in the way that they are mitigating their damages," said Pina D'Agostino, an associate professor with Osgoode Hall Law School at York University. 

"And when you're mitigating, you're acknowledging that we did something wrong, and you're trying to make things better."

It could signal TikTok is going to move toward a settlement, said D'Agostino, in part because the case might look bad on the company.

Business law expert Daniel Tsai doubts TikTok is feeling much pressure to settle the case. (James Dunne/CBC)

If there is a settlement negotiation, she says Standing and her lawyer should try to secure the deletion of her files from TikTok's archive, the removal of the videos that have her voice on them or the replacement of her voice on those videos, plus financial compensation. 

Daniel Tsai, a tech executive and business law expert in Toronto who has advised the federal government on intellectual property law, agrees the new voice could help Standing's case.

But he doubts TikTok is feeling much pressure to settle, noting the company does not appear to be losing any revenue or users from the case.  

He says that means using a new voice from now on could be the only concession TikTok makes, unless forced by a judgment.  

Tsai says, if TikTok did use Standing's voice, "removing the existing recordings will be akin to taking away a smoking gun from a crime scene," in the eyes of a judge. 

"If I was their counsel, I would advise against that," he said.

Tsai says the case is unlikely to be settled unless it's just before proceedings begin. 

Standing says she's eager for the case to be over and get back to the daily work she loves.

TikTok has until July 7 to respond to her claim.

Pina D'Agostino, an expert in copyright law, says TikTok's new voice could signal the company is moving toward a settlement. (Submitted by Pina D'Agostino)

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

James Dunne

Producer, CBC News Business

James Dunne researches, produces and writes stories for the business unit at CBC News. He has a decade of experience in business programming, including on the shows Venture and Fortune Hunters. An award-winning videojournalist, he's also worked on special projects and as the late lineup editor for the World at Six on CBC Radio One.

With files from Thomas Daigle

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversationCreate account

Already have an account?

now