Politics

Bringing up the dead: Ukraine searches the battlefields for unidentified remains

Ukrainian authorities say they've sent teams across the country to recover the remains of Russian soldiers killed in battle. Finding them is one problem. Sending them home is another.

From a shallow grave near Kyiv comes the story of a young Russian's life snuffed out by war

Ukrainian troops retrieve Russia's dead soldiers

2 months ago
Duration 2:15
For the last several weeks, an ad hoc team of Ukrainian soldiers has been revisiting the fresh battlefields around Kyiv to gather the dead. Ukraine says it has recovered the remains of roughly 200 Russian soldiers across the country.

Warning: This story contains graphic language and images of human remains

It must have been a cold, lonely, frightening death for Gavril Vanyushev.

The young Russian soldier was killed on the outskirts of Kyiv in a sleepy, forested hamlet about 50 kilometres west of the Ukrainian capital.

Retired schoolteacher Kateryna Karabchuck, 81, said she remembers a wounded Vanyushev wandering into her fenced yard. Her dog had started barking.

The body of an unidentified dead Russian soldier on a refrigerated rail car somewhere in Kyiv. The Ukrainians have collected over 130 dead Russians from local battlefields — remains Moscow has yet to accept for repatriation. (Murray Brewster/CBC News)

The Russian force to which Vanyushev belonged was trying at the time to cut the M06 highway — one of the main roads leading to Lviv in the west — in order to complete an encirclement of Kyiv. His unit was trading blows with Ukrainian forces when he was hit.

The Russians' mission failed. Bleeding, Vanyushev wandered into the winter-scorched village of Zavalivka before collapsing and dying. Many locals say he was left behind by his unit.

Vanyushev was buried in the forest near Karabchuck's house, along a trail that winds past a small lake. His temporary grave, dug by the locals, was marked by a pile of branches and surrounded by a handful of discarded vodka bottles.

"I realized this was somebody's son and I could not sleep at night," Karabchuck said, her hands shaking as spoke to international journalists through a interpreter.

She said she knew nothing about the Russian soldier except that he looked as though he'd come from far away, perhaps from Siberia. Her kind, happy face turned stern as she described the terror of the fighting that raged around her village last winter.

She said she saw a Russian "tank" on one side of the nearby pond, with Ukrainian troops, including territorial defence reservists, on the other side. "They were shooting at one another," she said.

The tank, she said, seemed to lose its way, found itself at the dead end of her street and then left.

Retired teacher Kateryna Karabchuck, 81, remembers a wounded Russian soldier wandering into her fenced yard last February following a battle. She said the soldier later died and was buried in the forest by her neighbours. The Ukrainian military has retrieved the soldier's remains. (Murray Brewster/CBC News)

Vanyushev may have been wounded in that exchange. No one in the village seemed sure. Other than a flash of compassion for his mother, Karabchuck and her husband held little sympathy for the young soldier, who might have been in his early 20s.

"It was our people who buried him because the Russians just left him," she said. "A dog found his body. He died like a dog, so I guess that was his fate."

For the last several weeks, an ad hoc team of Ukrainian soldiers has been revisiting the fresh battlefields around Kyiv to gather the dead. The Ukrainians say they have recovered the remains of roughly 200 Russian soldiers across the country.

On Wednesday, that team visited Zavalivka after receiving a call about the body buried in the forest. The Ukrainian troops were accompanied by a group of international media who went along to document the painstaking exhumation — a very public demonstration of how the country says it is living up to its international obligations.

Col. Volodymyr Lyamzin, the head of Ukraine’s civil-military affairs branch, speaks to the media as troops prepare to exhume the body of a Russian soldier killed in the fighting around Kyiv last winter. (Murray Brewster/CBC News)

"It's not pleasant work, for sure," said Col. Volodymyr Lyamzin, the head of Ukraine's civil-military affairs branch. "No one loves to do this, but they understand it is part of the job."

Most of the time they find themselves exhuming remains from hastily-dug graves, which they photograph extensively and geotag to record the location.

Lyamzin said Vanyushev was found face-down and partly wrapped in blue canvas. His identity papers had been collected by the locals who buried him, he added.

The troops, clad in white hazmat suits, carefully scraped away the damp, dark soil surrounding the body as a light smell of death and peat moss hung around them.

The grave offered possible clues to his fate. The Ukrainians pulled an improvised tourniquet from the ground. They found caked blood near Vanyushev's hip.

Using spades, they carefully cleared the area around the body before carefully lifting it into a white body bag.

The remains of a Russian soldier, believed to be Gavril Vanyushev, are exhumed from a temporary grave near Kyiv on May 11, 2022. He apparently was killed in a battle in late February as Russia attempted to seize the Ukrainian capital. (Murray Brewster/CBC News)

He was carted back to Kyiv to a nondescript railyard and loaded into a grey refrigerated rail car where the Ukrainians have stored the bodies of 136 dead Russian soldiers awaiting repatriation.

The problem, Lyamzin claims, is that Moscow has been reluctant to accept remains collected on Ukrainian battlefields.

"Russia does not seem interested at all," he said, noting that the Geneva Convention has provisions for the exchange of remains.

'We couldn't show them to their mothers'

Only one such swap has taken place in the war to date. Lyamzin said the badly decomposed state of the Ukrainian soldiers' bodies returned home made it impossible to positively identify them.

"We couldn't show them to their mothers," he said through an interpreter. 

At the end of March, Ukraine exchanged six dead Russians for two live prisoners of war.

The government in Kyiv has said it is prepared to keep collecting bodies and wait for them to be exchanged. At some point, it is going to have to consider reinterring the Russians if no one claims them.

Once Vanyushev's body was loaded into the rail car, the Ukrainian troops searched his pockets one last time. They found his bank card and a credit card, which they held up for the cameras.

It was a brief glimpse of an ordinary life extinguished by a brutal war, set against a macabre backdrop of a growing pile of white body bags.

Lyamzin took in the whole scene with an indifferent eye.

"I don't have any pity for them because they come to my country, they killed the kids and rape our women," he said.

"They have their brains, so they knew what they [were doing]. They were aware [of what they were] doing — a crime. So, I cannot have any pity [for] them."

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Murray Brewster

Senior reporter, defence and security

Murray Brewster is senior defence writer for CBC News, based in Ottawa. He has covered the Canadian military and foreign policy from Parliament Hill for over a decade. Among other assignments, he spent a total of 15 months on the ground covering the Afghan war for The Canadian Press. Prior to that, he covered defence issues and politics for CP in Nova Scotia for 11 years and was bureau chief for Standard Broadcast News in Ottawa.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?

now