New hominin species may have lived alongside 'Lucy'
Not everyone believes the fossils represent a new species
Jaw and teeth fossils found on the silty clay surface of Ethiopia's Afar region represent a previously unknown member of humankind's family tree that lived 3.3 to 3.5 million years ago alongside the famous human ancestor "Lucy," scientists say.
The fossils shed new light on a key period in the human lineage's evolution before the emergence of our genus Homo and provide the first evidence that two early human ancestor species lived at the same time and place prior to 3 million years ago, they said in announcing the discovery on Wednesday.
The new species, Australopithecus deyiremeda, combined ape-like and human-like traits as did Lucy's species, Australopithecus afarensis, but was sufficiently different to warrant recognition as a separate species, they said.
Lucy's skeleton was unearthed in 1974 about 50 km (30 miles) from the new fossils' location.
The new species' cheekbone position and generally small tooth size likely made it look more like our genus than did Lucy's species, said Cleveland Museum of Natural History paleoanthropologist Yohannes Haile-Selassie, who led the study published in the journal Nature.
The scientists found upper and lower jaws and teeth from at least three individuals, but no other remains. They previously found a 3.4 million-year-old partial fossil foot and "cannot rule out" that it belongs to the new species, Haile-Selassie said.
- Ancient hominin Little Foot lived alongside Lucy's species
- Newly discovered pre-human walked near 'Lucy'
Compared to Lucy, the new species had a more robust lower jaw, cheek bones further forward on the upper jaw, molars with thicker enamel and relatively small upper and lower cheek teeth, said paleoanthropologist Stephanie Melillo of the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology's Department of Human Evolution in Germany.
Would have been rivals
One unanswered question is how Lucy's species and the new one managed to co-exist.
"They would have been rivals if they were exploiting the same resources or had similar foraging strategies," Haile-Selassie said.
Dental differences suggest they had different diets, meaning they may not have competed for the same resources. Another human relative, Kenyanthropus platyops, also lived relatively nearby in Kenya.
Our species, Homo sapiens, appeared 200,000 years ago. The earliest known member of our genus lived 2.8 million years ago. Scientists previously had argued there was only one human ancestor at any time between 4 and 3 million years ago, each giving rise to another new species.
"The story is becoming more complicated as more branches are added to the human phylogenetic tree," Melillo said.
Some scientists doubtful
Bernard Wood of George Washington University, who didn't participate in the new work, told the Associated Press that the discovery provides "compelling evidence" that a second creature lived in the vicinity of Lucy's species at the same time. The next question, he said, is how they shared the landscape.
"These fossils certainly create an agenda for a lot of interesting research that's going to be done in the next decade," Wood said.
As evidence that the new fossils represent a previously unknown species, the researchers cite specific anatomical differences with known fossils. But Tim White, a University of California, Berkeley, expert in human evolution, was unimpressed.
He told the Associated Press he thinks the fossils actually come from Lucy's species.
"Anatomical variation within a biological species is normal," he said in an email. "That's why so many announcements of this sort are quickly overturned."
With files from the Associated Press