Science

Your dog's personality may have little to do with its breed

Research confirms what dog lovers know — every pup is truly an individual. Many of the popular stereotypes about the behaviour of golden retrievers, poodles or schnauzers, for example, aren't supported by science, according to a new study.

Howling, pointing and showing friendliness to human strangers have at least some genetic basis

Elizabeth Kelly plays with her English springer spaniel, Louise, in the Brooklyn borough of New York on April 26. Kelly says Louise is 'friendly, but she's also kind of the queen bee.' A new study has found that many of the popular stereotypes about the behaviour of specific breeds aren't supported by science. (Emma H. Tobin/The Associated Press)

Research confirms what dog lovers know — every pup is unique.

Many of the popular stereotypes about the behaviour of golden retrievers, poodles or schnauzers, for example, aren't supported by science, according to a new study.

"There is a huge amount of behavioural variation in every breed, and at the end of the day, every dog really is an individual," said study co-author and University of Massachusetts geneticist Elinor Karlsson.

She said pet owners love to talk about their dog's personality, as illustrated by some owners at a New York dog park.

Elizabeth Kelly said her English springer spaniel was "friendly, but she's also kind of the queen bee." Suly Ortiz described her yellow Lab as "really calm, lazy and shy."

Suly Ortiz describes her yellow Lab as 'really calm, lazy and shy.' Research confirms what dog lovers know: every pup is truly an individual. (Emma H. Tobin/The Associated Press)

And Rachel Kim's mixed-breed dog is "a lot of different dogs, personality-wise — super independent, really affectionate with me and my husband, but pretty, pretty suspicious of other people, other dogs."

How much does breed predict behaviour?

That kind of enthusiasm from pet owners inspired Karlsson's latest scientific inquiry. She wanted to know to what extent are behavioural patterns inherited — and how much are dog breeds associated with distinctive and predictable behaviours.

The answer: While physical traits such as a greyhound's long legs or a Dalmatian's spots are clearly inherited, breed is not a strong predictor of any individual dog's personality.

The researchers' work, published Thursday in the journal Science, marshals a massive dataset to reach these conclusions — the most ever compiled, said Adam Boyko, a geneticist at Cornell University, who was not involved in the study.

Huskies compete in their group during the 28th international sled dog race near Oberhof, Germany,on Feb. 24, 2018. Some breeds, such as huskies and beagles, may show a greater tendency to howl. But many of these dogs don't, as both the owner survey and genetic data showed. (Jens Meyer/The Associated Press)

Dogs became humanity's best friend more than 14,000 years ago, as the only animal domesticated before the advent of agriculture.

But the concept of dog breeds is much more recent. Around 160 years ago, people began to selectively breed dogs to have certain consistent physical traits, like coat texture and colour and ear shape.

The researchers surveyed more than 18,000 dog owners and analyzed the genomes of about 2,150 of their dogs to look for patterns.

Some behaviours show inheritance, but not strictly along breed lines

They found that some behaviours — such as howling, pointing and showing friendliness to human strangers — do have at least some genetic basis. But that inheritance isn't strictly passed down along breed lines.

For example, they found golden retrievers that don't retrieve, said co-author Kathryn Lord, who studies animal behaviour with Karlsson.

Some breeds, such as huskies and beagles, may show a greater tendency to howl. But many of these dogs don't, as both the owner survey and genetic data showed.

The researchers could find no genetic basis for aggressive behaviours nor a link to specific breeds.

"The correlation between dog behaviour and dog breed is much lower than most expected," said Jeff Kidd, a geneticist at the University of Michigan, who had no role in the research.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?

now