European probe dodges SpaceX satellite to avoid collision

A European space probe has performed an evasive manoeuvre to avoid a possible collision with another satellite after its operator, private firm SpaceX, failed to receive a warning message.

SpaceX blames miscommunication for message it would not move Starlink 44 to avoid ESA's Aeolus

A trail of almost 60 Starlink launched atop a Space X Falcon 9 rocket on May 23. One of them was on a possible collision course with an ESA satellite, forcing ESA to move its satellite. (Marco Langbroek)

A European space probe has performed an evasive manoeuvre to avoid a possible collision with another satellite after its operator, private firm SpaceX, failed to receive a warning message.

Engineers decided to move the Aeolus satellite into a higher orbit after being told last month by SpaceX that it had no intention of changing the course of its Starlink 44 satellite, officials at the European Space Agency (ESA) said Tuesday.

SpaceX said what appeared to be a hard-nosed stance was actually the result of a communications error.

The two operators last exchanged messages Aug. 28, when the probability of a collision was far below the threshold for evasive manoeuvre, the California-based company said in a statement.

The U.S. Air Force's 18th Space Control Squadron, which monitors objects in orbit, later raised the probability of a collision to more than 1 in 10,000, requiring an evasive manoeuvre.

"But a bug in our on-call paging system prevented the Starlink operator from seeing the follow-on correspondence on this probability increase," SpaceX said, adding that had the message been seen, it would have co-ordinated with the Europeans to determine who should give way.

The company said it is investigating the issue and plans to implement "corrective actions."

The European Space Agency said the manoeuvre didn't affect operations of Aeolus, which was launched in August 2018 to measure global wind speeds and directions, thereby improving weather forecasts.

No orbital traffic rules

But ESA said the incident, along with the absence of firm traffic rules in orbit, highlighted the need to improve co-ordination among satellite operators.

"Today, this negotiation is done through exchanging emails, an archaic process that is no longer viable as increasing numbers of satellites in space mean more space traffic," said Holger Krag, head of space safety at ESA. The agency is proposing an automated system to deal with collision risk.

A crash could have sprayed thousands of pieces of debris across a wide area, greatly increasing the chances of further collisions between satellites and clouds of space junk.

While satellites have to dodge each other from time to time, "it is really the first time that we had to do it with one of these big constellations," said Klaus Merz of ESA's space debris office.

Starlink 44, which was launched in May, is part of a so-called mega constellation that will grow to thousands of satellites and with which SpaceX plans to provide internet services around the globe.

Merz noted that despite not hearing from SpaceX anymore, at least ESA engineers knew which course Starlink 44 was on and were able to dodge the satellite.

"In the end the key information we needed was there."


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?