Virtual reality: The difference between a $20 and $1,100 VR headset

Facebook, Google and Samsung are among the companies offering new virtual reality headsets and experiences at prices ranging from $20 to $1,100. How do they differ — and are they worth the price? CBC's Anand Ram has a look.

How Google Cardboard, Samsung Gear VR, HTC Vive and Oculus Rift compare

CBC's Anand Ram tries out the Samsung Gear VR heaset. It has straps to keep the device mounted to your face and touch controls and buttons add a layer of interactivity. (Courtesy Anand Ram/CBC)

At technology shows like this week's Mobile World Congress in Barcelona, there's a good chance an oddly shaped visor will be strapped to your head and pressed against your eyes in an effort to make your mouth drop wide open.

The virtual reality renaissance is already here. And for the budding VR industry, this year could mean the difference between winning or withering away.

Winning means convincing a lot of people — not just to smile or gasp or laugh, but to walk away with a readiness to spend money — perhaps hundreds of dollars — and bring that experience home.

Facebook, Google and Samsung are just a few of the big companies hoping to do that, at prices ranging from $20 to more than $800. But how do these experiences differ — and are they worth the price?

Google Cardboard

At around $20, Google Cardboard is VR at its cheapest and most practical: a piece of cardboard with some plastic lenses. Put an Android smartphone or iPhone inside, start up any number of Cardboard-ready apps and you're ready to go. (Almost any smartphone will do — my two-year-old Nexus 5 handled it just fine.)

At around $20, Google Cardboard is VR at its cheapest and most practical: a piece of cardboard with some plastic lenses. Put a smartphone inside, start up any number of Cardboard-ready apps and you're ready to go. (Anand Ram/CBC)

The VRSE app is one of the most impressive examples on Cardboard. It offers VR experiences like being at the 40th anniversary special of Saturday Night Live. Rather than paying attention to Will Ferrell as Alex Trebek, I found myself moving my head to take in the awkward smiles of the crowd during a dud or staring at the cue card holders.

Google's own Cardboard app has some neat offerings, including a "urban hike" through some of the world's most famous landmarks. It's not the same thing as physically being at the Eiffel Tower, but you can still look up in amazement.

In that sense, Google Cardboard is passive VR. You're mostly an observer, albeit with a larger field of vision than say, a movie. Being handheld, it's also not the most comfortable, which could affect your sense of immersion.

Samsung Gear VR

A $140 step up from Google Cardboard is Samsung's Gear VR. The concept is similar, with a smartphone and two lenses powering the virtual reality. The headgear is the key difference.

For now, Gear VR only works with four models of Samsung smartphones. (Anand Ram/CBC)

Built in collaboration with Oculus VR (a company owned and backed by Facebook), the Gear VR has straps to keep the device mounted to your face. Touch controls and buttons add a layer of interactivity. A curated store has a selection of movies, apps and games.

One of the unique examples was Dead Secret, a game that uses tense music and touch controls to help you investigate a murder-mystery.

For now, Gear VR only works with four models of Samsung smartphones (although it will soon work with the newly announced Samsung Galaxy S7 and S7 Edge). Like the Cardboard, it's also limited in the frame of reference it provides — meaning you can look around, but you can't move around in the virtual space.

Oculus Rift, HTC Vive, Playstation VR

The VR experiences that do allow you to move around are a lot more immersive. From disarming a bomb to strolling on the deck of a sunken ship, these are being demonstrated around the world as the height of VR right now.

A woman checks a pair of HTC Vive Virtual Reality goggles during the Gamescom 2015 fair in Cologne, Germany. High-end VR headsets like it offer sharper, smoother moving imagery and better interactivity than budget products like Google Cardboard. (Kai Pfaffenbach/Reuters)

You'll find them in the Oculus Rift, HTC Vive and Sony's PlayStation VR — the products of big money that translates into sharper, smoother moving imagery and better interactivity. These experiences involve more complex headsets, tracking equipment and advanced controllers — all connected to a powerful computer or console.

One of the best examples to me was a surprisingly simple app on the HTC Vive. It's a Google program called Tilt Brush. I could draw in a 3D space and move through the stuff I had drawn, effectively dropping myself into a world I created. The immersion in apps like that can even make you forget the cord sticking out the back of your headset.

Promise vs. Price

For the consumer, that power comes at a price. Take the Oculus Rift: It's coming out at the end of March to customers who paid $600 US ($823) to pre-order it. The HTC Vive just announced pre-orders, starting at $800 US ($1,098). PlayStation VR is expected later this year.

A visitor plays a game on a PlayStation VR at the Paris Games Week. Pricing for the device hasn't been released, but it's not expected to be drastically cheaper than the Oculus Rift. (Benoit Tessier/Reuters)

With the Vive and Rift, there's also a less obvious cost. The computer that runs them has to be powerful. Recently, Oculus announced bundle pricing for a Rift and a computer that can reliably handle it. The lowest bundle was $1,500 US ($2,059). PlayStation VR will require a PS4, a $350+ purchase.

Those prices could keep a lot of people from dipping their toes in right away, but virtual reality doesn't need a critical mass at all levels this year. It needs more people trying out Gear VRs and Cardboards, leaving die-hards and early adopters to take the financial leap into Rifts and Vives. With that, this nascent industry may have a chance to grow — and a skeptical audience may have time to be convinced.


Anand Ram


Anand Ram is a producer for CBC Television's The National. He has previously written for Financial Post and on personal tech and business.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?