Scientists find bone from Neanderthal-Denisovan 'love child'

Long, long ago, a Neanderthal woman had an intimate encounter with a man so exotic, he might be considered a different species. They had a daughter, scientists have learned through an extremely lucky find.

DNA from ancient hybrid suggests more interbreeding among early humans than previously thought

University of Toronto researcher Bence Viola holds a 3D printed replica of the bone fragment from Denisova cave. The original was ground up for carbon dating and DNA analysis. (Emily Chung/CBC News)

Tens of thousands of years ago in what is now the Altai mountains of Russia, a Neanderthal woman had an intimate encounter with a very exotic man — so exotic that he might even be considered a different species.

He was a Denisovan, another kind of ancient human that, like Neanderthals, once walked among modern humans but is now extinct.

That ancient encounter produced a daughter.

More than 50,000 years later, the discovery of a chip from one of her bones in Siberia's Denisova Cave — and the DNA inside it — has scientists very surprised and excited by the ancient story it tells.

Small amounts of Neanderthal DNA have previously been found in both modern humans and Denisovans (and Denisovan DNA has been found in modern humans), suggesting some, though not much, interbreeding among the groups.

But archaic human fossils are so rare that only half a dozen Denisovan fossils and a few hundred Neanderthal fossils have ever been found.

This bone fragment ('Denisova 11'), seen from different angles, was found in 2012 at Denisova Cave in Russia by Russian archeologists. It came from the daughter of a Neanderthal mother and a Denisovan father. (T. Higham/University of Oxford)

So scientists can't believe their luck with this new discovery.

"It's exciting, because we knew from other research that Neanderthals and Denisovans sometimes must have had kids together," said Viviane Slon, first author of the new study published Wednesday in the journal Nature. "But the fact that we were able to find one of those kids is completely unexpected."

So when Slon first saw the results of the DNA analysis she conducted, she thought something had gone wrong in the lab.

"I was taken aback," she recalled in a Skype interview from Tanzania, where she is travelling.

When she redid the experiment and rechecked the result, there was no doubt — the mitochondrial DNA from the bone fragment, which is inherited only from the mother, was Neanderthal. But the nuclear DNA, which is inherited from both parents, was half Neanderthal, and half Denisovan. The child was a hybrid of a Neanderthal mother and a Denisovan father.

Viviane Slon takes sediment samples in Denisova cave to look for ancient DNA. Slon did the DNA analysis of the bone fragment that showed it was a Neanderthal-Denisovan hybrid. (Courtesy Bence Viola)

Slon, a postdoctoral researcher working at the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology in Germany, shared the results with Bence Viola, an assistant professor of anthropology at the University of Toronto who is in charge of the catalogue of fossils found at Denisova Cave.

At first, he couldn't believe it either.

Only half a dozen Denisovan fossils have ever been found, all at Denisova Cave. And even Neanderthal fossils only number in the hundreds, so scientists were very excited when they found the fossil of a human man with a Neanderthal great-great-great grandparent.

"The likelihood of finding the one who is the love child of a Neanderthal and Denisovan is really even lower," he said. But he was convinced by Slon's analysis.

Not a child

Slon and Svante Paabo, director of the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology, asked Viola if he could figure out how old the hybrid human was when she died. They wondered if she might have had physical problems that would kill a hybrid in infancy or childhood — something that often happens with hybrids between species.

(There is some debate about whether Neanderthals and Denisovans are separate species. They're more genetically different from one another than any two humans alive today, but closer genetically than any gorilla or chimpanzee subspecies.)

Viola compared the thickness of the bone to that of Neanderthals of different ages and concluded that it likely belonged to an adult woman, but possibly an adolescent girl as young as 13 years old.

He thinks the discovery is "unambiguous" evidence that different kinds of ancient humans interbred, and probably more frequently than we thought. But it still leaves unanswered questions.

"How exactly they met is a question," he said. "I'm very curious if they recognized each other as distinct or they just thought, 'Those are kind of weird-looking guys in the next valley.' How did this work culturally?"

An exhibit shows the life of a Neanderthal family in a cave in the new Neanderthal Museum in the northern town of Krapina, Croatia. (Nikola Solic/Reuters)

The chip of bone discovered at Denisova Cave by Russian technologists in 2012 was brown and about as long as an adult's small toe.

It was one of tens of thousands of bone chips, most from ibexes, deer and horses, recovered from the cave using river water and a sieve. It was then screened by researchers at the University of Oxford using a technique that can tell roughly what animal group it was from based on differences in the protein collagen.

The bone chip was flagged as belonging to the human family, so Oxford master's student Samantha Brown brought it to Slon and her colleagues in Leipzig, Germany.

A bone that's been through a lot

Half the bone has since been ground up for radiocarbon dating, which showed it was more than 50,000 years old. The other half was ground up for DNA analysis, said Viola.

"There really is practically nothing left of this, which is a bit of a shame."

He worked from a small, grey plastic replica 3D printed from a micro-CT scan. It's so detailed, though, that you can see textures that suggest how the story ended.

"It looks acid etched. And that is, I think, because it was digested by a hyena," said Viola.

While Denisovans may have lived in Denisova Cave, it appears they didn't bury their dead there, so any bone fragments found inside were likely regurgitated by predators like cave hyenas.

Denisova cave is located in the Altai mountains of Russia. Fossils of Neaderthals, Denisovans, and ancient modern humans have all been found there. (Bence Viola)

Two other tidbits that came out of the analysis of the hybrid woman's DNA were that:

  • Her Neanderthal mother was more closely related to Neanderthals in western Europe than another Neanderthal found in Denisova Cave who lived there some time earlier, suggesting Neanderthals migrated across Eurasia.

  • Her Denisovan father had some Neanderthal ancestry of his own, revealing another interaction between Neanderthals and Denisovans.​

Researchers who weren't involved in the study said they were excited by the results.

Tangled tree of life

"Oh, I thought it was really cool," said Hendrik Poinar, an evolutionary geneticist at McMaster University in Hamilton and director of the school's Ancient DNA Centre.

He said that while humans like to categorize animals into individual "species" that can't interbreed, in nature, such groupings aren't as well defined as people might think, and neither is the path of evolution.

Fossils and genetics show us the tree of life is very tangled and "much messier than we thought," he said.

Fernando Racimo, an assistant professor of population genetics at the University of Copenhagen who does research on the genomes of ancient modern humans, Neanderthals and Denisovans, was also impressed by the discovery.

"It's amazing that we keep getting amazing genomes from the same cave in the middle of Siberia," he said.

Richard Green, an associate professor of biomolecular engineering at the University of California Santa Cruz who studies ancient DNA and human evolutionary history, said he was surprised by the findings given that Neanderthals and Denisovans were quite inbred, implying interbreeding was rare.

Poinar, Racimo and Green all thought the study was well done and convincing, and adds to the evidence that interbreeding among Neanderthals, Denisovans and modern humans may have been more common than previously thought.

"It's basically just saying the same story over and over again," Green said, "that whenever two human groups are living close enough together, they are going to hybridize."

The study was funded by the Max Planck Society, the Max Planck Foundation, the European Research Council and the Russian Science Foundation.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?